logo
episode-header-image
Nov 18
42m 42s

The State of Chocolate Is Dark

Slate Podcasts

About this episode

In early 2026, Brad Reese, the grandson of the inventor of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, posted a scathing letter accusing Hershey of altering the beloved candy’s recipe and defiling his family’s legacy. The screed went viral, with many people chiming in that they, too, were convinced that all sorts of chocolates taste worse now than they did before. Ancient civilizations cultivated chocolate for ceremonial rites—its Latin name even means “food of the gods.” It has figured in trade between empires, been a symbol of status, even provided sustenance in war. Chocolate, and how we consume it, has always been changing. So why is it suddenly unrecognizable?

Rachel Handler, a writer at New York Magazine, decided to investigate if chocolate truly has changed—and found the answer to be darker than expected, wrapped up in questions of language, taste, and memory amid a changing world. In this episode, you’ll also hear from Clay Gordon, a chocolate expert and critic at TheChocolateLife.

This episode was written by Willa Paskin and Evan Chung, our supervising producer, and produced by Alesandra Tejeda. Decoder Ring is also produced by Max Freedman. Merritt Jacob is Senior Technical Director.

If you have any cultural mysteries you want us to decode, email us at DecoderRing@slate.com or leave a message on our hotline at (347) 460-7281.

Get more of Decoder Ring with Slate Plus! Join for exclusive bonus episodes of Decoder Ring and ad-free listening on all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe from the Decoder Ring show page on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/decoderplus for access wherever you listen.

Need to set up your Slate Plus feed? If you subscribed through Slate.com, check out our FAQ at slate.com/podcastfaqs for easy instructions. Members subscribed via Apple Podcasts get automatic access—no setup required.


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next

Nov 4
Presenting: The Sporkful | Does The World Need A Better Tomato?
In New Jersey, the tomato is king. Almost a century ago, a scientist at Rutgers University developed a variety that became the tomato that lined grocery store shelves for decades. Now, Rutgers scientists are at it again—they’ve invented a new grape tomato called Scarlet Sunrise. ... 
37m 48s
Oct 29
The Spooky Saga of the Icelandic Dracula
Since Bram Stoker’s Dracula was first published in 1897 it has inspired hundreds, if not thousands, of other fictional vampires. But none are quite as strange as that found in the frigid climes of Iceland. There, just a few years after Dracula was first printed, emerged a so-call ... 
51m 9s

Recommended Episodes

Mar 2022
Ridiculous History Presents: A History of "Adult" Toys, Part 1
<p>While it's a taboo subject in the modern day, it turns out people have been improvising ways to pleasure themselves since, well, the dawn of history. In this week's two-part takeover episode, Ben and Noel join Eli and Diana Banks, real-life spouses and creators of the hit podc ... 
56m 35s
Nov 2021
The Whorigin Story
In this episode, the ladies investigate the history of casual sex and hookup culture. Digressions include the questionable ethics of the Mii plaza, the atrocities of Lamb (2021), and more of your hilarious sex stories. Watch the video episode <a href= "patreon.com/binchtopia" rel ... 
1h 23m
Mar 2022
Ridiculous History Presents: A History of "Adult" Toys, Part 2
<p>While it's a taboo subject in the modern day, it turns out people have been improvising ways to pleasure themselves since, well, the dawn of history. In the second part of this week's two-part takeover episode, Ben and Noel join Eli and Diana Banks, real-life spouses and creat ... 
1h 3m
Aug 2022
49: Sex Toys: Sinful or Medicinal?!?!
Welcome to the Dark History podcast. Sex has been a part of humanity since the dawn of time. Do you know what else has been around for a while? Sex Toys. Oh yeah. There’s proof of dildos as far back as 30,000 BCE. But how did it go from phallic rocks to the multi-million dollar s ... 
45m 19s
Jul 2023
Sexual Wellness, Sex Toys and Self-Love
Content warning: This episode is created for adult audiences only.  Chiquis has a spicy conversation with sexologist Rebecca Alavarez Story. The hot topics range from bedroom safety and faking orgasms to sex toys and anal sex. Rebecca also tells us how she first became interested ... 
35m 42s
Jul 2023
95: Sizzling Secrets of Sex Toys | Dark History with Bailey Sarian
Welcome to the Dark History podcast! Sex! It's been around since the beginning of our existence. But something else has been around for thousands of years too- sex TOYS. Yes, you heard it right, we have evidence of dildos dating as far back as 30,000 BCE. Get ready to find out th ... 
44m 42s
Oct 2021
What’s the Buzz?
tail spinning
10m 12s
May 2022
Sex Toys
Hidden in bedside tables or proudly displayed on mantelpieces, wherever you keep them (if you do), sex toys have come a long way since the first phallic-shaped object was found around 30,000 years ago.But before they were arriving through our post boxes in unmarked, tracked packa ... 
43m 6s
Mar 2023
The Rock Hard History of the Dildo
Grab this episode with both hands and hear how the dildo has been used and revered around the world for almost as long as humans have existed. This now-common bedroom accessory has its roots in ancient cultures, religion, spirituality and sexuality across all of history,... and i ... 
38m 33s