logo
episode-header-image
Aug 6
41m 26s

Ep.4: Rumors and Narratives

ID
About this episode
Sarah meets Misty's brother Colton for an intense conversation about how his sister’s disappearance in 1992 shaped the rest of his mother Diana's life and his own childhood. As Sarah examines the original police investigation, she learns of shocking failures and missed opportunities. When Sarah digs deeper into the statements of Trina, Misty's best friend who went to the fair with her, she discovers troubling inconsistencies in Trina’s story, which raise Sarah’s suspicions around a new suspect. Then Sarah receives a surprising email: a key witness finally agrees to talk after decades of silence.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Aug 20
Ep.6: A Person of Interest
Sarah meets with Puyallup Police Captain Jason Visnaw to learn about his efforts to reinvestigate the case of Misty Copsey, but he is tight-lipped, not wanting to jeopardize future convictions. Digging deeper into Rheuban Schmidt's story with local reporter Sean Robinson, Sarah f ... Show More
55m 40s
Aug 13
Ep.5: The Best Friend
Sarah sits down with Trina, Misty's best friend who went to the fair with her the night she disappeared – the first time Trina has spoken publicly about the case in more than 30 years. In a deeply emotional conversation, Trina reveals crucial details about their friendship, Misty ... Show More
43m 55s
Jul 30
Ep.3: Evidence?
Host Sarah Cailean continues to unravel the details of the case of Misty Copsey. When a former investigator reveals that the only evidence in the case – a pair of jeans, socks and underwear found months later along the side of a highway – may not have belonged to Misty, Sarah’s e ... Show More
50m 38s
Recommended Episodes
May 5
Your Next Listen: Fear Thy Neighbor
Check out Fear Thy Neighbor, from ID. Listen to Season 2, Episode 1, Intimidation Tactics here. Find Fear Thy Neighbor wherever you get your podcasts. What would you do if the person you feared most… was living right next door? On Fear Thy Neighbor, we dive deep into stranger tha ... Show More
33m 45s
Aug 2024
What to Listen to Next: Nightmare Next Door
If you enjoyed Killer Kin, you may also like Nightmare Next Door, from ID. Listen to episode 1 of the new season, Jack Be Deadly, and follow Nightmare Next Door wherever you get your podcasts. Nightmare Next Door is a true crime show that peels back the peaceful facade of small t ... Show More
43m 13s
Aug 2024
What to Listen to Next: Nightmare Next Door
If you enjoyed Deadly Nightmares, you may also like Nightmare Next Door, from ID. Nightmare Next Door is a true crime show that peels back the peaceful facade of small town America and exposes the dark secrets hidden behind its white-washed picket fences. Nightmare Next Door, the ... Show More
43m 17s
Jan 2025
Listen Now: Deadly Nightmares
On Deadly Nightmares, hear the real-life stories of ordinary people stalked by serial killers and attackers. You’ll hear investigators and experts recount cases of unspeakable violence, with some episodes featuring the voices of survivors who lived to tell their story. Deadly Nig ... Show More
34m 49s
Dec 2024
#552 - Too Many Dead Neighbors - Kerby, Oregon
This week, in Kerby, Oregon, a feud between neighbors boils over, when one of the neighbors ends the whole thing, by killing the other man. This is ruled self defense, so the man gets some new neighbors, who he doesn't like much better. Dogs barking, cats using a garden as a litt ... Show More
1h 12m
Mar 2021
EP. 12 KANSAS - The Wichita Horror: The Most Disturbing Murder Story I've EVER Heard
In the year 2000, an unbelievably brutal and shocking series of crimes rocked the city of Wichita, Kansas. What began as simple robberies quickly began to devolve into carjackings, then acts of violence, followed by, ultimately, a terrifying home invasion, hours of torture, and s ... Show More
38m 26s