logo
episode-header-image
May 2025
1h 12m

#596 - Messy Methy Murder Conspiracy - B...

James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
About this episode

This week, in Belle Fourche, South Dakota, a trip to a friend's house to buy some meth, turns into a horrifying three day session of brutality, when a man is duct taped, and seeming driven all over town, in the trunk of car. He's also stuffed into a tool box, among other atrocities. Several people witness this, and no one does anything to help. Eventually, everyone involved thinks it's "no body, no crime", but they are very much mistaken! Will anyone lead police to the body??


Along the way, we find out that Seth Bullock & Wild Bill Hickok didn't even know each other, that owing someone $250 for meth can be a life threatening situation, and that being on meth for 4 straight days can skew your remembering of times & dates!!


New episodes every Thursday!


Donate at: patreon.com/crimeinsports or go to paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder & Crime In Sports!


Follow us on...


twitter.com/@murdersmall

facebook.com/smalltownpod

instagram.com/smalltownmurder


Also, check out James & Jimmie's other show, Crime In Sports! On Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, Wondery, Wondery+, Stitcher, or wherever you listen to podcasts!


Up next
Nov 22
A Deadly Blame Game - Pierre, South Dakota
<p>This week, in Pierre, South Dakota, an affair turns into a need for a divorce, which leads to a woman, disappearing. She leaves her phone, purse & car, but she's nowhere to be found. Detectives look to her new boyfriend, but eventually blame the husband, claiming it was a brut ... Show More
1h 11m
Nov 20
Murder For My Love - Lynchburg, Virginia
<p>This week, in Lynchburg, Virginia, when a powerful couple is brutally murdered, in their home, detectives don't have a lot to work with, besides some bloody footprints, and blood from an unknown source. According to their daughter, they have a million enemies, ranging from ang ... Show More
3h 3m
Nov 15
Deadly Dark Delusions - Lashmeet, West Virginia
<p>This week, in Lashmeet, West Virginia, a sudden, and brutal murder may have been brought on by a very strange living arrangement, involving a woman, her boyfriend, and her ex-husband, One day, both the woman, and her boyfriend begin drinking, in the morning. This leads to argu ... Show More
1h 13m
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2025
Kentucky Fried Chicken Murders /// Part 1 /// 857
<p>Kentucky Fried Chicken Murders /// Part 1 /// 857</p><p>Part 1 of 2 </p><p><br /> </p><p><a href="http://www.truecrimegarage.com/" target="_blank">www.TrueCrimeGarage.com</a></p><p>The “Kentucky Fried Chicken Murders, Kentucky Fried Chicken Massacre, the KFC murders, the Texas ... Show More
56m 35s
Aug 29
EP. 214 - MINNESOTA: The Punk Rock Axe Murders
In today’s episode, we examine a disturbing story of family annihilation, punk rock and axe murder. This is the story of David Brom and his murderous rampage, and you’re listening to “MURDER IN AMERICA”! - Listen to our new show, "THE CONSPIRACY FILES"!: -Spotify - https://open.s ... Show More
1h 35m
Aug 2024
13x09: Stalked by a Cop
Stories in this episode: He Recorded Us For Years | hagetti (0:41) I was being watched | burst-beat (9:44) Close encounter with a serial killer at a highway rest stop. | Avulpesvulpes (13:28) The Men Under the Bridge | tielcas (18:59) I was nearly kidnapped at the beach when I wa ... Show More
55m 19s
Nov 12
CRIMES: The Murder of Charles Walton
In 1945, the quiet village of Lower Quinton, England, was rocked by a brutal killing. Seventy-four-year-old Charles Walton was found dead in a field — pinned to the ground with his own pitchfork, his body marked in what looked like ritual sacrifice. Was it a crime of passion… or ... Show More
45m 16s
Aug 21
448: The Murder of Hadas Winnick (from "I'm Related to a Killer")
<div>On September 25, 2007, 22-year-old Amy Winnick left her job near Calabasas, California, and headed home. Her cell phone rang. It was was her 25-year-old brother Jesse. "Don't go home," he told her. And then he said "I just killed Mom," and then he hung up. This unimaginable ... Show More
48m 32s
Feb 2025
BONUS: The CODIS Gap with Investigator Lindsey Wade
Reknowned investigator Lindsey Wade, author of the new book "In My DNA: My Career Investigating Your Worst Nightmares" (nominated for a CrimeCon CLUE Award) joins "Mind Over Murder" hosts Bill Thomas and Kristin Dilley to discuss the CODIS Gap.  Why are so many offenders, includi ... Show More
48m 54s
Jul 2025
Park Bench Murders ////// 856
<p>Park Bench Murders ////// 856</p><p>Part 1 of 1 </p><p><br /> </p><p><a href="http://www.truecrimegarage.com/" target="_blank">www.TrueCrimeGarage.com</a></p><p>On June 4, 2019, a little after 5 P.M., longtime friends Carnell “Nell” Sledge and Katherine “Kate” Brown arrived at ... Show More
1h 11m
Mar 2025
14x10: A Robbery and a Murder
Stories in this episode: It Wasn't An Owl | twigvicious (0:41) Almost Kidnapped at an Adult Store | Triple F Chronicles (14:11) My Friend, The Psychopath | Exxtol (23:48) They Waited For Me | kingsdeadfs (30:24) My Dog Knew That My Neighbor Was Watching Me | GoddessofDooom (36:23 ... Show More
53m 59s