logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2025
18m 25s

These Harry Potter Myths Were NEVER Cano...

Harry Potter Theory
About this episode

Welcome to Harry Potter Theory. Today we’re going to be taking a look at aspects of the Harry Potter universe that everyone seems to remember…The wrong way. And partly to blame for all of this is the fact that the Harry Potter books were adapted to film.


The short answer for WHY all of this happened is that in transforming the beloved book series into movies, a lot of liberties were taken.


  • Characters personalities were changed
  • Scenes that NEVER occurred were added
  • Character roles were switched
  • And in many cases, aspects of the books were outright omitted


But now that so many years have passed, a lot of these movie misconceptions have become so ingrained that they've completely overwritten how we remember the original Harry Potter books. How you perceive this video will depend entirely on how you engaged with the series. For some, the films were too frustrating to finish — filled with inaccuracies that clashed with the books- and by going down this path their memory of the books (and more importantly, accurate information) remained intact. 


But for many others, the books and movies have blended together into one seamless version of the story. Harry Potter as a whole became an amalgamation of both book and film — with the lines between them increasingly blurred.


And in many instances these changes became so pervasive that they overwrote how nearly everyone remembered the source material.


After you’ve watched the video, let me know how many of these things YOU remembered the wrong way. Be honest.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Up next
Aug 23
Who Taught Dumbledore? And Why Was He Was So POWERFUL? – Harry Potter Theory
Albus Percival Wulfric BRIAN Dumbledore is perhaps the greatest Wizard in history. This much is the truth, and it’s also something that even a stubborn dark wizard like Voldemort would have to admit (although perhaps not openly).Far from a one trick pony, by the time Dumbledore r ... Show More
17m 55s
Aug 19
These Harry Potter Myths Were NEVER Canon (But Everyone Thinks They Are)
Hey everyone, Welcome to another installment of Harry Potter Theory. Today, we’re diving into part 2 of the moments in the Harry Potter universe that everyone remembers… but remembers wrong- a major contributor to this being the FILMS. In adapting the books to the big screen, the ... Show More
10 m
Aug 16
Why Was Lavender Brown Played by 3 Different Actresses?
One of the strangest things about Lavender Brown’s character is that she was portrayed by not one, not two, but three different actresses over the course of the films — changing between Chamber of Secrets, Prisoner of Azkaban, and finally Half-Blood Prince. But what’s the reason ... Show More
8m 22s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2022
548: Will There Ever Be Another Harry Potter-Level Book Series?
After the Potter series proved to be successful, there was the Twilight Series. Next came The Hunger Games. And then came Divergent! Each series was marketed as "the NEXT Harry Potter." But, they weren't really as successful as Harry Potter at all! On this special episode of Mugg ... Show More
1h 20m
Aug 2020
#477: Burning 'Order of the Phoenix' Questions That Were Never Answered
News: The Harry Potter film series is moving to Peacock and leaving HBO Max. Muggle Mail covers Potter People The Podcast and an interesting fan fiction about Voldemort's return! It's our Order of the Phoenix Rewind episode! Acceptable. Troll. Exceeds Expectations. Just how good ... Show More
1h 27m
Jul 22
The Harry Potter TV Show Reveals First Looks and More!
Help MuggleCast grow! Become a MuggleCast Member and get great benefits like Bonus MuggleCast! Patreon.com/MuggleCast Grab official merch! MuggleCastMerch.com Pick up overstock merch from years past, including our 19th Anniversary Shirt! MuggleMillennial.Etsy.com On this week’s e ... Show More
1h 12m
Apr 2010
Episode #197: Swish and Flick
We attempt to guess which book was the Most Banned/Challenged of the decade. When can we expect the Deathly Hallows trailer to be released? Will WB aim for a PG-13 rating? Our thoughts on a LEGO: Harry Potter Collector’s Edition. A Harry Potter visitor attraction is approved at L ... Show More
1h 45m
Nov 2021
539: What Was The '98 Hogwarts School Year Like? And More Muggle Mail
On this week's episode, we empty some owl post from our Muggle Mail bag! What would the 1998-99 Hogwarts school year have looked like? Why did Harry decide to become an Auror? Plus, we analyze several new Credence theories, a Chicken Soup from India and a horcrux email from 2006 ... Show More
1h 20m
Sep 2024
Listeners Share 'Goblet of Fire' Theories, and 'Cursed Child' Star Joel Meyers Speaks With Us!
It's time to put Goblet of Fire in the rear-view mirror as we conduct our ceremonial book wrap episode, featuring our 7-Word Chapter Summary redo, 7 Word Book Summary, and more MuggleMail than you can shake a non-plot-holed Portkey at! Join Andrew, Eric, Laura and Micah for this ... Show More
1h 30m
Sep 2024
Figg's Bat Phone (OOTP Chapter 1, Dudley Demented)
This week, our Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix re-read begins! We examine the protections surrounding Harry now that Voldemort is back, and ask whether Dudley Dursley is a good boy now. News: There is an open casting call for children to become the next Potter trio for ... Show More
1h 13m
Jun 2019
#422: Fawkes Unites (HBP 29, The Phoenix Lament)
Welcome Slug Club member Chloe! Wizards Unite is out and we discuss what we like about the game so far! Hagrid's Magical Creatures Motorbike Adventure is dealing with some launch pains Chapter-by-Chapter returns with Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Chapter 29 The Phoenix ... Show More
1h 26m
Aug 19
You're A Fool, Harry Potter (OOTP Chapter 35, Beyond the Veil)
Help MuggleCast grow during our birthday month! Our 2025 physical gift is here! The MuggleCast Yearbook includes writing by each of the four hosts, telling the story of the podcast across the last 20 years, and featuring tons of colorful images and jam-packed with enough nostalgi ... Show More
1h 11m
Oct 2024
Chapter 21: Hermione’s Secret | Prisoner of Azkaban
Join J and Ben as they dive into Chapter 21 of the Prisoner of Azkaban and discuss Snape and Fudge’s conversation, why Dumbledore believes Sirius, the time turner, saving Buckbeak, the in-between-the-action moments, Harry’s belief that the patronus was cast by his dad, Harry actu ... Show More
1h 50m