logo
episode-header-image
Aug 11
1 h

BIGFOOT - Staying at This Cabin Was a Bi...

Cameron Buckner
About this episode
Staying at This Cabin Was a Big Mistake
In the mid-1960s, a financially struggling family from Ely, Nevada, was offered the use of a friend's ramshackle cabin in the Great Basin near Baker, Nevada. The isolated, one-room cabin lacked electricity and running water, with minimal furnishings like plywood-covered bed frames and a makeshift dining table. Despite its condition, the family—parents and four daughters—enjoyed their stays, cherishing the wilderness, a nearby creek they dammed for a pool, and a playful badger that raced their car. They hiked to an abandoned garnet mine, though the garnets were small and rough. In 1971, after staying with their grandparents, the daughters were excited to return to the cabin. During the drive, they teased their mother about Bigfoot, prompted by a National Enquirer article, unaware of her unease. Upon arrival, they found the back door violently torn off and the interior littered with leaves and mud, which they attributed to careless hunters. They cleaned up and stayed, but their mother remained anxious, staying awake all night by the fire. A sudden wind gust during a light snowfall heightened the tension, flapping a plastic sheet covering the doorless entry. The family left the next day and never returned. Years later, in 2020, the now-elderly mother, bedridden with dementia, revealed to her daughter a terrifying incident from a previous cabin visit with her husband, when they were alone. Something large and heavy circled the cabin at night, trying doors and windows, causing intense fear. They fled at dawn, seeing a tall, shadowy figure zigzag through the trees. The mother’s fear explained her anxiety during the 1971 trip, especially seeing the damaged cabin, yet she stayed to avoid disappointing her daughters. Years later, she and her husband found the cabin in worse condition, with both doors torn off and the heavy iron stove ripped out and discarded in a ditch, an act difficult to attribute to humans given the remote location and the stove’s weight. The family’s experiences left a lasting impression, blending fond memories with an unsettling mystery.
Join my Supporters Club for $4.99 per month for exclusive stories:
https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/what-if-it-s-true-podcast--5445587/support
Up next
Yesterday
The Breakout by Scott Hendrix
Scott Hendrix Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/stores/Scott-Hendrix/author/B09ZLMQP1N?ref=ap_rdr&isDramIntegrated=true&shoppingPortalEnabled=true&ccs_id=f8705893-ce3c-4e50-9014-cbd87482ebefThe Breakout by Scott HendrixIn the summer of his tenth year, young Henry Mason wanders ... Show More
16m 1s
Yesterday
Archive 209 Bigfoot
Archive 209 BigfootJoin my Supporters Club for $4.99 per month for exclusive stories:https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/what-if-it-s-true-podcast--5445587/support 
26m 17s
Oct 9
First Sasquatch Captured
First Sasquatch CapturedA veterinarian specializing in large animals graduates from the University of Kentucky and opens a private practice in 1995 before joining Tennessee's Elk Reintroduction Program in 2000. There, he monitors radio-collared elk in the North Cumberland Wildlif ... Show More
25m 31s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2024
S4 Ep157: Episode 157: Bizarre Family Horror
Tonight’s feature length podcast story is ‘I just found out that my family has been keeping a terrible secret from me’, a wonderful story By Mandahrk, kindly shared with me via NoSleep and narrated here for you all with the author’s express permission: https://www.reddit.com/user ... Show More
1h 35m
Feb 2022
S10E009 – "The Little Critters of Nature" – Scary Stories Told in the Dark
Otis presents a full episode tale of a terrifying encounter in the woods by TF Ahmad, where a young man recollects a search for a strange place in the woods leads him to a horrible truth about his community. To watch the podcast on YouTube: http://bit.ly/ChillingEntertainmentYT D ... Show More
1h 10m
Mar 2025
S5 Ep229: Episode 229: Terrifying Relationship Horror Stories
We open tonight’s podcast with ‘There’s Something Wrong with my Fiancé,’ an original story by The Life of Nikki, kindly shared with us at NoSleep and narrated with the author’s kind permission:  https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/8515hj/something_is_wrong_with_my_fiancee_p ... Show More
2h 49m
Feb 2022
S10E010 – "From the Stars...and Behind You" – Scary Stories Told in the Dark
Otis presents two stories from prolific Reddit author Weird BryceGuy. In the first, a strange sound emanating from the Missouri woods leads to the discovery of a strange being with ill intent. In the second, a man suffering from severe depressive episodes finds himself transporte ... Show More
1h 6m
Nov 2024
S5 Ep194: Episode 194: Ocean Cruise Horror
Today’s phenomenal podcast story is a terrifying tale titled ‘I Saw Something on a Cruise and Now I Can’t Sleep’, an original work by 1phrit, kindly shared with us at NoSleep and narrated with the author’s permission:  https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/7n3p15/i_saw_someth ... Show More
1h 34m
Aug 2024
Mon Histoire de Voyeurisme
Histoire postée sur le subreddit Horreur par l'utilisateur Stunning Hat en juillet 2024, l'histoire fait froid dans le dos... Source : https://www.reddit.com/r/Horreur/comments/1ebz0r6/mon_histoire_de_voyeurisme/ Pour m'envoyer vos histoires danslenoirpdcst@gmail.com Pour partici ... Show More
5m 36s
Jan 2025
S5 Ep211: Episode 211: Science Fiction Horror Stories
Tonight’s first two tales of terror are the bizarre and wonderful Alien fan-fiction takes ‘They Mostly Come at Night’ and ‘Feline,’ two fantastic stories by killahawke1, kindly shared with me both directly and also via the Creepypasta Wiki and narrated here for you all under the ... Show More
2h 47m
Dec 2023
S4 Ep149: Episode 149: Vampire Horror Stories
All of tonight’s podcast stories have been kindly shared with me via my subreddit for the express purpose of having me narrate them here for you all.  1 NosferatuNacht  https://www.reddit.com/user/Corpse_Child/  2 Greg against The Night  https://www.reddit.com/user/Stoic-Dreamven ... Show More
1h 48m
Apr 2023
S3 Ep120: Episode 120: Horror Stories from the realms of our worst nightmares
To get 20% off sitewide at www.exploreroam.com and use the code ‘Dungeon’ at check-out. Tonight’s first terrifying tale is ‘I Think I Went on a Date with a Demon’, a wonderful story JackGreeneOnAir, kindly shared with me via Dr. Crepen’s Vault and narrated here for you all with t ... Show More
1h 48m
Oct 2022
Cupid | Episode 1
Grandpa is somewhat of a stranger to Jason and Dylan, but he’s ready to make up for lost time. And, what better way to bond than over some good ole’ fashioned storytelling. What he has in store may be magical, but this isn’t a fairy tale. As the boys settle in, Grandpa begins to ... Show More
41m 17s