The boys take it back to the OG days with one of their first subjects covered way back when… we’re crackin’ open the old toy box for a full-on gold star redux on David Parker Ray a.k.a. The Toy-Box Killer (and his Torture Lab of Terror), this time diving even deeper into the life of one of New Mexico’s worst villains often described as one of the most sadist ... Show More
Jan 9
Last Update on the Left - Episode 11 - Return to Skinwalker Ranch
Something strange is going on in northeastern Utah, and this week on Last Update on the Left, the boys head deep into the mysteries of Skinwalker Ranch. From its infamous former owners and the bizarre phenomena that drove them out, to the current stewards and the reality shows th ... Show More
51m 46s
Jan 7
Side Stories: New Year's Evil
Henry & Eddie bring you 2026's biggest stories and true crime news - The strange truth behind the US takeover of Venezuela: Star Gates, The Epstein Files: UN-redacted, Mysterious deaths begin to pile up in Bayous of Houston Texas, Anti-Trans Alaska state medical board member dies ... Show More
59m 56s
Sep 2025
Bonus Episode: Mystery Recordings and Tortured Geniuses
This week in the After Party, Jake takes a closer look at the tales of mysterious rumored recordings from music history. Plus, your voicemails, DMs, and emails! On Tuesday, we're bringing you a new episode on 50 Cent, and Jake wants to know: Which hip hop artist (living or dead) ... Show More
38m 44s
Jul 2025
MURDEROUS MINDS: The Two-Faced Killer Pt. 2
After murdering his entire family, John List vanished without a trace—beginning one of America’s most infamous manhunts. In Part 2, we follow the chilling aftermath: the gruesome discovery, the decades-long search, and the primetime TV show that finally caught the killer hiding i ... Show More
46m 54s
Sep 2025
SERIAL KILLER: The Dating Game Killer Pt. 2
Rodney Alcala thought he was smarter than the police, the jury, and even the justice system. In Part 2, we follow the unraveling of "The Dating Game" Killer, from a failed attempt at self-defense to the discovery of a chilling trophy stash that linked him to more murders than any ... Show More
52m 3s
Aug 2025
SERIAL KILLER: "The Killer Boy" Pt. 2
He was America’s youngest serial killer—and his most brutal crime was still to come. In Part 2, we follow the murder that sealed Jesse Pomeroy’s fate, the investigation that exposed a disturbing pattern, and the historic trial that forced the country to confront how young is too ... Show More
45m 4s
Feb 2025
Dateline Presents: Murder in the Moonlight
<p>Hey Dateline fans! As a bonus, we’re giving you a special preview clip of our new podcast series, Murder in the Moonlight. </p><p>In this podcast, Keith Morrison takes listeners to a quiet farmhouse on America’s Great Plains, where Sharmon and Wayne Stock have just celebrated ... Show More
3m 24s