logo
episode-header-image
Sep 2025
50m 19s

They Found 4 Teen's Bodies In This Yogur...

Breanna Heim
About this episode

On December 6, 1991, a horrific crime shocked Austin, Texas. Four teenage girls were found murdered inside a local yogurt shop, their lives cut short in a brutal attack that left the city reeling.

Despite multiple arrests and decades of investigation, the Yogurt Shop Murders remain unsolved. False confessions, botched investigations and countless dead ends have left families searching for justice and a community haunted by unanswered questions. In this week’s episode of Hot On The Case, we’re diving deep into the timeline, theories, and chilling mystery of the Yogurt Shop Murders.

austincrimestoppers.org

  •  Call 512-472-TIPS (8477)

  • Up next
    Jul 3
    11 Year Old Girl Kidnapped For 18 Years & Found Alive
    In this week's investigation Hot On The Case dives into the kidnapping and incredible survival story of Jaycee Lee Dugard. At just 11 years old, Jaycee was abducted in South Lake Tahoe by Phillip and Nancy Garrido. She was held captive in a secret backyard before finally being fo ... Show More
    55m 19s
    Jun 26
    The Most Bizarre Disappearance Ever Caught On Camera
    In this week's investigation Hot On The Case covers one of the most confusing missing persons cases of all time. Brian Shaffer was a medical student at Ohio State who walked into a crowded college bar, and never walked back out of it. He can be seen on CCTV footage arriving with ... Show More
    50m 32s
    Jun 19
    One Of The Youngest Girls On Death Row Buried Her Victims Alive
    In this week's investigation Hot On The Case dives into the shocking story of Tiffany Cole, a young woman who became one of the youngest females sentenced to death in the United States. In 2005, Tiffany and three accomplices targeted Carol and Reggie Sumner, an elderly couple who ... Show More
    45m 24s
    Recommended Episodes
    Apr 2023
    The Yogurt Shop Murders
    Four teenage girls were brutally murdered inside an Austin, Texas, yogurt store in 1991. Suspects and even a motive were hard to come by. At different times, various people confessed to the crime. But each one was interrogated by the same cop, leaving many to wonder if these conf ... Show More
    42m 17s
    Jun 2025
    Austin Yogurt Shop Murders - 630
    December 6th, 1991. Austin, Texas. Close to midnight, a patrol officer reported a fire at a local frozen yogurt shop. Firefighters discovered the bodies of four teen girls who had been undressed, tied up, and shot execution style during a robbery. Almost eight years later, a grou ... Show More
    1h 9m
    Apr 2023
    The Yogurt Shop Murders
    It was 1991 when four teenage girls were brutally killed inside a yogurt store in Austin, Texas. With no witnesses to the crime, police had very little to go on. But soon, there was a confession. Then another. And another. It was up to investigators to sort through the evidence a ... Show More
    42m 17s
    Jan 2021
    EP. 1 TEXAS - The Austin Yogurt Shop Murders
    Four teenage girls found murdered, a slew of suspects, and no convictions- the story of the Austin Yogurt Shop murders is not only one of mystery, but a tale of anger, blood, false confessions & fire. And at its core is a crime that has gone unsolved for almost 30 years and has h ... Show More
    32 m
    Aug 2025
    The Yogurt Shop Murders
    On a cold December night in 1991, four teenage girls were found stripped, bound, and executed inside a burning yogurt shop in Austin, Texas. What began as a quiet shift at a family-friendly storefront ended in one of the most haunting and savage crimes the city has ever witnessed ... Show More
    55m 6s
    Aug 2025
    The Yogurt Shop Murders /// Part 1 /// 866
    tail spinning
    59m 46s
    Aug 2025
    INFAMOUS: The Yogurt Shop Murders
    <p>In 1991, Austin, Texas was rocked by one of the most horrifying crimes the city had ever seen: four young girls were brutally murdered and set on fire inside a local yogurt shop. The investigation would stretch on for decades, leading to four men being accused of the crime, ye ... Show More
    46m 59s
    Apr 2024
    1991 Austin Yogurt Shop Murders
    In 1991, an unsolved quadruple homicide took place at an I Can't Believe It's Yogurt! shop in Austin. All the victims were teenage girls and killed execution style. DNA was eventually found at the scene but the FBI refused to turn over the identity of the individual.Celebrate 4/2 ... Show More
    1h 21m
    Oct 2025
    Suspect Named In 1991 Quadruple "Yogurt Shop" Murders
    DNA evidence has helped police create a timeline for the long-unsolved 1991 murders of four teenage girls who were found dead at a yogurt store in Austin, Texas. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices 
    1m 45s