logo
episode-header-image
Aug 16
48m 42s

FRIDAY NIGHT SPECIAL: FOUR MISTRESSES, A...

iHeartPodcasts and CrimeOnline
About this episode

The lead up to James Craig’s trial has been bizarre.....two postponements, three different attorney teams, five added charges and a crazy action from an attorney, who allegedly set his own house on fire. Still, the Aurora dentist’s trial began and ended after jurors heard from four mistresses who said James Craig told them his marriage was over, but a divorce would break him financiall. 

Crag faced six  felony counts: 

  • Murder in the first degree 
  • Two counts of solicitation to commit tampering with physical evidence 
  • Three counts of solicitation to commit perjury in the first degree 

Court Documents show Craig, jailed on a murder charge of his wife, Angela Craig, still allegedly worked to convince inmates, a former mistress and even one of his own children to tamper with evidence, to plant it to make it look like Angela Craig wanted to kill herself.  

Prosecutors say James Craig even made a botched murder-for-hire attempt on the case’s lead detective just before a second attempt at trial  last year.   Craig allegedly offered people cash and dental work in return for a coverup .  

Craig insists  he ordered poison because she asked him to. 

James Craig and his wife Angela were married for over 20 years. They created a beautiful family of six, loving, happy family, happy children. Between work and taking care of their children, the Craigs still manage to fit a workout into their daily routine. The husband and wife go for a run or hit the gym together almost every day, and when they return home, James Craig makes protein shakes or fruit smoothies for breakfast while Angela delves into getting the kids ready for the day.   

Angela complains of having a really nasty headache, along with problems focusing her eyesight.  She goes to the hospital saying she felt tingly and cold.   Doctors cannot figure out what's wrong with her.   Angela goes to the hospital multiple times, only to be sent home.  When she goes back for a third time, that's when she's checked in and her condition deteriorates, coding quickly.  Angela passes away. 

One of Summer Brooks’ dental assistants recalls opening a package for Dr. Craig—that had potassium cyanide in it. She googles the symptoms of cyanide poisoning, and is horrified at how closely they match Angela’s symptoms. She immediately calls Craig’s partner, Ryan Redfearn, hoping he has some other explanation for the contents of the package...but he doesn’t. While visiting Angela, Redfearn tells a nurse about the cyanide, explaining there’s no medical use for the element in their practice. As a mandatory reporter, the nurse calls police.  

With suspicions raised, Angela Craig is sent for an autopsy with additional toxicology screening. Tests reveal the otherwise healthy mom of six died of poisoning from both cyanide and tetrahydrozoline, a common ingredient in eyedrops. While investigators have no definitive evidence Angela’s food and drinks were poisoned with cyanide, the tests reveal her cyanide levels increased while she was in the hospital.   

Police then check Craig's computer finding strange searches.  One of them was how to poison someone, how to make poison and top five or top 10 undetectable poisons that people won't be able to find after someone has died and will not signal foul play.

Less than 24 hours after his wife’s death, dentist James Toliver Craig is arrested for Angela’s murder and additionally charged with tampering with evidence. A 52-page arrest affidavit details Craig’s concerning computer searches, three poison orders, an ongoing affair, and proof Craig took several measures to cover his tracks.   

Police then learn the dentist  allegedly tried to hire his cellmate to kill Aurora PD’s lead detective Bobbi Jo Olson for $20,000. Calling Olson the “worst, dirtiest detective,” James Craig tried to recruit Nathaniel Harris to take her out for cash or free dental work. Olson wasn’t the only person on his list. Craig also asked Harris to kill another Aurora PD officer and two inmates ‘Roger’ and ‘Tommy.’ 

