logo
episode-header-image
Jul 16
49m 32s

Ep.1: Misty is Missing

ID
About this episode
Cold case investigator Sarah Cailean takes on the 1992 disappearance of 14-year-old Misty Copsey, who vanished after an afternoon at the Washington State Fair. The only evidence ever found was a pair of jeans, socks and underwear discovered months later along the side of a highway. Misty’s mother Diana spent her life searching for answers before passing away without resolution. Now, Sarah works with Misty’s brother Colton to uncover the truth. Can Sarah figure out who took Misty Copsey – and if it’s the same person who killed two girls whose remains were found near Misty’s clothing?

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Sep 24
Your Next Listen - Mind of a Monster: The Killer Nurse
If you enjoyed Who Took Misty Copsey? you may also like Mind of a Monster: The Killer Nurse, from ID. Listen to Episode 1, "Kristen Gilbert" here, and follow Mind of a Monster wherever you get your podcasts. From 1989 to 1995, nurse Kristen Gilbert murdered four of her patients, ... Show More
38m 56s
Sep 3
Ep.8: Mine Hunting
Sarah returns to Washington with forensic anthropologist Marion Davidson to conduct a comprehensive search of the former Schmidt family farm. Following anonymous tips about specific locations on the property, Sarah and Marion dig deeper – literally and figuratively – into potenti ... Show More
50m 27s
Aug 27
Ep.7: Closing In
Sarah meets with a woman connected to Rheuban Schmidt’s family who shares chilling, decades-old allegations against Rheuban, his notorious family, and a shocking rumor from the night Misty disappeared. When Sarah visits the current owners of the former Schmidt family farm, she le ... Show More
46m 46s
Recommended Episodes
Sep 25
The Disappearance of Stefanie Damron (Maine)
Stefanie Damron’s parents say that their 13-year-old daughter walked out the door and into the woods one September afternoon in 2024, and she hasn’t been seen or heard from since. They have their own suspicions about what happened to her, but so far, a multi-agency effort hasn’t ... Show More
22m 43s
Jul 2024
The Vanishing of Melanie James
Melanie James, 21, was last seen in the spring of 2014 in Farmington, New Mexico. Melanie’s sister, Melissa, saw her walking down the street with an unidentified man on April 20. Days later, police discovered Melanie’s purse and duffel bag in an alleyway in Farmington, but saw no ... Show More
34m 50s
Mar 2024
The Turn of the Windmill: The Disappearance of Debra Ann Wilhite
On October 14, 1974, 19-year-old Debra Ann Wilhite vanished after leaving her job at The Windmill, a truck-stop-slash-restaurant in Evansville, Indiana. Nearly fifty years later, she still hasn't been found. In this episode, The Murder Sheet sits down with Debra's daughter Misty ... Show More
1h 43m
Sep 5
Dateline Missing in America – Ep. 24: The Cold Case of Nancy Snow
On November 4, 1980, 44-year-old Nancy Snow boarded a flight to Baltimore from St. Louis, Missouri, where she had spent several months working on Gene McNary’s U.S. Senate campaign. That night she went to a party in Baltimore; the next morning she had breakfast with the party’s h ... Show More
44m 47s
Jul 30
Casefile Presents: Julie's Gone
Julie Ann Garciacelay was not quite 20 when she vanished from her inner-city apartment in Melbourne 50 years ago.Three men who were with her that night in July 1975 told police the young American left to make a phone call and didn’t return. One would be linked to the infamous Eas ... Show More
4m 6s
Aug 2024
243- The Murder of Shirley McAvoy
When thirty-two year old Shirley McAvoy didn't show up for her youngest daughter's birthday everyone knew something was wrong.  After being unable to reach her, Shirley's estranged husband, Brian, reported her missing to the Pittsfield Police Department in Maine. Initially, inves ... Show More
1h 14m
Mar 2024
238 - The Vanishing of Lola Katherine Fry
On November 13th, 1993, twenty-eight year old Lola Katherine Fry attended a party at a northeastside Indianapolis apartment owned by a friend.  She has never been seen again and more than thirty years later the mystery of her disappearance haunts family and friends. Reported miss ... Show More
1h 27m
May 2025
MISSING: The Mishawaka Girls
Nic Monroe is in a rut. At twenty-four, she lives alone in a dinky apartment in her hometown of Mishawaka, Indiana, she’s just gotten a DWI, and she works the same dead-end job she’s been working since high school, a job she only has because her boss is a family friend and feels ... Show More
7m 1s
Jul 24
The Disappearance of Starlette Vining (Maine)
Starlette Vining disappeared in 1998 and has never been found, yet 15 years after she was last seen in the small town of Presque Isle, Maine, a suspect was convicted of her murder. This is a wide-open look at how a cold missing persons case was successfully investigated and solve ... Show More
38m 9s
Sep 2
Episode 1167: Missing child not seen for three years may have been killed and hidden
Police are hunting for a second young child discovered to have been missing for years after a woman told social workers he had been killed.The child, who would now be seven years old, hasn’t been seen since he was three and his disappearance was only reported on the anniversary o ... Show More
13m 14s