logo
episode-header-image
Nov 12
1h 8m

Georgia Hardstark - The Horrors Persist ...

Katie Maloney, Dayna Kathan
About this episode

Hello to our lovely coven, happy Wednesday! We are thrilled, honored, gooped and gagged, because our guest today is THE Georgia Hardstark from My Favorite Murder! The trio dive into the origins of MFM (including Karen's intro song), share their own spooky experiences, and of course, chat about all of your favorite true crime cases. Georgia talks about working with Karen Kilgariff, her husband Vince and their love story, and touches on the wildest cold cases like the Yogurt Shop Murders and the Idaho 4. Basically, this is a Disrespectfully x MFM dream collab that you do NOT want to miss! XO

In need of something cute and cozy for the fall? Get yourself or whoever's on your daddy list a tee, hoodie, or beanie from our store! Please support our show and show off your love for Disrespectfully by repping our official gear :) K Love ya bye!

00:00 - We are hungover :)
00:50 - Hi Georgia!
01:50 - Starting My Favorite Murder and our own Scary Heauxmetowns
06:30 - Monster Series and True Crime Shows
09:25 - Green River Killer
11:20 - Ann Rule and Ted Bundy
13:25 - Quince
14:50 - Mint Mobile
16:00 - Georgia and Vince
20:00 - Oasis and Casa Vega
21:50 - Starting and Maintaining MFM with Karen
24:40 - Horror Movies and Paranormal Experiences
27:40 - Karen making the MFM Intro song
29:10 - Cases we love - Serial
32:40 - Cases we love - Karen Reed
34:10 - Cases we love - Idaho 4
38:40 - The Ted Bundy of the Valley
41:20 - Cases we love - Jonbenet Ramsey
43:50 - Cases we love - The Golden State Killer
45:45 - Cases we love - Amy Lynn Bradley
47:10 - Perelel
48:50 - Cold Cases - Yogurt Shop Murders
50:35 - Cases we love - Amanda Knox
52:50 - Catfished Documentary
55:30 - Different Flavors of Parenting
1:00:00 - Colin Farrell and the Illuminati
1:03:25 - MFM Touring, Live Shows, and Closing Thoughts

Thank you to our sponsors!

Quince: Go to https://Quince.com/disrespectfully for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns

Mint Mobile: Get premium wireless for $15 a month at https://MintMobile.com/DISRESPECTFULLY

Perelel: Exclusive for our listeners, new customers can enjoy 20% off their first order with code DISRESPECTFULLY at https://perelelhealth.com

Connect with the Coven!

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1930451457469874
Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/disrespectfullypod/

Listen to us on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/disrespectfully/id1516710301
Listen to us on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0J6DW1KeDX6SpoVEuQpl7z?si=c35995a56b8d4038            

Follow us on Social!

Disrespectfully Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/disrespectfullypod
Disrespectfully Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@disrespectfullypod
Katie Maloney Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/musickillskate
Dayna Kathan Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/daynakathan
Leah Glouberman Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/leahgsilberstein
Allison Klemes Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allisonklemes/

Buy our merch!
https://disrespectfullypod.com/

Disrespectfully is an Envy Media Production.