Joining Nancy Grace today:

  • Eric Faddis - Trial Lawyer and TV Legal Analyst, Founding Partner of Varner Faddis Elite Legal, former felony prosecutor and current criminal defense and civil litigation attorney
  • Dr. Shavaun Scott -  Psychotherapist, Author of “The Minds of Mass Killers: Understanding and Interrupting the Pathway to Violence”
  • Fil Waters  - Former homicide detective for the Houston police department, President & CEO of Kindred spirits Investigations & Security, Inc., kindredspiritsinvestigations.com
  • Dr Ernest Chiodo  - Attorney, Physician, Biomedical Engineer, Toxicologist, Author: “Toxic Tort: Medical and Legal Elements”, www.ernestpchiodo.com
  • Steffan Tubbs -  Host:  'Arsenic, DDS - The Bizarre Case of Dr. James Craig'; Former patient of James Craig

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Up next
Today
Trial Looms for Scorned Hairstylist Accused of Hiring Hitman to Murder Ex & His Teen Daughter
Jaclyn Diiorio, 26, a hairstylist, and her police officer boyfriend broke up after dating for nearly a year. The relationship had been contentious, with both filing protective orders. After the breakup, Diiorio began dating again and turned to Tinder. During conversations with a ... Show More
41m 22s
Today
Mayhem in the Morgue | First Day
Welcome to the debut episode of Mayhem in the Morgue — an unfiltered, insightful look into the world of forensic pathology, hosted by veteran medical examiner Dr. Kendall Crowns. With more than 35 years of experience in death investigation, Dr. Crowns brings a unique perspective ... Show More
8m 35s
Yesterday
Donna Adelson Trial Moves Forward in Murder of Son-in-Law |Crime Alert Recap Saturday 08.22.25
Breaking crime news as it happens throughout the day! Follow "Crime Alert Hourly Update" now on your favorite podcast app: https://link.chtbl.com/Crime_Alert Here's some of our top stories this week: Jury now set in Donna Adelson's murder trial. She is accused of being one of the ... Show More
11m 5s
Recommended Episodes
Nov 2019
The Smoking Gun - 6
New evidence emerges which points to a crime.. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
37m 37s
Jun 2024
Sonia Mitchell
When a young father goes missing, authorities suspect his illegal activities, but a revelation about the mother of his children turns the investigation upside down.Season 23 Episode 02Originally aired: January 28, 2018Watch full episodes of Snapped for FREE on the Oxygen app: htt ... Show More
43m 40s
Feb 2020
Chapter 2: The Day Delphi Changed
As the search for Abby Williams and Libby German ends at a crime scene, the reality of what's happened is worse than anyone could have imagined. A massive law enforcement presence arrives, and a double murder investigation begins.To learn more about how HLN protects listener priv ... Show More
1h 10m
Apr 2019
Pressed For Crime
A brutal murder, lots of suspects, and conflicting evidence... but the forensics were clear on one thing: The killer knew his victim. And that alone gave investigators a head start.To learn more about how HLN protects listener privacy, visit cnn.com/privacy Learn more about your ... Show More
21m 52s
Feb 2025
True Crime Vault: Family Secrets
A New Jersey radio host's murder is the focus. Included: her daughter's five-year fight for justice; and the victim's husband's alleged involvement in her murder, with links to his ties to an illegal drug-distribution ring.Originally aired: 06/22/18 Learn more about your ad choic ... Show More
47m 21s
Jan 2019
Private Thoughts
Firefighters find an entire family dead inside their burned-out home, and at first glance, it appears to be a case of murder-suicide. But clues found at the scene soon lead investigators to believe otherwise. Forensic science, a time card, a drawing, and an audiotaped diary help ... Show More
21m 49s
Aug 2023
Lyla Nettle
The investigation goes international after a grieving mother leaves Australia behind her. Subscribe to Crime X+ today. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
54m 36s
Nov 2019
The Verdict - 7
Lindy is charged with murder. She awaits a verdict. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
40m 9s
Feb 2025
The 911 call in the Hollywood hairdresser murder. And investigators explore links between six violent deaths and a group called the Zizians.
In a Los Angeles courtroom, prosecutors play police interviews with a woman accused of conspiring to kill her celebrity hairstylist husband. NBC News investigative reporter Rich Schapiro shares his reporting on a Bay Area-based group that investigators believe may be tied to deat ... Show More
29m 6s
Aug 2023
Lasonya Dutton
A beloved daughter is found dead and mauled by dogs just metres from her family's kitchen window. Subscribe to Crime X+ today. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
44m 29s