The Hall of Fame—and of Shame—of Oscars ...

On this episode of Critics at Large, with the ninety-eighth Academy Awards just around the corner, Vinson Cunningham, Naomi Fry, and Alexandra Schwartz are joined by their fellow staff writer Michael Schulman to take stock of Oscars season. They discuss the biggest races and consider whether the year’s Best Picture nominees—many of them both critical and commercial successes—might represent a return to the bygone era of “grownup movies.” At the center of all this pageantry is the host: a notoriously tricky role for even the most seasoned performers. Together, the critics revisit the highs and lows of Oscars hosting history, from the long tenure of Bob Hope to the golden age of Billy Crystal. These m.c.s’ success hinges on their ability to walk a fine line, embodying the celebratory spirit of the evening while also poking fun at its absurdity. “It’s about that insider-outsider aspect. You are the court jester,” Schwartz says. “Are you really wanting to be vizier to the king, or are you O.K. in that jester role?” Read, watch, and listen with the critics: “Oscar Wars,” by Michael Schulman “Marty Supreme” (2025) “Sinners (2025) “The Secret Agent” (2025) “One Battle After Another” (2025) “‘Come to Brazil?’ The Oscars Just Might,” by Michael Schulman (The New Yorker) “Sentimental Value” (2025) “The Mastermind” (2025) “Peter Hujar’s Day” (2025) Billy Crystal’s opening monologue for the 1990 Oscars Chris Rock’s opening monologue for the 2005 Oscars Ricky Gervais’s opening monologue for the 2020 Golden Globes Nikki Glaser’s opening monologue for the 2026 Golden Globes New episodes drop every Thursday. Follow Critics at Large wherever you get your podcasts. Critics at Large is a weekly discussion from The New Yorker which explores the latest trends in books, television, film, and more. Join us every Thursday as we make unexpected connections between classic texts and pop culture.