logo
episode-header-image
Yesterday
30m 58s

Killer Thriller: Criminal Minds Star Kir...

iHeartPodcasts
About this episode

An Amish husband secretly living as "Amish Stud." Multiple affairs. A wife who never saw it coming.

Kirsten Vangsness joins Elisa Donovan to explore the shocking true story behind Amish Stud, revealing how charm, loneliness, and manipulation can lead someone to do the unthinkable.

Follow Kirsten on Instagram: @kirstenvangsness

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Up next
Yesterday
HIV Positive “Dope-Smoking Pedophile Preacher” Facing Charges After Infecting Man And Raping Teen
Florida officials are investigating whether there are other victims out there, after they charged a local pastor with dozens of charges they say he confessed to committing. 42-year-old Timothy Chaneyfield was the pastor of a local baptist church and also worked in the Polk County ... Show More
17m 10s
Yesterday
Montauk Mystery UPDATE: Martha Nolan Family Claims Yacht Owner Caused Her Death, Plans $50 Million Lawsuit
It’s been exactly one year since 33-year-old fashion designer Martha Nolan was found dead on a yacht in Montauk and there is still no official cause of death and no formal persons of interest named. Nolan’s family believes they know who is responsible for her death, and are plani ... Show More
21m 35s
Yesterday
Killer Mom Trial: Nanny Says Lindsay Clancy Was “A Wonderful Mom”; Fireworks Between Defense And Prosecution
It was a shortened day of testimony, but it was a powerful day in court. The prosecution called five witnesses to the stand, including several more medical and scientific experts, one of whom evoked a fiery exchange between Lindsay Clancy’s defense attorney and prosecutors. The s ... Show More
20m 17s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2025
The Damage Is Done
Aubrey O’Day was one of the first to speak out against Sean “Diddy” Combs — and she won’t be the last.In this raw and deeply personal episode, Aubrey sits down with CNN’s Elizabeth Wagmeister, the journalist who helped bring the Cassie surveillance footage to light. Together, the ... Show More
30m 47s
Mar 2019
The Way of the Warrior [6]
A new witness emerges...with a shocking accusation. 
31m 38s
Jun 2025
The Jane Doe Dilemma
Amy, T.J, and Aubrey O’Day explore the layered testimony of Jane Doe — with one foot planted in survivor advocacy, and the other stepping into the uncomfortable complexities of testimony that doesn’t fit neatly into one box. While abuse is always the abuser’s fault, Jane’s story ... Show More
50m 24s
Oct 2024
True Crime Junkies with Marcia Clark
<p>In 1995, she was a household name when she served as lead prosecutor during O.J. Simpson's Los Angeles trial. Today, Amy and T.J. are turning the tables asking her the hard hitting crime questions you want to know.</p> <p>Marcia Clark reveals why Diddy will have an uphill batt ... Show More
26m 56s
Jul 2025
The Jury Is Out…
While the jury deliberates, Aubrey is left wondering whether or not they took the bait. From the tired “she loved the freak offs” defense, to categorizing Cassie as someone who was ‘All About the Benjamins,’ they continued the victim-blaming during closing arguments. But hear wha ... Show More
37m 22s
Feb 2024
Turnabout Is Fair Play
Now Amy Robach has T.J. Holmes under the microscope. In this in depth sit down with Amy, T.J. is now the subject, opens up, and reveals the truth. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
42m 34s
Jan 2017
Case Evidence 01.09.17
Take a deeper look at the evidence as experts discuss new developments in the case. Today we have a special guest, the hosts of another investigative podcast called Accused. Amber and Amanda weigh in on Payne's investigation. 
17m 25s
Oct 2022
Introducing: True Crime Reality
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
1 m
Mar 2022
What Happened To Sandy Beal — TRAILER
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
3m 7s
Aug 2023
Introducing: The Idaho Massacre
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
1m 38s
Listen to millions of songs and podcasts on Anghami