logo
episode-header-image
May 2018
52m 39s

S2 E2: The Route

The New Yorker
About this episode

The case against Curtis Flowers relies heavily on three threads of evidence: the route he allegedly walked the morning of the murders, the gun that investigators believe he used, and the people he supposedly confessed to in jail. In this episode, we meet the witnesses who said they saw Flowers walking through downtown Winona, Mississippi, the morning of the murders. Some of their stories now waver on key details. 


Up next
Mar 2025
From The New Yorker Radio Hour: Rachel Aviv on Alice Munro’s Family Secrets
Alice Munro, a winner of the Nobel Prize in Literature, was perhaps the most acclaimed short-story writer of our time. After her death, last year, her youngest daughter, Andrea Skinner, revealed that Munro’s partner, Gerald Fremlin, had sexually abused her starting when she was n ... Show More
32m 13s
Nov 2024
Donald Trump, Pete Hegseth, and the Future of American War-Crimes Prosecutions
Donald Trump’s selection of Pete Hegseth for Secretary of Defense caught the attention of the In the Dark team. Hegseth, formerly a weekend co-host of “Fox & Friends,” is a longtime supporter of accused American war criminals, and has called Eddie Gallagher, the Navy SEAL who was ... Show More
25m 34s
Nov 2024
Presenting “Sold a Story”
In the Dark presents the first episode of “Sold a Story,” an award-winning investigative podcast that is changing how children are taught to read. In this episode, “The Problem,” a mother watches her son's first-grade lessons during Zoom school and discovers with dismay that he c ... Show More
32m 15s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2017
S1 E09: A Deal With the Devil
One night in 1982, a 20-year-old man is senselessly murdered at an abandoned gas station. A mobster is taken into witness protection after he pins the murder on his boss. This brutal crime will push three wiseguys out of the mafia in very different ways. For a full list of credit ... Show More
35m 13s
Aug 2023
The Video Strangler Pt. 2
Like many serial killers, Maury Travis became over-confident. In the summer of 2002, after reading a story in the newspaper about one of his victims, he mailed a letter to the local newspaper offering them information on the location of another. He was careful not to leave any fi ... Show More
48m 39s
Jan 2022
The Brides in the Bath Murders Pt. 2
In 1915, Scotland Yard detective Arthur Neil had three deceased brides, one suspect, and tons of circumstantial evidence. But he needed something more concrete. Luckily for him, that something walked right through the door. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.c ... Show More
45m 49s
Feb 2020
S7E5: Twisted Love: Bringing A Murderer To Justice
Houston police say without Mark Castellano’s full confession, they had nothing to keep him in custody and may never have found the body of his ex-girlfriend, Michelle Warner. This is the final episode of Dr. Phil’s true crime podcast, “Twisted Love: Bringing A Murderer To Justice ... Show More
44m 56s
Jan 2020
S7E4: Twisted Love: Bringing A Murderer To Justice EP4
Episode 4 of the podcast “Twisted Love: Bringing A Murderer To Justice,” Mystery And Murder: Analysis By Dr. Phil, Mark Castellano’s trial begins after he confesses to killing his ex, Michelle Warner. Michelle’s family honors her memory. See omnystudio.com/policies/listener for p ... Show More
39m 36s
Aug 2019
S3E4: Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? Mystery and Murder: Analysis By Dr. Phil
Amber Hilberling was charged with second-degree murder in the March 2013 death of her husband, Josh Hilberling, despite her insistence that she acted in self-defense when, during an argument, she pushed him and he fell to his death out a window of their high rise apartment in Tul ... Show More
49m 40s
Jan 2023
The Marlborough Mystery Pt. 2
Based on witness testimony, authorities believed that Scott Watson killed Olivia Hope and Ben Smart. The jury agreed and took less than 24 hours to convict him. But since his incarceration, several witnesses have recanted their testimony, saying they were pressured by police. Lea ... Show More
48m 24s
Sep 2020
How To Get Away With Murder
One day in 1987, a young girl in a small town in upstate New York disappeared and then turned up dead. For seven years her murder went unsolved, until police finally caught the killer, a local man whom everyone knew. The town would never be the same, according to our listener Jen ... Show More
33m 54s
Aug 2019
S3E3: Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil
The State of Oklahoma arrested Amber Hilberling and charged the pregnant 19-year-old with second-degree murder, despite her insistence that she only pushed her husband in self-defense and never meant for him to fall out of the window to his death. In episode 3 of Beautiful Victim ... Show More
47m 45s