logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2025
1h 34m

197 - Same-Sex Attraction and Conversion...

CatholicCulture.org
About this episode

We all know the secular world opposes the very idea of a person with same-sex attraction seeking any kind of therapy or spiritual counsel that might enable them to reach a state of healthy relations with the opposite sex. But what's odd is that many Catholics seem to have bought into this. Many assume that if someone is not currently attracted to the opposite sex, this is a static, lifelong condition and therefore they must be called to celibacy. But this view involves multiple misunderstandings – of the SSA experience, of anthropology, of the power of God's grace, and of the good of celibacy itself.

Today's guests know otherwise because they both have a background with same-sex attraction, and yet are each now married with children. Andrew Comiskey and Marco Casanova run Desert Stream and Living Waters Ministries, which for decades have offered help to Christians seeking healing from sexual disorders (including but not limited to SSA). This conversation offers solid, spiritually and psychologically sound, experience-based answers to some disputed questions about how the Church should be pastoring those with same-sex attraction.

It's not about "conversion therapy". It's about conversion in the Catholic sense – one day at a time.

--Can we really put a ceiling on God's ability to heal us psychologically?

--Does any attempt at such healing amount to the secular bugbear of "conversion therapy"?

--What does life look like for a person with a "gay" past who is now married to the opposite sex?

--Is it legitimate for Christians to embrace a gay identity as long as they don't act out sexually?

--Is there such a thing as a chaste same-sex romantic relationship?

Links

Thomas Mirus, "Your sexual pathology doesn't make you special" https://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/your-sexual-pathology-doesnt-make-you-special/

Andrew Comiskey, Rediscovering Our Lost Fullness: A Guide to Sexual Integration https://sophiainstitute.com/product/rediscovering-our-lost-fullness/

Desert Stream Ministries http://www.desertstream.org/

Desert Stream on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJVUJQREephvIkJWlTuwXBg

DONATE to make this show possible! http://catholicculture.org/donate/audio

SIGN UP for Catholic Culture's newsletter: https://www.catholicculture.org/newsletters

Up next
Nov 21
The Most Dangerous Man in England: Newman and the Laity - Paul Shrimpton
<p>Paul Shrimpton assisted in the process of making St. John Henry Newman a Doctor of the Church. He joins the podcast to discuss his involvement in the process, and his new book from Word on Fire Academic, "<em>The Most Dangerous Man in England": Newman and the Laity</em>.</p> < ... Show More
1h 30m
Nov 14
Should mothers work outside the home? w/ Margaret H. McCarthy
Should mothers work outside the home? If you want an answer more solid than groundless internet opinion or conveniently vague appeals to personal discernment, this is the podcast for you. Margaret McCarthy joins the Catholic Culture Podcast to discuss her essay on why anti-sex-di ... Show More
1h 51m
Oct 22
Triumph of the Heart director faced glorious trials making great Catholic art - w/ Anthony D'Ambrosio
An episode from Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast, too good not to share for Catholic Culture Podcast listeners! Anthony D'Ambrosio directed, wrote, and produced the outstanding new film Triumph of the Heart about St. Maximilian Kolbe. In this inspiring interview, he discusses ... Show More
54m 31s
Recommended Episodes
Sep 2024
Stigmata: Miracle Or Hoax?
In this episode of The Catholic Talk Show, the guys are joined by Dr. Paul Kengor to discuss the phenomenon of The Stigmata where Saints like Padre Pio, Saint Paul, Saint Catherine of Sienna, and more, miraculously bear the wounds of Christ. Learn more about your ad choices. Visi ... Show More
52m 2s
Sep 2023
Ephesians Part 1 • Dr. Matthew Richardson • Oct 2 - Oct 8
<p><b>How does conversion rely upon revelation and revelators? Dr. Matthew Richardson examines Paul’s letter to the Ephesians, discusses conversion, and how God reveals mysteries through revelation to His children.<br/><br/></b>Show Notes (English, French, Spanish, Portuguese): h ... Show More
1h 16m
May 2025
The Three Temptations of St. Katherine | Metropolitan Neophytos
In this episode, Metropolitan Neophytos of Morphou deliveres an inspiring homily reflecting on the life and virtues of St. Katherine of Alexandria, highlighting her exceptional wisdom, beauty, and wealth in the ancient world. He emphasizes how St. Katherine’s gifts became her gre ... Show More
16m 27s
May 2025
Exorcism, Spiritual Warfare, and S*xuall Abuse (Fr. Dan Reehil) | Ep. 525
Father Dan Reehil is a Catholic priest who transitioned from a successful Wall Street career to the priesthood after a life-changing pilgrimage to Medjugorje in 1998. This spiritual conversion led him to leave New York after 9/11 and begin priestly formation in Boston. He was ord ... Show More
2h 18m
Oct 2024
Episode #110- October 16, 2024: Fall Saints That We Fall in Love With
#110 Fall Saints That We Fall in Love With In this episode, Stacy, Lauren, and Annie share about their Confirmation Saints and other Saints whose feast days are in Autumn and how they have pursued them over the years. The Message of St. Therese of Lisieux by Mgr Vernon Johnson St ... Show More
38m 12s
Feb 2025
Faith that Heals w/ Fr. Mathias Thelen
<p dir="ltr">This week, Jake and Bob are joined by Fr. Mathias Thelen, Co-Founder and President of Encounter Ministries and Pastor of St. Patrick Catholic Parish in Brighton. Fr. Mathias shares his story of experiencing the transformative power of the Holy Spirit, encountering an ... Show More
1h 5m
Apr 2025
BONUS: All About Saints of the First Monasteries (with Fr. Gregory Pine and Fr. Boniface Hicks)
A new "Catholic Classics" season with Fr. Mike Schmitz is coming this fall! In the meantime, Ascension has released a new book in the Catholic Classics series titled "Saints of the First Monasteries." Fr. Boniface Hicks, a contributor to the book, joins Fr. Gregory Pine to explor ... Show More
25m 18s
Oct 2024
History of Greek-American Monasticism (Pt.1) - With Constantine Zalalas
<p><b>Part 1: History of Greek-American Monasticism - With Constantine Zalalas</b><br/><br/>Mr. Zalalas is an international speaker and retreat master for all Orthodox jurisdictions in the United States and abroad. He holds Masters (with honors) in Dogmatic Theology from the Univ ... Show More
57m 15s
Oct 15
The State of the Church (Raymond Arroyo) | Ep. 546
In this episode, Matt interviews Raymond Arroyo—host of EWTN's "The World Over," New York Times Best Selling author, award-winning producer, chart topping vocalist and broadcaster, and podcast host. The conversation touches on the papacy (specifically the differences between JPII ... Show More
2h 25m