Up next
Nov 21
Third Eye Traumatized | WWDD/Heauxmetown Heroes w/ Katie Maloney & Dayna Kathan
<p dir="ltr">Hello to our lovely coven, happy Friday! Today we get knee deep in all of your crazy Heauxmetown Hero tales, and dive into the nitty gritty for WWDD. </p> <p dir="ltr">In need of something cute and cool for the summer? Get yourself or whoever's on your daddy list a t ... Show More
1h 8m
Nov 19
Glitch in the Matrix | Disrespectfully w/ Katie Maloney & Dayna Kathan
<p dir="ltr">Hello to our lovely coven, happy Wednesday! Buckle up, because we're ALL over the place, but in the best way babes. Dayna has experienced her very own glitch in the Matrix (free earring, nice!), Katie rings in the Reason for the Season (hint: it's soup), and the gals ... Show More
57m 8s
Nov 14
The Golden Middle Finger | WWDD/Heauxmetown Heroes w/ Katie Maloney & Dayna Kathan
Hello to our lovely coven, happy Friday! Today we get knee deep in all of your crazy Heauxmetown Hero tales, and dive into the nitty gritty for WWDD. In need of something cute and cool for the summer? Get yourself or whoever's on your daddy list a tee, hoodie, or daddy hat from o ... Show More
59m 4s
Recommended Episodes
Aug 21
I Gave My Girlfriend 5 Covid Shots Accidentally... and This is What Happened
👉 Subscribe on 🔴 YouTube - youtube.com/amithejerk?sub_confirmation=1 📷 Am I the Jerk? on Instagram 📷 - instagram.com/amithejerk Am I the Genius? on 🟢 Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kb6l0leZvREWgHDG14i4o?si=0ab70d199ba64141 🐤 x.com/amithejerk 📘 facebook.com/amithe ... Show More
22m 3s
Jan 2025
Episode 56: Lack of Home Training
Bailey finally left her home this weekend, the Eagles are going to the Super Bowl, and Brandon has a new fetish to share.  Let our sponsor BetterHelp connect you to a therapist who can support you - all from the comfort of your own home. Visit https://betterhelp.com/betweenusgirl ... Show More
48m 31s
Jul 2025
Entitled Friend is RUINING MY JOB after I GOT HER HIRED 4 days ago
👉 Subscribe on 🔴 YouTube - youtube.com/amithejerk?sub_confirmation=1 📷 Am I the Jerk? on Instagram 📷 - instagram.com/amithejerk Am I the Genius? on 🟢 Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kb6l0leZvREWgHDG14i4o?si=0ab70d199ba64141 🐤 x.com/amithejerk 📘 facebook.com/amithe ... Show More
22m 6s
Jul 2024
Episode 32: Yap-a-thon
Let our sponsor BetterHelp connect you to a therapist who can support you - all from the comfort of your own home. Visit https://betterhelp.com/betweenusgirlies and enjoy a special discount on your first month. The Girlies didn’t write an outline for this week’s episode so we’re ... Show More
46m 8s
Feb 2025
Motherhood Catch-up
<p>This week, the girls are having a chatty catch-up episode! They talk about the highs &amp; lows of being a new parent, balancing work &amp; family, an eagle live stream (?), &amp; so much more.&nbsp;</p><p><br></p><p>What we are wearing/mentioning links:&nbsp;</p><p><a href="h ... Show More
1h 7m
Nov 2024
Cavallari is a Freakin Trainwreck!
<p>Join me for this fun solo episode to debunk headlines over the years. We discuss a "fling" with Scott Disick, who these "sources" are, when The Hills took it too far, the worst thing I had to live out in the tabloid world, getting proposed to over text, hookup rumors, and "fri ... Show More
52m 36s
Jun 2025
Karen DEMANDS that I GET FIRED.... but ends up GETTING FIRED HERSELF
👉 Subscribe on 🔴 YouTube - youtube.com/amithejerk?sub_confirmation=1 📷 Am I the Jerk? on Instagram 📷 - instagram.com/amithejerk Am I the Genius? on 🟢 Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kb6l0leZvREWgHDG14i4o?si=0ab70d199ba64141 🐤 x.com/amithejerk 📘 facebook.com/amithe ... Show More
21m 46s
Aug 11
I Hired a Dog Walker who Turned Out to be a JUNKIE that TRASHED MY HOUSE… so I Got Even
👉 Subscribe on 🔴 YouTube - youtube.com/amithejerk?sub_confirmation=1 📷 Am I the Jerk? on Instagram 📷 - instagram.com/amithejerk Am I the Genius? on 🟢 Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kb6l0leZvREWgHDG14i4o?si=0ab70d199ba64141 🐤 x.com/amithejerk 📘 facebook.com/amithe ... Show More
22m 11s
Jun 2025
My Girlfriend Stole My Money… so I Ruined Her Life with One Video
👉 Subscribe on 🔴 YouTube - youtube.com/amithejerk?sub_confirmation=1 📷 Am I the Jerk? on Instagram 📷 - instagram.com/amithejerk Am I the Genius? on 🟢 Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kb6l0leZvREWgHDG14i4o?si=0ab70d199ba64141 🐤 x.com/amithejerk 📘 facebook.com/amithe ... Show More
22m 46s
Nov 13
Karen slides into my INSTAGRAM DM's... DEMANDING I PAY FOR HER UBER
Am I the Jerk? is the show where you can confess your deepest darkest secrets and be part of the conversation. 👉 Subscribe on 🔴 YouTube - youtube.com/amithejerk?sub_confirmation=1 📷 Am I the Jerk? on Instagram 📷 - instagram.com/amithejerk Am I the Genius? on 🟢 Spotify - http ... Show More
21m 55s