On September 4, 1998, eight-year-old Shy’Kemmia Pate disappeared from her neighborhood in Unadilla, Georgia. She was last seen on a quiet Friday night, just steps from her home, as summer came to an end. By the time an official search began, the most critical hours were already gone.
What followed was an investigation shaped by delays, limited timelines, an ... Show More
Jan 21
MURDERED: The Murder Of Zion Foster
In January of 2022, 17-year-old Zion Foster left her home in Eastpointe, Michigan, and never returned. What began as a desperate search for a missing teenager slowly became something else entirely. As police worked to retrace Zion’s final movements, her family pushed for answers, ... Show More
45m 46s
Jan 14
MURDERED: Three Women Murdered In East Cleveland
Between the fall of 2012 and the summer of 2013, three women disappeared from Cleveland under very different circumstances. Shetisha Sheeley, Angela Deskins, and Shirellda Terry were not reported missing in the same way, and their cases were never linked while they were still ali ... Show More
42m 10s
Jan 12
AFTERTHOUGHTS: Samira Watkins
In this Afterthoughts episode, we unpack the case of Samira Watkins and talk through what stayed with us after telling her story. From the dangers of trusting the “safe” option, to the weight of circumstantial evidence, to the devastating impact Samira’s loss had on her family — ... Show More
48m 50s
Aug 2024
231. What Happened to Maddi Kingsbury?
In this episode, Payton and Garrett explore the recent case of Maddi Kingsbury. When Maddie suddenly disappears, her friends and family launch a desperate search. However, suspicions arise when her boyfriend begins behaving strangely, prompting the police to dig deeper for answer ... Show More
47m 21s