logo
episode-header-image
Nov 13
46m 4s

Robert Warren: Do Mining Pools Actually ...

STEPHAN LIVERA

About this episode

Robert Warren, Head of Comms at Elektron Energy, says Bitcoin mining pools do centralize something, but it is mainly control of block templates, not the power to reorg the chain. He treats FPPS as an insurance product: pools take variance and charge a fee, and a miner who doesn't like the deal can switch to a fallback pool almost immediately.

Stephan and Rob also walk through AntPool white-labeling, why a run of Foundry or SpiderPool blocks is usually just variance, why listed miners are leasing sites to AI and HPC, and why Elektron is staying bitcoin-first. Rob argues network security barely changes as public hashrate rotates to private operators, and that hashrate is still going up and to the right.

Timestamps

00:00 Intro

00:31 Do Mining Pools Threaten Bitcoin?

04:20 On-Chain Data Hides Miner Incentives

06:40 Why Miners Wouldn't Follow BIP 110

08:06 Miners Don't Control Hashrate's Value

10:56 If a Few Pools Find Most Blocks?

12:51 FPPS Is an Insurance Product

17:14 AntPool, White Labels, and Censorship

21:36 Censorship and Other Risks

22:36 Why Selfish Mining Stays Theoretical

24:51 A Run of Blocks Isn't Centralization

29:01 Can Miners Fix Pool Centralization?

29:17 DATUM

33:13 MARA, Ocean, and DMND on Templates

34:08 Why Public Miners Are Pivoting to AI

35:45 Why Elektron Is Staying Bitcoin-First

37:50 What Happens to Hashrate and Security?

39:36 A Rotation to Private Miners?

42:47 Will Hashrate Be Higher in 10 Years?

44:47 Hashrate Heating and Home Miners

Show notes

Links:

Robert Warren on X: https://x.com/BikesandBitcoin

Elektron Energy on X: https://x.com/ElektronEnergy

Profit Maximization and Protocol Risk (Elektron thread): https://x.com/ElektronEnergy/status/2117293466338095389

Elektron Energy: https://elektronenergy.io


Up next

Nov 19
Why USDT Is Heading Back to Bitcoin Through RGB | Viktor Ihnatiuk SLP790
Viktor Ihnatiuk of Utexo explains how his team plans to bring USDT back to Bitcoin using RGB. He argues that businesses will come first, drawn by privacy, and that RGB's client-side validation lets asset transfers happen with little on-chain data.Stephan Livera and Viktor cover h ... 
45m 34s
Nov 11
Joe Burnett: Your Wealth Is Melting in the Age of AI | SLP788
Joe Burnett, VP of Bitcoin Strategy at Strive, argues that wealth stored in dollars, gold, houses and even mega-cap stocks is melting: technology can produce more of those things, so they lose value when measured in bitcoin. He says AI speeds that process up by destroying moats, ... 
54m 3s

Recommended Episodes

Nov 2021
Episode 119: Green loans
Join Mark Randall and Andrea Pryde as they discuss the accounting challenges associated with so-called ‘green loans’ 
19m 49s
Nov 2021
188 - Lessons from Oslo: How to create green innovation
Following last week’s conversations on climate change we wanted to talk about the real, tangible ways that we can create this better, greener future through public initiatives. The race to 2030 is on - and the finish line is closer than we might think!<hr><p style='color:grey; fo ... 
32m 49s
Apr 2023
Media Shakeups + Who’s Behind the Climate Crisis — with Bill McKibben
Bill McKibben, a contributing writer to The New Yorker and the Schumann Distinguished Scholar in environmental studies at Middlebury College, joins Scott to discuss the state of climate change, including the problem of burning fossil fuels and potential solutions. Follow Bill on ... 
47m 59s
Jan 2024
The Chris Chatman Do-Over - 2. Environment
Environmental activist The Green Team (Joy and Coy Pfeffer) join the Chatman crew to debate diva cups, dryer balls, and climate change. Starring Ike Barinholtz, Neil Casey, Lisa Gilroy, Craig Cackowski, and Carla Cackowski. 
24m 43s
May 2023
Is Biomass Green
<p>In the world of economics, it’s vital to understand energy. Energy is the economy. The economy and real estate are connected through multiple threads.</p> <p>The ESG movement of environmental sustainability and governance has its heart in the right place. The problem is the so ... 
6m 52s