logo
episode-header-image
Jun 26
1h 59m

Aaron Stupple & Logan Chipkin — The Sove...

Jim O'Shaughnessy
About this episode

What if everything we think we know about raising children is not just wrong, but actively harmful? Aaron Stupple and Logan Chipkin, authors of "The Sovereign Child," join Infinite Loops to make a case so compelling and radical that it challenges the very foundation of modern parenting and education.

From birth, we're told that children need rules, structure, and authority to thrive. But what if this approach is crushing their natural creativity, problem-solving abilities, and authentic self-development? Stupple and Chipkin argue that children are people—full stop. They have reasons, preferences, and the capacity to make decisions about their own lives, yet we systematically ignore this reality in favor of compliance and control.

We dive deep into their concept of the "foul four"—the four devastating ways that imposing non-consensual rules damages children's relationships with themselves, their parents, problem-solving itself, and their understanding of how to navigate the world. From the arbitrary nature of bedtimes to the deeper psychological damage of forcing gratitude and politeness, this conversation will make you question every "because I said so" moment in your childhood and parenting. Whether you're a parent, educator, or simply someone interested in human flourishing, this episode offers a radically different lens through which to view childhood, autonomy, and what it means to raise great adults.

Important Links:

Show Notes:

  • Opening & The Radical Quote
  • The Childhood Inversion Problem
  • False Dichotomy: Control vs. Neglect
  • AI Steel-manning the Opposition
  • Edge Cases and Prohibition Parallels
  • Podcast Host Reactions & Food Wars
  • Evolutionary Food Arguments
  • Raising Great Adults
  • Scaling Challenges & Sleep Dilemmas
  • Market Opportunities & Historical Context
  • Why Alternative Schools Didn’t Scale
  • The Foul Four Explained
  • Game Rules vs. Imposed Rules
  • Etiquette, Manners & Sibling Conflicts
  • The Bully Problem & Popper’s Paradox
  • Class and Economics Arguments
  • Rules Built on Sand
  • Falsification & Moral Philosophy
  • Conformity, Culture & Progress
  • Emotional Intelligence & Propaganda
  • Self-Silencing & Social Dynamics
  • The School Persona Revelation
  • Emperor of the World
  • Matilda & Closing Thoughts

Books Mentioned:

  • The Sovereign Child: How a Forgotten Philosophy Can Liberate Kids and Their Parents (Aaron Stupple with Logan Chipkin)
  • Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (Dr. Robert Cialdini)
  • The Open Society and Its Enemies (Karl Popper)
  • What the Tortoise Said to Achilles (Lewis Carroll)
  • No Country for Old Men (Cormac McCarthy)
  • One Summer: America 1927 (Bill Bryson)
  • Alice in Wonderland (Lewis Carroll)
  • Matilda (Roald Dahl)

Authors Mentioned:

  • Jed McKenna
  • Jonathan Haidt
  • Edward Bernays
  • Robert Solomon
  • David Deutsch

