We teamed up with self proclaimed skeptic, Justin from Generation Why to swap stories that ride the line between true crime and paranormal—and it did not disappoint.
Justin brings us the tragic and strange case of Christopher Case, a man who believed he’d been hexed by a witch… and died days later.
Then, it’s our turn: we take you inside the Sheraton Gunt ... Show More
Jun 11
Encounters x335 - Phone Calls From the Other Side
If your phone rang at 3 a.m. and the caller ID said “Payphone, Rhode Island,” would you answer? This week’s encounters episode dives into haunted phone calls, cursed voicemails, creepy glitches, and spirits who are just one bad connection away. Static-filled voices, phantom landl ... Show More
54m 39s
Jun 7
Episode 376 - Haunted Cafe Lafitte in Exile | The Queer Ghosts of Bourbon Street
We found one of the most haunted and legendary bars in New Orleans, and the ghosts there never stopped partying. In this episode, we explore the wild history and lingering spirits of Cafe Lafitte in Exile, the oldest continuously operating gay bar in the United States. With repor ... Show More
53m 9s
Jun 4
Encounters x334 - Haunted New Orleans | Voodoo, the Rougarou & French Quarter Frights
You all asked for this paranormal fever dream, and we’re delivering. This episode is packed with haunted New Orleans encounters that will make you want to book a flight and immediately cleanse your suitcase afterward. We’re talking ghostly figures caught in cemetery photos, possi ... Show More
1h 8m
May 2022
8x13: Sleepwalking Horror - Let's Not Meet
Stories in this episode: - Sleepwalking Horror, by Callie (0:50) - It's Okay, Sweetie, by Anna (9:29) - My Sister Dated a Murderer, by Sara (16:08) - The Chef That Made My Life Hell, by Anon (22:53) - My Crazy Stalker Roommate, by Michaela (37:48) Extended Patreon Content: - Boyf ... Show More
44m 37s
Sep 2023
11x14: The Best of Season 1 (pt 2)
Stories in this episode: - A Man Wanted to Buy my Laptop, by SMILEY_ATTACK (1:14)- Apparently, I "Got Lucky", by FrappeInMyStache (5:04)- RING Doorbell Stolen and Used to Scare Me, by cheeseylump (8:20)- My Encounter at an Abandoned Hospital, by boygenieous (10:15)- I Like to Wat ... Show More
1h 23m
Jun 2022
The Haunted Farmhouse (ft. Shelby Scott) – Ep. 29
Stories in this episode:- Having a Drink with a Dead Man, by Leti - David's Shadow, by Rachel- My Abduction Story, by emodrakefan- 200 Year Old Haunted Farmhouse, by ctenc001- The Red Light, by Tanu - My Stories, by AshleyBe sure to check out Shelby Scott's podcast at scareyoutos ... Show More
49m 58s
Jan 2023
Haunted Prison & Rabbit Man – Ep. 58
Stories in this episode:- Orbs Are NOT the Vibe, by Katie- The Invitation, by Kliff Hollowz- The Presence, by MK- Was it a Ghost? by Jade- Rabbit Man, by Stephanie Viada- My Encounter with the Holy Spirit, by Elise- Haunted Prison, by Seth- Welcome to My House, by LamaGirlSubmiss ... Show More
50m 40s
Jan 2023
UFO on the River (ft. Cassidy Liston) – Ep. 60
Stories in this episode:- UFO on the River, by Rhett- Restaurant Kitchen Encounter, by Auston- I Think Something is Attached to Me, by Stevie- Haunted Drill Hall, by Jared- The Time I Saw Myself Die, by Tina- My Psychic Circle Story, by BizaSubmissions: stories@oddtrails.comListe ... Show More
54m 22s
Apr 2022
Episode 59 | KARLA AND PAUL - THE BEAUTIFUL SERIAL KILLER COUPLE
Send us Fan MailIn this podcast we're going to dig in to the disturbing story of Karla Homolka and her then husband Paul Bernardo. Back in the early '90s the two met, married and then went on a spree of abduction, rape and murder of teenage girls, one of whom was Homolka's own si ... Show More
30m 21s