logo
episode-header-image
May 21
1h 27m

Spotlight: Peril, Pills, Promises & Pote...

PROFESSOR ROSS TUCKER AND MIKE FINCH
About this episode

Join Discourse


Nutrition tips, training insight, performance debates, sports opinions — if you’re into it, we’re talking about it. Become part of the “Science of Sport” Discourse community via Patreon.


Show notes


This week on Spotlight, we take a tour through some of the big stories in sport and sports science right now—from race tactics and concussion protocols to doping ethics, expert credibility, and how we identify and develop talent.


We start with a lively discussion on the Giro d’Italia and that gravel stage. Was it thrilling unpredictability—or dangerous chaos? As the General Classification gets a dramatic shake-up, we debate whether the pursuit of entertainment justifies what some see as random, unfair risk and compromised race integrity. Do stages like this belong in a Grand Tour, or are they an unwelcome injection of chance into a sport built on precision and control?


From there, we shift to cycling’s ongoing concussion challenges. Jonas Vingegaard’s recent comments compel questions about whether current policies do enough to manage brain injuries. Despite a policy that asks multiple people in the race to identify possible cases, the sport appears to be struggling to accurately identify who gets tested, when and how. Are critical medical decisions still slipping through the cracks because the wrong people, with misaligned incentives, are being asked to make them under pressure?


Then it’s time for our first featured topic: the evolution of the Enhanced Games. With swimmer James Magnussen chasing a chemically-aided world record and a million-dollar prize, we unpack the ethical and medical dangers of performance enhancement. What are the risks—for athlete health, for fairness, and for the messages it sends to the next generation?


Next, we ask: How do you know who to trust? In an age of slick communication and pseudo-expertise, we explore the credibility of experts, and discover why true experts often sound less confident, not more. Ross explains how confidence can be a red flag, and why uncertainty and nuance are often markers of real scientific thinking.


Finally, we dive into the messy reality of Talent ID. Ross explains four common errors—especially the “ghosts” created when resource-strained systems make early, high-stakes decisions that can harm both performance and people.


We close with a brief segment on doping in Ironman, and why the “contaminated meat” excuse likely doesn’t hold up—though science says it’s not entirely impossible.


Links



Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Yesterday
Vingegaard's Muscle: No Match for Pogacar? | Who is to Blame for Tour Crash Chaos?
Discourse - the best thing about this Podcast, is all yours for a small monthly pledge. No exorbitant fee, no toilet paper advert every 510min, and access to hundreds of listeners who share great advice, insight, training strategies and opinion. Join now!The showThis week on The ... Show More
1h 9m
Jul 7
What It's Really Like to be a Tennis Professional on Tour
Kevin Ullyett has won 34 career tennis titles - including two doubles (2001 US Open, 2005 Australian Open) and one mixed (2002 Australian Open) Grand Slams - and had a world ranking of 107th in singles. So he knows what it's like to fight his way through the ranks and play among ... Show More
1h 28m
Jul 2
Spotlight: Failing to Science the Sh*t Out of Running / A Legal Lens on Liability and Sports Injury
We kick off this Spotlight at the Western States 100, where much of the buzz centered on David Roche’s DNF. Roche, a polarizing figure who promised to “science the shit” out of the race, faced unfair criticism both before and after the race, and Ross reflects on how the scientifi ... Show More
1h 35m
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2025
249: The Untold Evolution of Sports Medicine
In this episode of the Science for Sport podcast, host Richard Graves sits down with Dave Hancock, a sports performance pioneer with a career spanning over three decades in professional sport. From the sidelines of Leeds United to the championship-winning New York Knicks and beyo ... Show More
32m 9s
Nov 2024
241: The Data Revolution in Sport: Insights from Elite Sports Analysts on Optimising Performance
Episode 241 In this week's Science for Sport podcast, host Richard Graves dives into the world of data analysis in professional football with two brilliant guests—Arian Forouhandeh, Physical Performance Data Lead at Wolves, and Ryan White, Sports Science Analyst at Crystal Pa ... Show More
31m 29s
Jan 2025
250: The Science for Sport Story
In this episode, we unveil The Science for Sport Story with none other than its founder, Owen Walker. From his early days chasing football dreams to building the world’s go-to platform for sports science education, Owen shares the highs, lows, and pivotal moments that shaped Scie ... Show More
25m 51s
Oct 2024
What do the IOC, TikTok, NFL, and EA Sports have in common?
Regardless of size or type of organisation the sports media ecosystem is rapidly evolving. On this episode of StreamTime Sports co-host Nick Meacham and Chris Stone discuss the industry's biggest challenges and hottest topics in advance of SportsPro Madrid.   Listeners of StreamT ... Show More
49m 55s
May 2024
214: Designing The Perfect Sport Scientist
In episode 214 Harry Routledge, High Performance Practitioner, joins us. Specifically Harry will be looking at: What Sport Scientists do The skills and qualifications needed Specialists vs generalists How to develop your skills About Harry : "I am an experience High Performance P ... Show More
22m 10s
Jan 2025
252: How to Maximise Athlete Performance & Recovery
This week we are unlocking the Secrets of Elite Performance with Dr Peter Tierney! From the high-pressure world of professional rugby and football to cutting-edge performance apparel, Dr Peter Tierney has seen it all. In this episode, we dive deep into what it takes to win at the ... Show More
29m 21s
Jul 2024
UP407 What We Talk About When We Talk About Gareth Southgate
Leadership is one of the most important and yet misunderstood topics in sport.  This summer, it has dominated the headlines. Performances of the England football team have mainly been analysed via the lens of its manager.  So what is leadership and what are the mistakes we make w ... Show More
46m 48s
Sep 2024
234: Perfect Programming: Individualisation For 100s Of Athletes At Once
In episode 234 Jake Reeve S&C Coach at Loughborough University, joins us. Specifically Jake will be looking at: Testing & Profiling How to individualise training programs What these programs look like in real life About Jake "Jake is the Lead Strength & Conditioning Coach for Ath ... Show More
17m 42s
Jan 2025
251: Old-School Grit vs Modern Sports Science in Football
Dive into this episode of the Science for Sport podcast with Chris Morgan, whose football journey spans from playing in the Premier League with Barnsley and Sheffield United to coaching and now working as a FIFA football agent. Chris offers unparalleled insights into how the game ... Show More
34m 11s
Oct 2024
Ep. 151 - Sports Science Unleashed: Maximizing Athletic Performance with Biomechanics
Dr. Dean Mitchell sits down with Dr. John DeWitt, one of the leading minds in sports science and biomechanics, for an in-depth look at how cutting-edge technology is changing the game for professional athletes. As the Director of Applied Sports Science at Rice Athletics and a for ... Show More
53m 31s