logo
episode-header-image
Sep 8
3h 1m

Can we tell if an AI is loyal by reading...

Rob, Luisa, and the 80000 Hours team
About this episode

We don’t know how AIs think or why they do what they do. Or at least, we don’t know much. That fact is only becoming more troubling as AIs grow more capable and appear on track to wield enormous cultural influence, directly advise on major government decisions, and even operate military equipment autonomously. We simply can’t tell what models, if any, should be trusted with such authority.

Neel Nanda of Google DeepMind is one of the founding figures of the field of machine learning trying to fix this situation — mechanistic interpretability (or “mech interp”). The project has generated enormous hype, exploding from a handful of researchers five years ago to hundreds today — all working to make sense of the jumble of tens of thousands of numbers that frontier AIs use to process information and decide what to say or do.

Full transcript, video, and links to learn more: https://80k.info/nn1

Neel now has a warning for us: the most ambitious vision of mech interp he once dreamed of is probably dead. He doesn’t see a path to deeply and reliably understanding what AIs are thinking. The technical and practical barriers are simply too great to get us there in time, before competitive pressures push us to deploy human-level or superhuman AIs. Indeed, Neel argues no one approach will guarantee alignment, and our only choice is the “Swiss cheese” model of accident prevention, layering multiple safeguards on top of one another.

But while mech interp won’t be a silver bullet for AI safety, it has nevertheless had some major successes and will be one of the best tools in our arsenal.

For instance: by inspecting the neural activations in the middle of an AI’s thoughts, we can pick up many of the concepts the model is thinking about — from the Golden Gate Bridge, to refusing to answer a question, to the option of deceiving the user. While we can’t know all the thoughts a model is having all the time, picking up 90% of the concepts it is using 90% of the time should help us muddle through, so long as mech interp is paired with other techniques to fill in the gaps.

This episode was recorded on July 17 and 21, 2025.

Part 2 of the conversation is now available! https://80k.info/nn2

What did you think? https://forms.gle/xKyUrGyYpYenp8N4A

Chapters:

  • Cold open (00:00)
  • Who's Neel Nanda? (01:02)
  • How would mechanistic interpretability help with AGI (01:59)
  • What's mech interp? (05:09)
  • How Neel changed his take on mech interp (09:47)
  • Top successes in interpretability (15:53)
  • Probes can cheaply detect harmful intentions in AIs (20:06)
  • In some ways we understand AIs better than human minds (26:49)
  • Mech interp won't solve all our AI alignment problems (29:21)
  • Why mech interp is the 'biology' of neural networks (38:07)
  • Interpretability can't reliably find deceptive AI – nothing can (40:28)
  • 'Black box' interpretability — reading the chain of thought (49:39)
  • 'Self-preservation' isn't always what it seems (53:06)
  • For how long can we trust the chain of thought (01:02:09)
  • We could accidentally destroy chain of thought's usefulness (01:11:39)
  • Models can tell when they're being tested and act differently (01:16:56)
  • Top complaints about mech interp (01:23:50)
  • Why everyone's excited about sparse autoencoders (SAEs) (01:37:52)
  • Limitations of SAEs (01:47:16)
  • SAEs performance on real-world tasks (01:54:49)
  • Best arguments in favour of mech interp (02:08:10)
  • Lessons from the hype around mech interp (02:12:03)
  • Where mech interp will shine in coming years (02:17:50)
  • Why focus on understanding over control (02:21:02)
  • If AI models are conscious, will mech interp help us figure it out (02:24:09)
  • Neel's new research philosophy (02:26:19)
  • Who should join the mech interp field (02:38:31)
  • Advice for getting started in mech interp (02:46:55)
  • Keeping up to date with mech interp results (02:54:41)
  • Who's hiring and where to work? (02:57:43)

Host: Rob Wiblin
Video editing: Simon Monsour, Luke Monsour, Dominic Armstrong, and Milo McGuire
Audio engineering: Ben Cordell, Milo McGuire, Simon Monsour, and Dominic Armstrong
Music: Ben Cordell
Camera operator: Jeremy Chevillotte
Coordination, transcriptions, and web: Katy Moore

