logo
episode-header-image
Jul 2
32m 7s

Ret FBI Breaks Down The Ridiculous 3rd P...

True Crime Today
About this episode
This was recorded BEFORE Bryan Kohberger's Plea Deal-
Ret FBI Breaks Down The Ridiculous 3rd Party Claim Kohberger's Team Wanted You To Believe

In a startling courtroom twist, Bryan Kohberger’s defense team attempted to introduce the notion of an unidentified third-party culprit responsible for the gruesome murders of four Idaho college students. Judge Hippler swiftly rejected this controversial tactic, dismissing it as unsubstantiated and unsupported by credible evidence. While some saw this as an act of legal desperation, others wonder if there’s a deeper strategic motivation behind such an unusual and seemingly far-fetched claim.

Retired FBI Special Agent Robin Dreeke, a respected expert in human behavior, credibility analysis, and jury psychology, offers a detailed breakdown of why such third-party claims rarely find traction in high-stakes murder trials. Robin explores the psychological strategies employed by defense attorneys in introducing alternative suspects, even when they know the odds of acceptance are slim.

Could the defense have hoped to subtly introduce doubt in jurors' minds before trial even begins? Is Anne Taylor intentionally planting seeds of confusion and uncertainty among potential jurors who inevitably follow news coverage closely? Robin dissects these subtle tactics, explaining the psychological dynamics that defense teams leverage to influence juror perceptions long before jury selection occurs.

Drawing from extensive courtroom experience, Robin discusses real-world examples illustrating why juries typically reject vague third-party claims and how such strategies can potentially backfire, making the defense appear desperate rather than strategic. Robin also highlights the critical difference between effective doubt creation and overplaying one’s hand with weak, unsupported claims.

Join us for an insightful, behind-the-scenes look at courtroom strategies, psychological manipulation, and how modern trial tactics increasingly rely on shaping public perception. Discover why, even when claims seem absurd, they might serve a deeper strategic purpose in today's complex legal landscape.

Hashtags:
#BryanKohberger #ThirdPartyClaim #CourtroomStrategy #RobinDreeke #DefenseTactics #JuryPsychology #TrueCrimeCommunity #LegalAnalysis #IdahoMurders #JusticeForIdaho4

Want to comment and watch this podcast as a video? 

Check out our YouTube Channel. https://www.youtube.com/@hiddenkillerspod
Instagram https://www.instagram.com/hiddenkillerspod/
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/hiddenkillerspod/
Tik-Tok
https://www.tiktok.com/@hiddenkillerspod
X Twitter
https://x.com/tonybpod

Listen Ad-Free On Apple Podcasts Here:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/true-crime-today-premium-plus-ad-free-advance-episode/id1705422872

Up next
Yesterday
The Idaho Murders: The First 72 Hours Of Kohberger’s Chaos
In this episode of Hidden Killers with Tony Brueski, we pull back the curtain on the most misleading—and most dangerous—phase of any major crime story: the first 72 hours. Using the Bryan Kohberger case as a case study, Tony dissects how the earliest reporting on the University o ... Show More
16m 50s
Oct 8
Forgetting Bryan Kohberger: A Mother’s Powerful Choice
In the face of unthinkable tragedy, Stacy Chapin, the mother of slain University of Idaho student Ethan Chapin, chose a path of grace over vengeance. This deeply moving commentary from Hidden Killers explores her powerful decision to not let Bryan Kohberger—the accused killer—def ... Show More
13m 58s
Oct 7
Buried in a Box: Bryan Kohberger’s Miserable Life Behind Bars
What does life look like for Bryan Kohberger now that he’s off the front page and locked inside one of Idaho’s most restrictive prisons? In this episode of Hidden Killers with Tony Brueski, we go inside the Idaho Maximum Security Institution—home to death row, long-term restricti ... Show More
15m 25s
Recommended Episodes
Jun 2025
Arson, Ego & Apologies: FBI Behavioral Analysis of Diddy’s Alleged Tactics
Arson, Ego & Apologies: FBI Behavioral Analysis of Diddy’s Alleged Tactics When Kid Cudi’s Porsche was firebombed, it wasn’t just an act of destruction — it may have been a message. In this episode of Hidden Killers, former FBI behavioral analyst Robin Dreeke joins us to analyze ... Show More
10m 7s
Sep 2023
Conspiracy in Canton - 001
It’s one of the most polarizing cases in true crime right now. A 16 year veteran of the Boston Police Department, left to die in one of the biggest blizzards in Massachusetts history. Prosecution has charged his girlfriend, 42 year old Karen Read, with his murder, claiming she hi ... Show More
56m 19s
Apr 2024
The Endless Pit: Alex Murdaugh's Fight Against Fate
In a compelling episode of "Hidden Killers With Tony Brueski," guest Jennifer Coffindaffer, a retired FBI Special Agent, delves into the complex web of Alex Murdaugh's legal troubles following his 40-year federal prison sentence for financial crimes. This sentence, harsher than a ... Show More
7m 33s
Aug 21
A TikTok teen charged with murder. A defense team requests evidence testing. Plus, interrogation tactics.
17 year old Sarah Grace Patrick is accused of gunning down her mother and stepfather in Georgia. The defense team of the man accused of killing UNC Chapel Hill student Faith Hedgepeth in 2012 has filed motions that raise new questions about crime scene evidence. Updates on Florid ... Show More
26m 39s
Feb 2025
2.14.25 CRU with Nancy Grace: Mystery DNA in the Kohberger Case - What That Could Mean For The Defense
Today Nancy Grace and Sheryl McCollum open CRU with a heartfelt tribute to their friend and colleague, Dave Mack, following the loss of his wife, LaDonna. Despite his grief, Mack’s dedication to his work shines through. Nancy and Sheryl then dive into the latest developments in t ... Show More
29m 26s
Feb 2025
REWIND | The Weleetka Murders
Two young girls shot dead in a town of less than 1000 people. With local law enforcement stumped, they turned to the renowned FBI Behavioral Analysis Unit for answers. Julia Cowley is a retired FBI criminal profiler with a twist - she's a forensic scientist too. In this episode w ... Show More
51m 35s
Mar 2025
Emotional testimony from a killer. A murder defendant's unusual defense. And travel scam safety tips.
Listen to this week's episode of the Dateline: True Crime Weekly podcast with Andrea Canning. A California jury hears chilling details about the murder of hairstylist Fabio Sementilli from the man who admits he helped kill him. In Kansas, the lead detective on a double murder cas ... Show More
28m 52s
Jan 2025
Verdict in the pharmacist poisoning trial. A deadly love triangle in paradise? And Bryan Kohberger is back in court.
Listen to this week's episode of the Dateline: True Crime Weekly podcast with Andrea Canning. In West Virginia, there was emotional testimony last week from the children of the pharmacist accused of poisoning her husband. This week the jury returned its verdict.  KHNL reporter Ma ... Show More
28m 4s
Aug 7
The Michael Proctor files. Parents of murdered daughter want answers. And behind the scenes with a CSI.
Prosecutors at the Norfolk County Superior Court in Massachusetts share new details in the murder case against disgraced art salesman Brian Walshe, just two months after they finished one of the biggest trials of the year -- Karen Read. And Michael Proctor, the lead investigator ... Show More
28m 27s