logo
episode-header-image
Jun 20
59m 32s

Episode 21: Why won’t Haredim serve in t...

Haviv Rettig Gur
About this episode

Haredi Israelis make up some 13% of the population but have extremely low rates of workforce participation and military service. The growing welfare subsidies that sustain their communities have increasingly become a source of tensions and frustration for other Israelis, and the multi-front war that began on October 7 has now made their exemptions from military service a major political issue. Israel needs more workers, less welfare spending and many more soldiers to thrive in the future. Can the Haredi community change? What happens if it doesn't?


We spoke with Shmuel Rosner, senior fellow at the Jewish People Policy Institute and veteran journalist and analyst. Rosner has studied the Haredi community and the policy debates on these questions. He's the editor and publisher of the political website The Madad, themadad.com, which we recommend for, among other things, its aggregation of polling and political writing from across the spectrum of Israeli media.


This episode was sponsored by Julie and Frank Cohen because they believe this podcast is a way to teach our story, and because understanding our past and present is key to building a better future.


Julie and Frank have asked to dedicate this episode to someone we lost on October 7.


Today we remember Yochai Azulay, 28, from Holon, was murdered while trying to flee the Hamas attack on the Supernova music festival on October 7. Born in Tel Aviv, Yohai grew up in a traditionally religious family and spent much of his time devoted to exploring his roots and his connection to Judaism. He served in the Kfir Brigade during his mandatory military service, and after his release, he toured around South America. After his return, Yohai soon met his girlfriend, Noa, and the pair were planning a future together.


If you would like to sponsor an episode, please email us at haviv@askhavivanything.com.

Up next
Aug 22
Episode 37: The genocidal claim of genocide with Adam Louis-Klein
Many of our Patreon subscribers have asked us to address the campaign against Israel that accuses it of genocide, colonialism and so on. This episode is the beginning of our deep dive into examining these questions.What do anti-Zionists argue? What do they want? When is it antise ... Show More
58m 1s
Aug 8
Episode 35: Solving hunger in Gaza with Prof. Yannay Spitzer
Professor Yannay Spitzer is an economic historian who has studied food and hunger. His efforts over the past month to get real reliable data on hunger out of Gaza and publicize it to Israelis, data that is neither delayed nor politicized like the many claims of rampant hunger mad ... Show More
52m 44s
Aug 6
Episode 34: My life in Al-Qaeda, a conversation with Aimen Dean
Aimen Dean was once a fervent young jihadi fighter, a passionate believer in radical Sunni Islam who had memorized the Quran by 12 and was fighting in the Bosnian jihad by 16.Haviv talked to Aimen about the religious and psychological journey of a young jihadi, his experiences in ... Show More
2h 9m
Recommended Episodes
Oct 2024
Yahya Sinwar’s death
On Thursday, the Israeli military announced it had killed Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar in an operation in southern Gaza the day prior. Sinwar was one of the primary architects of Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack on Israel and was believed to have been hiding in Gaza’s tunnel system since the a ... Show More
29m 5s
Jul 2024
INTERVIEW: Isaac talks with Alon Gat
Isaac got to talk with Alon Gat. He recounts his harrowing experience on October 7th, what happened to him and his family, the current situation, and his hope for the future of Israelis and Palestinians. You can subscribe to Tangle by clicking here or drop something in our tip ja ... Show More
51m 22s
Apr 2025
77 and counting - with Eyal Waldman (featuring Emily Damari)
Unholy is going live in London! Join Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland for a special night of news and great guests: Yuval Noah Harari, Andy Nyman and Mira Awad—live on stage, June 8th 2025. If you’ve ever wanted to see the podcast come to life, now’s your chance. Reserve your se ... Show More
1h 3m
Oct 2024
The Sunday Podcast: An interview with Dr. Noam Weissman
Since Isaac is off coaching his frisbee team to a national championship, Ari and he couldn't record a Sunday podcast for you all. So to make up for that, we are releasing last week's special Friday edition interview for you all to enjoy. To listen to this and all our other podcas ... Show More
1h 3m
Jun 2024
The Sunday Podcast: Isaac and Ari talk about Project 2025, the latest inflation report, and Ari shares a ghost story.
On today's episode, Ari shares a ghost story, Isaac and Ari talk about Project 2025, the latest inflation report and the partisan views around it, and as always, the Airing of Grievances. You can catch our latest YouTube video, an interview with Alyssa Cass and Pat Rosenstiel, an ... Show More
1h 2m
Aug 2024
The HIV-Positive Ray Brothers House Is Burned Down (1987) w/ Eric Marcus
Come to our first ever live show! In Boston, on Friday, September 13th. Tickets are available now!It's August 29th. This day in 1987, an arson burns down the house of the Ray brothers, three HIV-positive children who had contracted the virus through blood transfusions.Jody, NIki, ... Show More
24m 21s
Apr 2023
Changing Culture, Career Insights and Outcomes with Jason Lengstorf
Our 100th episode special with Jason Lengstorf! It's been a while since we've done an in-person episode, but Jason happened to be in the neighbourhood, so we made it happen 🙌 We had a blast and kept rolling longer than usual with exciting discussions on various topics 🚀 ... Show More
1h 51m
May 2019
Episode 6: The .01 Percent
In this episode, Israeli poet Tahel Frosh talks to us about her debut poetry collection Betsa (Avarice, 2014), financial crisis, and the value of culture. We revisit the summer of 2011, when a series of protests spread across Israel sparked by rising housing costs, the increased ... Show More
27m 46s
Aug 12
Interviewing A Gym Bro In Gaza
Donate Here: https://chuffed.org/project/142592-help-gym-rat-and-his-family-survive-gazas-genocideOn this week’s episode of RAW TALK, Brad sits down with Mohammed from Gaza and talks about growing up through 9 wars, being displaced 13 times, training in the rubble of his bombed h ... Show More
58m 8s
Aug 2024
Episode 753 | "The Bleepless Pod"
In the latest dudecast episode from the JBP, Joe reacts to Kanye West singing his name during his ‘Vultures Listening Experience’ event in Korea (36:40) before turning to Lil Yachty’s recent exchange with his podcast co-host Mitch (45:44) and his rant about Karrahbooo (57:39). J- ... Show More
4h 34m