logo
episode-header-image
Aug 2025
1h 10m

I Called the Police on My Serial Killer ...

Superreal
About this episode
tail spinning
Up next
Today
I Committed a School Shooting
In 2004, Jon Romano brought a shotgun to school intending to take his own life. One person was injured before he was tackled to the ground. Today, Jon reflects on the path that led him there—and what he wishes he’d told the people around him sooner.Find us on TikTok: @whatitwasli ... Show More
1h 2m
May 2
I Got Caught Fabricating Stories for the New York Times
In 2003, Jayson Blair was a rising star in journalism, until he got caught plagiarising stories and inventing details. What followed was one of the most high-profile downfalls in modern media. In this ep, Jayson reflects on why he lied, how he got away with it for so long, and ho ... Show More
40m 48s
Apr 25
I Woke From a Coma to a Man Claiming to Be My Boyfriend
After Brooke Knisley fell from a tree, she couldn’t walk, talk, or remember anything—or anyone. So when a man appeared claiming to be her boyfriend, she believed him. What followed was months of manipulation, as she slowly uncovered who he really was.This is a recent episode from ... Show More
52m 1s
Recommended Episodes
Nov 2024
TikToker April Holt’s Death Almost Went Unsolved… Until Her Mom Got Her Killer To Confess
April Lynn Holt was a mother of two, living outside of Nashville, Tennessee, working hard to create a good life for herself and her family. TikTok was a huge passion of hers, and she began making content back in the pandemic and had garnered over 200,000 followers. Her content wa ... Show More
1h 11m
Jul 2025
Edward Cairney and Avril Jones
<p>In the late ‘90s, Margaret Fleming was living under the care of Edward Cairney and Avril Jones, friends of her deceased father. In October 2016, the police launched an investigation when concerns were raised about a benefits claim made by Avril on Margaret’s behalf. </p><p>Joi ... Show More
1h 2m
Feb 2025
The White House Farm Murders
<p>On August 7th, 1985, an entire family was murdered at their farmhouse in Essex, England. Authorities initially believed it was a murder-suicide, but suspicion soon turned to Jeremy Bamber, the surviving family member who called police to the house that night.</p><p>Join Mike a ... Show More
1h 19m
Jul 2024
The Infamous Case of Daniel LaPlante (Massachusetts)
<p>For months, Frank Bowen's daughters complained of strange noises and odd happenings in their Pepperell, Massachusetts home. Frank was sure it was just their imaginations, until an intruder took the entire family hostage one night in December of 1986. When the suspect was relea ... Show More
48m 28s
Dec 2023
My Fugitive Dad | 3. The Last Randele
At a social security office in Boston, Ted Conrad is reborn as Thomas Randele. It was the first time this surname was ever recorded. Then he went about making friends and making excuses for why he didn’t have to work. Ashley sifts through her Dad’s past trying to figure out what ... Show More
44m 5s
May 2024
The Disappearance of April Dawn Pennington (Connecticut)
<p>When a 15-year-old girl snuck out of her bedroom window one night in May of 1996, it was like she vanished right into thin air with no leads. Years later unsealed court documents revealed that police had a theory and a suspect from the earliest days of the case, but it would t ... Show More
38m 4s
Jul 2024
Episode 356 - Davy Tweed: Behind Closed Doors
As far as the people of County Antrim, Northern Ireland, knew, Davy Tweed was a sporting hero, dedicated public servant, and good Protestant family man. But his stepdaughter Amanda Brown knew what this public façade masked: a volatile, unstoppable juggernaut of physical and sexua ... Show More
1h 1m
May 2024
Facebook Catfish Murders: Jenelle Potter Tricks Dad & Boyfriend Into Murder
In 2012, Billy Payne and his fiancée Billie Jean Hayworth were found shot dead in their home, their 7-month-old baby still alive in Billie Jean’s arms. When police began their investigation, they found through social media that the murders were plotted by a woman named Jenelle Po ... Show More
53m 34s
Jul 2021
The SERGEANT & The Serial Killer
It was the summer of 1974. The day couldn’t be more perfect for Mary-Ann Pryor and Lorraine Kelly to go out and have fun. The two best friends had planned to go together to the Garden State Plaza, a mall in Paramus, New Jersey.💥 Exclusive Videos - https://www.patreon.com/scarymy ... Show More
13m 49s
Nov 2024
#530: Dad fakes it to the border
<p>Dad went out for a carton of milk? Jim and Kathy explore the story of a father and husband who supposedly went missing in a tragic kayaking incident, but as the story unfolds; they discover that things aren't what they seem. A double life is unveiled and the truth is somewhere ... Show More
22m 7s