logo
episode-header-image
Oct 21
56m 34s

How Accurate Is the Movie Lincoln? Harol...

Scratch Track Productions
About this episode

How accurate is Steven Spielberg's Lincoln? And what did the movie get wrong?

Listener Elijah wants to know how closely the 2012 film starring Daniel Day-Lewis matches the real history of Abraham Lincoln—and there may be no better person to answer than Harold Holzer, one of America's leading Lincoln historians and the film's principal historical advisor.

Harold takes Bob Crawford behind the scenes of Lincoln, explaining what the movie gets remarkably right—and where Hollywood took some liberties. He reveals how the filmmakers approached Lincoln's voice, personality, storytelling, political maneuvering, and relationship with the people around him.

The conversation goes deep into the dramatic struggle to pass the 13th Amendment, including Lincoln's efforts to win Democratic votes, his secret meeting with Confederate peace commissioners, and the complicated politics surrounding emancipation. Harold also weighs in on the movie's portrayals of Thaddeus Stevens, Mary Todd Lincoln, Edwin Stanton, and Lincoln himself.

And then there's the historical detail Harold warned screenwriter Tony Kushner about—one that Spielberg decided was simply too dramatically effective to change.

If you love Lincoln, Abraham Lincoln, the Civil War, historical movies, or the question of where Hollywood ends and history begins, this episode is for you.

Featuring Harold Holzer, Lincoln historian, author, and historical advisor to Steven Spielberg's Lincoln.

Up next
Oct 28
America's Other WWII Internment Camps
During World War II, the United States incarcerated more than 110,000 people of Japanese ancestry. But Japanese Americans weren't the only people imprisoned, relocated, or restricted as suspected "enemy aliens." Thousands of German and Italian immigrants—and some of their America ... Show More
40m 39s
Oct 14
Do We Really Need Political Parties?
America's founders feared political parties—and then almost immediately began creating them. So are parties an unfortunate obstacle to democracy, or are they the reason democracy works at all? Georgetown University political scientist Hans Noel joins Bob Crawford to explain why t ... Show More
43m 15s
Oct 7
Tuscarora Jack: Patriot or Villain?
Listener Laura is descended from Colonel John Barnwell—better known as "Tuscarora Jack"—but she struggles with her ancestor's brutal actions during the Tuscarora War. Why is Barnwell still celebrated as a hero in South Carolina? Bob speaks with author and fellow Barnwell descenda ... Show More
32m 15s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2021
Crusader for the Constitution
The Constitution originally intended to protect liberty, has become the tool by which the government increases its powers and limits freedoms. Today’s guest says, “The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing people he doesn’t exist; The greatest trick the system ever ... Show More
39m 22s
Jun 2024
The Constitution is Amazing (and Ridiculous), Part One: A Troubled, Ambitious Origin Story
Something like 60% of Americans have never fully read the US Constitution. How did such a short document become one of the most important pieces of writing in human history -- and why are some parts of it arguably ridiculous? Ben, Noel and Max welcome returning guest AJ Jacobs, a ... Show More
33m 54s
Apr 2022
US vs: Constitutions
The United States Constitution gets a lot of credit for being the first of its kind. The progenitor of democratic constitution making. The spark that started a global fire. Is that the long and short of it, or is there more to the story? Linda Colley, author of The Gun, The Ship ... Show More
32m 57s
Mar 2022
The Constitution and the Bill of Rights
Long before we could decide and insist upon what they mean to us, a handful of powerful men had to put pen to paper. We're revisiting two episodes from our Foundational Documents series: The Constitution and The Bill of Rights. This is the story of how these now-indispensable doc ... Show More
1h 3m
Jan 2024
The Pursuit of Happiness with Jeffrey Rosen
We’ve heard it before: Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. But what did the nation’s Founders mean when they identified “the pursuit of happiness” as an unalienable right? And what role does moral philosophy play in understanding the virtues that accompany the pursuit of ... Show More
39m 18s
Mar 2024
Amending the Constitution
The process is pretty straightforward. Plenty of people want to make some change. And yet? We've only done it 27 times. So what does it take to amend the U.S. Constitution and why does it barely ever happen? Robinson Woodward Burns, Associate Professor of Political Science at How ... Show More
21m 40s
Aug 2025
We the People: Succession of Power
The 25th amendment. A few years before JFK was shot, an idealistic young lawyer set out on a mission to convince people something essential was missing from the Constitution: clear instructions for what should happen if a U.S. president was no longer able to serve. On this episod ... Show More
47m 31s
Oct 2025
A Brief Overview of the U.S. Presidency
<p>What exactly is the job of the U.S. president? Dr. Roy traces the presidency from its constitutional origins through major turning points in U.S. history, exploring how each era redefined executive authority. He discusses the balance between leadership and restraint, the rise ... Show More
1h 56m