episode-header-image

Today

38m 52s

Bonus Episode: 'The Rabbi, The Mistress ...

Always True Crime

About this episode

For this bonus episode, I am a guest once again on one of my favourite shows, the excellent REDRUM Podcast with Grace.

We look at a complex case from New Jersey in the US where the wife of a highly respected Rabbi, 52 year old Carol Neulander, was bludgeoned to death in her Cherry Hill home with a one-foot section of lead pipe on 1 November 1994, after returning home from her work as a bakery manager. Just who murdered Carol and why?

1, Listen to other episodes of the REDRUM podcast, by following these links:

Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/redrum-true-crime/id1515905584 Apple Podcasts

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/1FCoeRZQeDkEJ5i8bGuFpy

2, To find out more about my UK True Crime Podcast, check out my website below:

https://uktruecrime.com

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next

Who Do You Trust? : Episode 458

So who do you trust? I mean, who do you really trust? In this episode from north London we look at the shocking murder of 74 year old Anjelica Hallwood, where twin brothers left their own 18th birthday party to carry out the most shocking of crimes.Find out more about me and the ... Show More

Monthly Bonus Episode - 'True Crime Round-Up' August 2025

Welcome to episode eight in the series of my monthly chats with Stuart from @britishmurders. As usual, we look at crime stories that made headlines in August 2025, covering local, national, and international headlines.This month, for the second consecutive month, Stuart decided n ... Show More

A Charming Stranger: Episode 457

The story this week comes from a small town in South Wales. It is a story about trust misplaced, lives shattered, and the devastating cost of chasing a dream that was never real. Find out more about me and the UK True Crime Podcasthttps://uktruecrime.com Hosted on Acast. See acas ... Show More

Recommended Episodes

Abducted on Her Morning Run by Pure Evil: The Murder of Eliza Fletcher

In the early hours of September 2, 2022, 34-year-old wife and mother of two Eliza Fletcher went out for a ten mile run. She had been training for a marathon, and found that the earlier she went out for her runs, the more time she had later in the day to spend with her two young s ... Show More

Episode 344: Janice Lillie

On the morning of November 12th of 1991, 41-year-old Janice Aschraft Lillie left her volunteer work at Belle Chasse High School to go to her office in Gretna, Louisiana. Janice’s husband, 41-year-old Norman Lillie, needs her help collecting back rent from their tenants. The coupl ... Show More

#557 - Suburban Ax Murder Mystery - Brighton, New York

This week, in Brighton, New York, a woman is brutally murdered with an ax, in her very comfortable suburban home, making everyone wonder if a crazed killer was on the loose. Detectives seem to have no clue who could have done this, until a old neighbor, with a violent past confes ... Show More

Ivy League Genius Kevin Jiang Murdered by Fiancé’s Stalker Who Tried To Flee?!

On the night of February 6, 2021, 26-year-old grad student Kevin Jiang left his fiancée's apartment in New Haven, CT. After he got into his car, another car crashed into it from behind. Upon getting out of his car to check on the man who hit him, Kevin was fatally shot by the dri ... Show More

He Orchestrated Her Murder, but Failed?!

Schanda Handley was kidnapped from her home in Louisiana by two men posing as delivery workers — but this wasn’t random. In this episode, Kendall Rae unpacks the harrowing case and the shocking revelation that Schanda’s estranged husband was behind the plot. A chilling story of b ... Show More

The Murders of Kathy Perry and Rhonda Travers (Rhode Island)

In a nine-month span between 1986 and 1987, two women were found brutally slain in the same Rhode Island city. Investigators believed that the first was abducted from the side of the road on her way home from work in the middle of the night, while the second appeared to get into ... Show More

The Murder of Denise Robert (New Hampshire)

She was out on her usual Sunday night walk when an unknown killer pulled up and shot her, leaving her mortally wounded in the street of what locals considered a safe neighborhood. Why someone would target Denise Robert and take her life still doesn’t make any sense to her family ... Show More

From “Perfect” Marriage to Possible Murder: The Disappearance of Jennifer Dulos

Jennifer Dulos, a loving mother of five, was two years into a bitter divorce battle against her soon-to-be-ex-husband, Fotis Dulos, when she suddenly vanished. Though her car was quickly found a few miles from her home, Jennifer’s body has never been found. Investigators conducte ... Show More

The Murder of Tashauna Jackson (Connecticut)

In the last episode of Dark Downeast, you heard the story of Denise Hart and her still unsolved homicide in Vermont. I mentioned in that episode the case of another woman who grew up in the same city and around the same people as Denise. So, that’s the story I’m going to tell you ... Show More

The Murders of Mark Harnish & Theresa Marcoux (Massachusetts)

It was one of the most confounding unsolved crimes that the town of West Springfield, Massachusetts, had ever seen. Two young people, shot and killed in their car without any conceivable motive. This seemingly random double murder remained unsolved for over 40 years…Until police ... Show More

Listen to millions of songs and podcasts on Anghami