logo
episode-header-image
Jul 2025
1h 3m

Pee-wee Herman Part 2 with Jamie Loftus

Sarah Marshall
About this episode

In the second part of our series, pop culture historian Jamie Loftus takes us through the meteoric rise of Pee-wee Herman and the withering of Paul Reubens' world as dubious allegations surface that threaten to turn a beloved children’s character into a real life villain. Jamie tells us about his struggle to reconcile the character of Pee-wee with the real Paul Reubens, and how his longtime friendships became his sanctuary until the very end. 

Content Warning: This episode contains discussion of explicit materials involving minors 

More about Jamie Loftus:

https://www.jamieloftus.xyz/

Support You're Wrong About:

Bonus Episodes on Patreon
Buy cute merch

Sarah's other show, You Are Good

Support the show

Up next
Nov 11
The Dictionary Wars! with Gabe Henry
Remember being a teen and coming up with “cool” ways of spelling common words? Well, just like the teenager it was, the United States in the 18th century was annoying their mom, England, with the hip words that were being edited and added to their lexicon. The antagonistic pair o ... Show More
1h 12m
Oct 28
Introducing: The Devil You Know with Sarah Marshall
Listen now to the first episode of Sarah's new 8-part series with CBC Podcasts, The Devil You Know.In the 1980s and 90s, Satan and his followers were accused of brainwashing children, sacrificing babies, and infiltrating North American society on a massive scale — yet these thous ... Show More
41m 10s
Oct 14
Midnight Ghost Shows with Chelsey Weber-Smith
What do you get when you combine a horror movie audience, a spiritualist séance, and a haunted house attraction? Beginning in the 1930s and lasting into the 1960s, midnight ghost shows were ghoulishly chaotic, wonderfully campy 4D theater performances that accompanied the scary m ... Show More
1h 43m
Recommended Episodes
Nov 2023
Journalist Tells Story of SC Mass Murderer Pee Wee Gaskins
Seton and Matt talk with Jeff Keating, host of the podcast "Pee Wee Gaskins Was Not My Friend". Pee Wee Gaskins is one of the most infamous and prolific mass murderers in South Carolina history. Alex Murdaugh's, attorney, Dick Harpootlian was the solicitor who put Pee Wee on dea ... Show More
45m 22s
Jan 2025
Episode 335: The Crimes of Peter Nygard
Peter Nygard is one of the world’s most reviled sexual predators who you may have never heard of. For decades the Canadian fashion mogul intimidated his victims into silence and paid to bury accusations made against him while trafficking underage girls to his Bahamian party mansi ... Show More
59m 22s
Jan 2025
Origins of the Devil
<p>(1/2) How has the devil been depicted through history? What are his origins? And why should he be portrayed as beautiful?</p><br><p>In the first part of a two part mini-series on Lucifer himself, Anthony and Maddy talk with Professor Michelle Brock of Washington and Lee Univer ... Show More
49m 59s
Oct 2022
#403: House of Hammer - Part 4
<p>We finish our coverage of the Discovery plus docs-series&nbsp;&nbsp;“House of Hammer” and re-focus on Armie Hammer’s aunt, Casey as well as on the terrible legacy of her grandfather, Armand Hammer.&nbsp;</p><p>Jim and Laura explain why Casey Hammer would have remained so attac ... Show More
41m 43s
Oct 15
Talking Dateline: The Prince, The Whiz Kid, & The Millionaire
<p>Lester Holt talks with Josh Mankiewicz about his episode, “The Prince, The Whiz Kid, & The Millionaire.” After retired art dealer and Palm Springs socialite Cliff Lambert vanished in 2008, investigators uncovered a plot by a group of grifters that ended in murder. Lester and J ... Show More
25m 17s
Nov 2018
Bonus Episode: Inside the TV Series "Dirty John" Part 2
<p>In the second of three special episodes, Connie Britton (“Friday Night Lights,” “Nashville”) talks about playing Debra Newell in the new Bravo series, and why the story feels timely. Julia Garner and Juno Temple, who play Newell’s daughters, discuss how they came to inhabit th ... Show More
14m 6s
Apr 2020
Crossover Week: Crimes of Passion (Lorena Bobbitt Pt. 3)
If you enjoy the true stories told in Not Guilty, check out this episode from our series Crimes of Passion: Just because John and Lorena Bobbitt were acquitted for their individual crimes in 1994 didn't mean their challenges were behind them. But while Lorena used her verdict to ... Show More
48m 37s
Feb 2023
Poacher, Pet Man - Predator: Part 2
The concluding part of the Series 8 opening tale drops this time around on The True Crime Enthusiast Podcast - where last part, we heard of the tragic tale of 16 year old Leeds schoolgirl Leanne Tiernan, who disappeared without trace one November afternoon in 2000, and who was sa ... Show More
1h 25m
Apr 2021
Monsters Of Ayrshire: Part 2 - Devil In The Dock
Continuing this series Monsters Of episodes - which has now become a trilogy - this second part of the tale continues off from the horrific account of the murder of 16 year old Mhairi Julyan, a young woman walking home from a Christmas pantomime in December 1995 who was abducted, ... Show More
53 m
Jan 2025
Failure Throwback: Jamie Dornan
I’m revisiting some of my favourite episodes this Christmas. This week it’s Jamie Dornan, whose episode went out when we were in deepest, darkest lockdown, on 24th November 2020. This is what I wrote at the time: You’ll know Jamie from starring on our screens in The Fall, Fifty S ... Show More
1h 8m