Up next
Jul 3
Rupert Sheldrake — On Scientism, Morphic Resonance and the Extended Mind (Infinite Loops CLASSICS)
Hello everyone, Jim here. We're taking a brief two-week break from new episodes to spotlight a couple of golden oldies from the Infinite Loops archive. Years later, these remain some of my favorite conversations. We’ll be back soon with fresh episodes, but in the meantime, enjoy ... Show More
1h 7m
Jun 19
Nadia Asparouhova — An Antimemetic Rollercoaster
Nadia Asparouhova, author of "Antimemetics: Why Some Ideas Resist Spreading," joins me for a fascinating exploration of why some ideas go viral while others—often the most important ones—resist transmission entirely. We dive into antimemes, Curtis Yarvin's journey from being canc ... Show More
1h 31m
Jun 5
Dr. Diane Hennacy Powell — Speculations in Post-Materialism (EP.271)
Dr. Diane Hennacy Powell, neuropsychiatrist and author of "The ESP Enigma," joins me for a mind-bending exploration of consciousness, savant abilities, and the limitations of materialist science. Trained at Johns Hopkins under a neurologist-turned-psychiatrist, Diane has spent de ... Show More
1h 26m
Recommended Episodes
Nov 2024
220. Is Your Attention Span Shrinking?
Does a surplus of information create a shortage of attention? Are today’s young people really unable to focus? And do goldfish need better PR?  SOURCES:Neil Bradbury, professor of physiology at Rosalind Franklin University.Nicholas Carr, writer and journalist.Johann Hari, writer ... Show More
37m 11s
Feb 2025
523. Why We Dream, Learn, and Adapt Faster Than Any Other Species | Dr. David Eagleman
Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down with neuroscientist, bestselling author, and PBS presenter Dr. David Eagleman. They discuss brain plasticity, how perception works, whether free will exists (and if it’s superordinate), how willingness to engage with higher entropy indicates sophi ... Show More
1h 30m
Oct 2024
S2: 7. Wonderland
In the 1990s a group of futurist thinkers meet on one of the world’s first email lists. The Extropians imagine a world of augmented human bodies, nanotechnology, cryptocurrencies and artificial intelligence. Now, some of the thinkers on that email list are turning that AI future ... Show More
39m 48s
Dec 2024
#782: Legendary Inventor Danny Hillis (Plus Kevin Kelly) — Unorthodox Lessons from 400+ Patents, Solving the Impossible, Real Al vs. “AI”, Hiring Richard Feynman, Working with Steve Jobs, Creating Par
Danny Hillis is an inventor, scientist, author, and engineer. While completing his doctorate at MIT, he pioneered the parallel computers that are the basis for the processors used for AI and most high-performance computer chips. He is now a founding partner with Applied Invention ... Show More
2h 36m
Jul 2024
Your Brain is a Storyteller — Theodore H. Schwartz
In his new book, Gray Matters: A Biography of Brain Surgery, neurosurgeon Dr. Theodore Schwartz delves into the history and practice of neuroscience. What he and his fellow scientists have discovered is that our lives are based on stories that our brains construct, and those stor ... Show More
33m 51s
Apr 22
Charles Augustus Milverton - Part One
THE SLITHERING SERPENT - Penny returned to us and it wasn't the apology that we were grateful for. It was the lead. A lead to the man who harvests the world's secrets. Quite how we could stomach even just a few minutes with this enormous wanker is still slightly beyond my compreh ... Show More
42m 19s
Aug 2024
Sendhil Mullainathan Thinks Messing Around Is the Best Use of Your Time (Update)
Revisiting Steve’s 2021 conversation with the economist and MacArthur “genius” about how to make memories stickier, why change is undervalued, and how to find something new to say on the subject of scarcity. SOURCE:Sendhil Mullainathan, university professor of computation and beh ... Show More
46m 54s
Apr 24
Consciousness, Reasoning and the Philosophy of AI with Murray Shanahan
In this episode, Hannah is once again joined by Murray Shanahan, Professor of Cognitive Robotics at Imperial College London and Principal Scientist at Google DeepMind, for a philosophical deep dive on AI. They explore everything from consciousness and metacognition in animals, to ... Show More
40m 30s
Oct 2024
142. What’s Impacting American Workers?
David Autor took his first economics class at 29 years old. Now he’s one of the central academics studying the labor market. The M.I.T. economist and Steve dissect the impact of technology on labor, spar on A.I., and discuss why economists can sometimes be oblivious. SOURCES:Davi ... Show More
1h 3m
Nov 2024
The Tech-God Complex: Why We Need to be Skeptics
Silicon Valley's interest in AI is driven by more than just profit and innovation. There’s an unmistakable mystical quality to it as well. In this episode, Daniel and Aza sit down with humanist chaplain Greg Epstein to explore the fascinating parallels between technology and reli ... Show More
46m 32s