logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2025
47m 17s

301. Why do we love true crime?

iHeartPodcasts
About this episode

Why are we so obsessed with the dark side of life? From true crime and horror movies to disaster documentaries and haunted house tours, morbid curiosity is everywhere - but what does it actually say about us? In today’s episode, we explore the psychology of morbid curiosity - why we’re drawn to frightening, disturbing, and even grotesque content, and how this strange pull might be more adaptive than we think.

We discuss:

  • What morbid curiosity really is, and how it shows up in daily life
  • The four types of morbid curiosity (and which ones you might lean toward)
  • How personality traits like openness and sensation seeking shape our preferences
  • Why some people find comfort in horror, and others find control in true crime
  • The evolutionary and neurological roots of this phenomenon
  • How morbid curiosity can turn maladaptive (and where the line is)

Whether you're deep into Reddit rabbit holes or just wondering why you can't look away from crime scene documentaries, this episode is for you. We explore the fascinating science behind fear, survival, and our cultural obsession with darkness - and why it might say more about our strength than our weakness.

 

ORDER MY BOOK: https://www.psychologyofyour20s.com/general-clean

Follow Jemma on Instagram: @jemmasbeg

Follow the podcast on Instagram: @thatpsychologypodcast

For business: psychologyofyour20s@gmail.com

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Up next
Oct 7
340. The 10 regrets I have about my 20s (so far)
Today I'm reflecting on some of the lessons I've been taking from my early 20s. We all have regrets about things we wish we'd done differently or not done at all, and I'm hoping you can learn from mine. We talk about everything from bad financial decisions, ghosting friends, stay ... Show More
39m 2s
Oct 2
339. The psychology of rock bottom
Hitting rock bottom is one of the most painful human experiences - when the future is blurry, the past feels heavy, and you barely recognize the person staring back in the mirror. Maybe it’s the end of a relationship, losing your job, battling addiction, or simply feeling like ev ... Show More
40m 1s
Oct 1
I Am Not Here To Manage Other People's Emotions
In this bonus release, I am sharing an episode of my other podcast, MANTRA. This week's mantra is I Am Not Here to Manage Other People’s Emotions. It's a common trap to feel responsible for the feelings of those around us, often at the expense of our own emotional well-being. But ... Show More
32m 24s
Recommended Episodes
Aug 23
#984 - Coltan Scrivner - Why We’re Drawn to Death, Crime, & Danger
Coltan Scrivner is a behavioral scientist, an expert on morbid curiosity in horror and true‑crime media, and an author. Why are humans so curious about death? From car accidents to scary stories, roller coasters, and horror movies, some people are fascinated while others are repu ... Show More
1h 6m
Sep 22
Why Are We Morbidly Curious - The Paranormal Podcast 902
Why do we slow down to stare at accidents, binge horror movies, or devour true crime podcasts? What draws us toward the dark and disturbing even when it frightens us? To explore this fascinating question, I’m joined by Dr. Colton Scrivner, a behavioral scientist and the world’s l ... Show More
43m 44s
Oct 2024
Exploring the Science of Spookiness at the Recreational Fear Lab
Why do so many of us love a good scare? Whether it’s horror movies, haunted houses or creepy podcasts, there’s something thrilling about feeling spooked—especially around Halloween. In this episode, host Rachel Feltman dives into our fascination with fear and morbid curiosity wit ... Show More
17m 32s
Aug 2024
The Science of Morbid Curiosity w/ Dr. Coltan Scrivner
This week Scott is joined by true crime and morbid curiosity psychologist, Dr. Coltan Scrivner. Scott and Dr. Scrivner discuss how to determine your level of interest in morbid curiosity, why some people have a higher level of tolerance (and even attraction) to scary things, and ... Show More
1 h
Jul 2024
The BLACK Eyed Kids - Face To Face With These Freaky Children
All throughout history and in basically every culture around the world, you’ll find stories about creatures with eyes so black, they’re like staring into the abyss. If you’re one of the unlucky ones that finds yourself making contact with them, they invoke a feeling of immense dr ... Show More
26m 16s
Dec 2024
The Kansas City Vampire - Convinced he had to eat human flesh to live?! (Podcast Exclusive)
Hi friends, happy Tuesday! Friends... I often wonder what drives someone to cross every fricken line imaginable. Like where do we, as people, go wrong? It tends to be head trauma... but sometimes... It's other things that drive people to go off the deep end. Well, in this episode ... Show More
28m 48s
Dec 2024
anatomy of evil: h.h. holmes (how victorian vice shaped the mask of a gentleman killer) [preview]
In this episode of "Anatomy of Evil," I peel back the velvet curtain of the Victorian era to reveal the disturbing world of H.H. Holmes, America’s first documented serial killer. His story isn't just a tale of murder and deception—it's a harrowing journey into the complexities of ... Show More
46m 27s
Jul 2023
What Makes A Killer: Season 5
Join us on a chilling journey into the depths of the human psyche. Welcome to 'What Makes a Killer,' the podcast that explores the twisted minds behind the most notorious crimes.  Each episode, host Jennifer Nittoso explores a different case, examining the motives, the methods, a ... Show More
1m 30s
Oct 2024
Why is horror so fun?
It makes sense that we run away from scary things. That’s a good way to stay alive. But why do some people also love scary things? Why do people gravitate toward horror?Guests: Mathias Clasen and Marc Andersen, co-directors of the Recreational Fear Lab at Aarhus UniversityFor sho ... Show More
21m 51s
Oct 2024
Obsessed with Serial Killers ////// 790
Obsessed with Serial Killers  ////// 790Part 1 of 1 www.TrueCrimeGarage.comDoes America and other nations have an obsession with Serial Killers?  Many have asked that question.  I say no, but what is clearly obvious is many people have a very deep fascination with Serial Killers. ... Show More
1h 13m