In this episode of All Things Policy, Brigadier Anil Rahman and Air Marshal P.D. Joseph are joined by Dr. Kelly Grieco, Senior Fellow at the Stimson Center in Washington D.C., to assess whether U.S. air operations in the Iran conflict constitute a coherent theory of limited war. Drawing on Thomas Schelling's coercion framework, the episode asks whether air power alone can compel a regime fighting for survival to yield. Dr. Grieco argues that the initial U.S. aim of regime change through aerial decapitation collapsed within 72 hours, giving way to intermediate military objectives targeting Iran's Navy, ballistic missiles, and drones with no defined political end state. Iran's war of disruption -- Strait of Hormuz closures and drone attacks on Gulf states hosting U.S. forces -- has proven more strategically decisive than the American-Israeli war of destruction. Air Marshal Joseph identifies U.S. casualty aversion and the sidelining of joint operations as structural limits that Iran, fighting for regime survival, has fully exploited. The episode surfaces a pattern repeated from Vietnam to Iraq: tactical air dominance that cannot convert into strategic leverage. As China draws lessons from U.S. base vulnerabilities and low-altitude air denial over the Strait, the episode asks whether American over-reliance on air primacy now actively undermines deterrence in the Indo-Pacific.
Are you passionate about shaping India's future? Keen to find solutions for India's most pressing challenges? Look no further than Takshashila's Post Graduate Programme in Public Policy. This 48-weekend programme will equip you with the knowledge, skills, and network needed to pivot to a meaningful career in public policy. Apply at school.takshashila.org.in/pgp by June 1st. The programme begins by June 20th. Hope to see you there!
All Things Policy is a daily podcast on public policy brought to you by the Takshashila Institution, Bengaluru.Find out more on our research and other work here: https://takshashila.org.in/research-areas