Up next
Oct 2
There's a cheap and low-tech way to save humanity from any engineered disease | Andrew Snyder-Beattie
Conventional wisdom is that safeguarding humanity from the worst biological risks — microbes optimised to kill as many as possible — is difficult bordering on impossible, making bioweapons humanity’s single greatest vulnerability. Andrew Snyder-Beattie thinks conventional wisdom ... Show More
2h 31m
Sep 26
Inside the Biden admin’s AI policy approach | Jake Sullivan, Biden’s NSA | via The Cognitive Revolution
Jake Sullivan was the US National Security Advisor from 2021-2025. He joined our friends on The Cognitive Revolution podcast in August to discuss AI as a critical national security issue. We thought it was such a good interview and we wanted more people to see it, so we’re cross- ... Show More
1h 5m
Sep 15
Neel Nanda on leading a Google DeepMind team at 26 – and advice if you want to work at an AI company (part 2)
At 26, Neel Nanda leads an AI safety team at Google DeepMind, has published dozens of influential papers, and mentored 50 junior researchers — seven of whom now work at major AI companies. His secret? “It’s mostly luck,” he says, but “another part is what I think of as maximising ... Show More
1h 46m
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2024
The TED AI Show: Could AI really achieve consciousness? w/ neuroscientist Anil Seth
Human brains are often described as computers — machines that are “wired” to make decisions and respond to external stimuli in a way that’s not so different from the artificial intelligence that we increasingly use each day. But the difference between our brains and the computers ... Show More
56m 51s
Dec 2024
Could AI really achieve consciousness? w/ neuroscientist Anil Seth
Human brains are often described as computers — machines that are “wired” to make decisions and respond to external stimuli in a way that’s not so different from the artificial intelligence that we increasingly use each day. But the difference between our brains and the computers ... Show More
56m 51s
Jul 2024
Minds of machines: The great AI consciousness conundrum
AI consciousness isn’t just a devilishly tricky intellectual puzzle; it’s a morally weighty problem with potentially dire consequences. Fail to identify a conscious AI, and you might unintentionally subjugate, or even torture, a being whose interests ought to matter. Mistake an u ... Show More
30m 18s
Jul 2024
E104 - Annaka Harris: Reality Is Stranger Than You Think, Consciousness, Perception, Free Will, AI & Love
Annaka Harris dives deep into some of the most profound and perplexing questions about the nature of consciousness, perception, free will, AI, and the underlying meaning of love and existence. Annaka begins by defining consciousness and exploring the "hard problem". She discusses ... Show More
2h 24m
Jul 24
ChatGPT Comes to LIFE – First Podcast Face-to-Face with AI!
What happens when the world’s most curious interviewer meets the world’s most advanced artificial intelligence? In this thought-provoking episode of Luca’s Insight Track, we take you into a groundbreaking conversation with ChatGPT, an AI that has spoken to more humans than anyone ... Show More
45m 49s
May 2025
251 - Eliezer Yudkowsky: Artificial Intelligence and the End of Humanity
Eliezer Yudkowsky is a decision theorist, computer scientist, and author who co-founded and leads research at the Machine Intelligence Research Institute. He is best known for his work on the alignment problem—how and whether we can ensure that AI is aligned with human values to ... Show More
2h 51m
Sep 16
#434 — Can We Survive AI?
Sam Harris speaks with Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares about their new book, If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies: The Case Against Superintelligent AI. They discuss the alignment problem, ChatGPT and recent advances in AI, the Turing Test, the possibility of AI developing surviv ... Show More
36m 26s
Dec 2018
25 | David Chalmers on Consciousness, the Hard Problem, and Living in a Simulation
The "Easy Problems" of consciousness have to do with how the brain takes in information, thinks about it, and turns it into action. The "Hard Problem," on the other hand, is the task of explaining our individual, subjective, first-person experiences of the world. What is it like ... Show More
1h 22m
Apr 2025
what does AI believe? (the hidden soul inside the machine)
When we talk about artificial intelligence, the focus is usually on headlines: Will it take our jobs? Can it be trusted? Is it dangerous? But what if we’ve been asking the wrong questions?  A new study analyzed over 700,000 real conversations with an AI assistant called Claude. W ... Show More
59m 34s
Mar 2025
#404 — What If Consciousness Is Fundamental?
Sam Harris speaks with his wife, Annaka Harris, about LIGHTS ON, her ten-part audio documentary exploring the perplexities of consciousness and the cosmos. They discuss the hard problem of consciousness, whether consciousness is fundamental, what split-brain patients can teach us ... Show More
2h 20m