logo
episode-header-image
Aug 21
16m 1s

Montauk Mystery: She Was Laid to Rest Ye...

iHeartPodcasts
About this episode

"She had a short life, but a packed life." Family and friends gathered to say goodbye to Martha Nolan-O'Slattara in her native Ireland yesterday. Her sister called her a "built-in best friend."  Her partner said he was blessed to have experienced Martha's love. But her family is still waiting for answers about her death. It’s been 2 weeks since she was found unresponsive on a boat at the Montauk Yacht Club.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Up next
Yesterday
Legally Brunette: The Menendez Brothers & Jillian Michaels
We’re giving you a breakdown of why Erik and Lyle Menendez have been denied parole. Is there another avenue that can lead to their release? Plus, Jillian Michaels has been vocal about Netflix’s latest “Biggest Loser” documentary and the lies against her. What’s Jillian’s defense ... Show More
29m 36s
Yesterday
Sunday Morning Run: Inspiration from Abraham Lincoln to Babe Ruth to T.J. and His Pastor.
Get your week started with some words of wisdom. Hear the weekly wrap of Amy and T.J.’s quotes of the day that will get your week started off with intention and purpose. Plus, a bonus quote from the creator of “The Handmaid’s Tale” that Amy and T.J. say should be in every classro ... Show More
22m 27s
Aug 23
A Different Tone, But Same Outcome: Why Parole Was Denied for Lyle Menendez
After a marathon hearing lasting 11 hours, with the support of a dozen family members, a separate parole board denied parole to Lyle Menendez. Amy and T.J. give all the details from the hearing, including how a tearful and apologetic Lyle tried to explain his illegal cellphone us ... Show More
20m 34s
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2025
Post Mortem | Could Angela Prichard Have Been Saved?
CBS News Correspondent Jonathan Vigliotti and 48 Hours Producer Mead Stone discuss the case of Angela Prichard, who was gunned down at her workplace by her estranged husband, Christopher, in Bellevue, Iowa. They discuss the 9-1-1 call Angela made in the final moments of her life ... Show More
23m 41s
Mar 2017
Episode 2: Leanne Disappears
It is Monday, September 23rd, 1991 - the day Leanne Holland was last seen alive. What did she do? Who was she with? We hear from Graham Stafford, the man who describes her last known activities. How did her family react to her disappearance? And, what happened next...Music: Touch ... Show More
24m 39s
Dec 2024
Ep. - 1183 - MISTAKEN IDENTITY
Kate discusses three of the most moving stories from the Oprah Winfrey Show, including a story of mistaken identity.  Five lives were lost in a tragic car accident, and the sole survivor was rushed to the hospital, where she remained in a coma for five weeks. Everyone believed th ... Show More
24m 35s
Sep 2021
Finding healing in the sea that took my family
Geraldine Mullan lived with her husband John and their two children Tomás and Amelia in a town on the beautiful Irish coastline of County Donegal – a salty inlet of the Atlantic Ocean. They all loved the water, which during lockdown became a welcome escape for the whole family. B ... Show More
22m 53s
Feb 2025
A Deadly Family Secret
On Valentine's Day morning in 2000, Jane Dorotik learned that her husband of 30 years was dead. The 55-year-old engineer and father of three was found on a road near their home, bludgeoned to death with a rope around his neck. Despite her denial of any involvement, Jane was arres ... Show More
49m 57s
Aug 6
A Bathtub Drowning
In September 2001, Doug Grant discovered his wife Fayleen lying unconscious in their bathtub. She couldn’t be revived at the hospital and her death was considered a drowning. But as investigators discovered Fayleen had a history of dramatic mood swings and was considered by some ... Show More
45m 57s
Dec 2024
Marriage Secrets
In December of 2007, Jocelyn Earnest was found dead from a gunshot wound in her Virginia home. Beside her was a revolver and a suicide note. But investigators believed that the scene was staged and found fingerprints on the note that matched her estranged husband, Wesley Earnest. ... Show More
47m 40s
Oct 2024
Tammy Pitkin - USA
In this episode we tell the baffling story of the disappearance of Tammy Pitkin, whose car was found abandoned on a dead end forest service road in Sweet Home, Oregon, almost 400 miles from her home in Red Bluff California. Tammy had recently separated from her husband but was lo ... Show More
40m 36s
Feb 2025
Who's There?
In 1982, a quiet town in Kansas was rocked by the murder of a young banker named David Harmon who was bludgeoned to death in his bed. His wife told authorities that it was a home invasion. Investigators suspected that she was having an affair with a family friend and that the two ... Show More
49m 43s
Mar 2024
Vanished Weeks Before Her Dream Wedding: What Happened to Niqui McCown?
Niqui McCown was a 28-year-old mother living in Richmond, Indiana, with her 9-year-old daughter, Payton, and her fiancé, Bobby Webster. In July of 2001, they were 3 weeks away from their wedding, and Niqui was said to have been very excited. But on the 22nd of that month, she van ... Show More
48m 48s