In this episode, Payton and Garrett examine the mysterious disappearance of Kelly Dwyer. When Kelly fails to show up for work, her friends and family begin retracing her final known movements leading to the man she was last seen with. What unfolds is a chilling story of secrets, red flags, and a shocking twist that would take years to uncover.
Links:
Pat ... Show More
Yesterday
312. Murder of the Hotel Heir - Benji Novack
On this episode, Payton and Garrett explore the strange and tragic case of Benji Novack, a millionaire businessman with an obsession for Batman memorabilia. When he’s found brutally murdered in his hotel room, investigators must dig through a long list of suspects to uncover the ... Show More
51m 2s
Mar 9
311. A Love Affair That Turned Deadly - The Murder of Steven Beard
On this episode, Payton and Garrett dive into the case of Steven Beard. When the wealthy retired man calls 911 claiming his stomach literally exploded, police are shocked to figure out what really happened. Links: Netflix Video Every Monday @11am PST, 12pm MST, 2pm EST 1pm CST ht ... Show More
49m 54s
Mar 2
310. The Suspicious Death of Lois McMillen
On this episode, Garrett and Payton explore a brutal murder that shattered a quiet island paradise. As authorities rush to make arrests, doubts grow, as some believe the true killer might be free. Links Netflix Video Every Monday @11am PST, 12pm MST, 2pm EST 1pm CST https://www.n ... Show More
47m 45s
Sep 2025
KIDNAPPED: Sherri Papini
When Sherri Papini vanished during a jog in 2016, the search gripped the nation. Morgan and Kaelyn revisit the twists in this bizarre kidnapping case: a frantic husband’s 911 call, a nationwide hunt, Sherri’s shocking roadside reappearance, and the clues—DNA, text messages, and a ... Show More
1h 25m
Sep 2025
MISSING: Asha Degree
She was smart, cautious, and afraid of strangers. So why did 9-year-old Asha Degree leave her North Carolina home in the middle of the night and vanish forever? Now, 25 years later, Morgan and Kaelyn revisit the key evidence: the missing backpack, a mysterious green car, and a DN ... Show More
1h 17m