episode-header-image

Oct 2025

54m 5s

The Facebook Trap that Ended in Murder.

About this episode

Virgina, 2021:

Chelsea Perkins, a married mum of 2, opened up Facebook to reconnect with an old school friend called Matthew Dunmire. But this catchup had dark intentions… Chelsea had a very serious axe to grind with Matthew.

Back in 2017 Chelsea accused him of assaulting her but unfortunately there was nothing Police could do to help. She’d since re-branded as an Only Fans model by the name Selena Savage, and now, unable to forget that horrific night she would lure Matthew out. Tempting him with a night of passion, and when they were finally alone together, she would act on her revenge.

But what would happen next…NO ONE could’ve ever predicted…

Resources:

Rights4Girls https://rights4girls.org/

https://linktr.ee/eleanornealeresources

Watch OUTLORE Podcast:

https://www.youtube.com/@EleanorNeale

Follow Me Here for Updates & Short Form Content:

Up next

Murdered for £1,500: Pennie Davis

47-year-old mother of five Pennie Davis was tending to her horses when she was murdered in an isolated Hampshire field. There were no obvious witnesses, no clear motive and seemingly very little for police to go on... until a car key found beside her body led them to a man Pennie ... Show More

Epstein Part 2: The Accusers, the Accomplices & the Disappearance

Behind Jeffrey Epstein’s crimes are countless stories, allegations and questions that still remain. In Part 2, we look at the women whose lives became intertwined with Epstein, from those who accused him of abuse to those alleged to have helped facilitate it, and the complicated ... Show More

Epstein Part 1: The Models, the Island & the Mysterious Death

Behind Jeffrey Epstein’s crimes are countless stories, connections and questions that still remain. In Part 1, we look at the mysterious death of model Ruslana Korshunova, her previously reported trip to Epstein’s private island, and Karyna Shuliak, the woman who remained close t ... Show More

Recommended Episodes

This OnlyFans Model is in BIG Trouble - The Selena Savage Story

Chelsea Perkins, a former U.S. Coast Guard veteran who later became an adult model under the name “Selena Savage,” pleaded guilty in May 2025 to second-degree murder after luring Matthew Dunmire to a remote area of Cuyahoga Valley National Park in Ohio

S1 E39: The Only Fans Murderer: Case of Christian Obumseli

On April 3rd, 2022, Courtney Cleeney, Only fans model and Instagram personality, went on Instagram live to talk to her fans. She talked about her summer plans, her new makeup, etc. But no one watching the live would have guessed that 30 minutes after the live ended, Courtney woul ... Show More

240. The OnlyFans Killer

In this episode, Payton and Garrett delve into the case of social media power couple Christian Obumseli and Courtney Clenney. Despite their picture-perfect online presence, a much darker reality unfolded behind closed doors—one that ultimately led to Christian’s tragic demise. T ... Show More

Jenelle Potter : The Facebook Murder

Jenelle Potter was allegedly being cyberbullied and when the people she claimed to be the bullies turned up dead, everyone thought she killed them to stop the bullying, but it turned out that far more was going on under the surface. For more stories of the worst people on earth, ... Show More

Behind the Mask (Ernest Ibarra)

<p>A social media blogger is tied up in her home and her husband is abducted, and later found dead. Police soon have a web of suspects, and learn that appearances and the truth can be far from the same.</p><p> </p><p>View source material and photos for this episode at: <a href="h ... Show More

The OnlyFans Murder - The Story of Fake Barbie

<p>In 2022, British OF model Abigail White, known online as "Fake Barbie," was convicted of murdering her boyfriend, Bradley Lewis, by stabbing him in the heart at their home in Kingswood, near Bristol. The incident occurred shortly after Lewis ended their relationship< ... Show More

Blonde beauty Cynthia George is in a lustful extramarital affair with charming entrepreneur Jeff Zack. When his obsession sends her into the arms of another man, a volatile mix of jealousy and rage soon erupt in a shocking act of violence.For even more Scorned: Love Kills, head t ... Show More

When Catfishing Goes Wrong - The Real Story of TallHotBlond

An online love triangle spirals into a deadly obsession. Thomas Montgomery, a married man in his mid-forties, pretends to be a younger Marine named “Tommy” in an internet chat room. He meets “Talhotblond,” an online persona used by an 18-year-old high schooler named Jessi.