logo
episode-header-image
May 8
49m 43s

Gayle McCaffrey

SARAH TURNEY
About this episode
In March 2012, 36-year-old Gayle McCaffrey vanished from the Charleston, South Carolina home she shared with her husband, Robert McCaffrey. At first, there were signs that Gayle may have left on her own but as investigators looked closer, the story became far more complicated. More than a decade later, Gayle has never been found, and the questions surround ... Show More
Up next
Yesterday
Marjorie West
On Mother’s Day in 1938, 4-year-old Marjorie West was picking wildflowers with her sister in the Allegheny Forest when she vanished. Within minutes, her family was searching. Within hours, hundreds of people were combing the woods. And within days, thousands of volunteers, law en ... Show More
49m 18s
Apr 30
Update: Lisa McBride
When 27-year-old Lisa McBride disappeared in June of 1990, she was reported missing within hours. Her family was immediately alarmed. Police quickly believed they were looking at foul play. A 17-member task force was formed. Her family offered a massive reward. Thousands of flyer ... Show More
37m 51s
Apr 24
The Fisher Family
In April 2001, first responders were called to the scene of an explosion and house fire at the Fisher family home in Scottsdale, Arizona. But as investigators started piecing together what happened, it became clear they were dealing with a lot than property damage or arson. It wa ... Show More
57m 49s
Recommended Episodes
Sep 2022
Episode 79 | A MACABRE MURDER IN BALI | Family Vacation Turns Deadly
Send us Fan MailThis is the macbre story of a weathly mother, Sheila von Wiese, her spoiled and deeply troubled daughter, Heather Mack, and what was meant to be a peaceful mother/daughter vacation in paradise that ended in a grizly murder in Bali. Heather Mack was a problem child ... Show More
22m 54s
Aug 2018
The Female Of The Species
<p>Two tales from years gone by this week on The True Crime Enthusiast Podcast, that highlight just how obsessions can grow, and how dangerous and tragic they can sometimes become....</p><p>Music used in this episode: <strong>"Peaceful Mind"</strong> by <strong>Borrtex</strong></ ... Show More
1h 3m
Apr 2022
Episode 59 | KARLA AND PAUL - THE BEAUTIFUL SERIAL KILLER COUPLE
Send us Fan MailIn this podcast we're going to dig in to the disturbing story of Karla Homolka and her then husband Paul Bernardo. Back in the early '90s the two met, married and then went on a spree of abduction, rape and murder of teenage girls, one of whom was Homolka's own si ... Show More
30m 21s
Jan 2019
The Grady Babies Kidnappings, Part 5
This episode explores the psychology and motivations of infant abductors, and expands to discuss both Grady cases and others in our nation. Fetal abduction is discussed, so listener discretion advised. Thanks to forensic psychologist Dr. Jenny Johnson and NCMEC's Angeline Hartman ... Show More
51m 9s
Mar 2025
Side Stories: Casey Anthony, Legal Advocate
<p>Henry and Eddie bring you this week's biggest stories and true-crime news, starting with Casey Anthony's social media re-emergence as a "Legal Advocate". Then, the mysterious deaths of Gene Hackman & Betsy Arakawa, Pope Death Watch 2025, 17-year-old serial killer Antonio Reyes ... Show More
1h 22m
Dec 2018
The Grady Babies Kidnappings, Part 4
Episode four details kidnappings that took place in 1989 and 1993; one of the infants is still missing today. Bibliography for this episode available on website. For more information, support, and resources for persons affected by mental illness, visit https://www.nami.org. Pre o ... Show More
38m 48s
Oct 2022
Episode 80 | Insanity Plea saves 'Werewolf Killer' from Life in Prison (and other INSANE stories)
Send us Fan MailBack in 2018 Brad Jackson was brutally murdered by a man he didn't know. The man, Pankaj Bhasin (aka the Werewolf Killer) suffered a complete mental derailing and attacked and killed Jackson because he thought he was turning into a werewolf. It's a shocking story ... Show More
21m 18s
Nov 2022
Episode 83 | REPORTER MURDERED ON LIVE TV by Disgruntled Co-Worker
Send us Fan MailIn this podcast we're going to dig into the background on a disturbing murder on live television that took place on the morning of August 26, 2015. News reporter Alison Parker and photojournalist Adam Ward, both employees of CBS affiliate WDBJ in Roanoke, Virginia ... Show More
18m 58s
Jun 2022
The Haunted Farmhouse (ft. Shelby Scott) – Ep. 29
Stories in this episode:- Having a Drink with a Dead Man, by Leti - David's Shadow, by Rachel- My Abduction Story, by emodrakefan- 200 Year Old Haunted Farmhouse, by ctenc001- The Red Light, by Tanu - My Stories, by AshleyBe sure to check out Shelby Scott's podcast at scareyoutos ... Show More
49m 58s
Listen to millions of songs and podcasts on Anghami