logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2025
57m 44s

Unfortunately Precedented Times

Julia Hava & Eliza McLamb
About this episode

In the first installment of a two-part series on immigration, the girlies ask an important question: what gives someone the right to call a place home — and who gets to decide? Is citizenship a moral construct, or just a legal one? If borders are made up, why do they control so much of our lives?

In light of the ongoing deportation horrors and increasingly aggressive border enforcement, we’re looking back to figure out how we got here. From early immigration through World War I, we trace the long, messy history of who’s been allowed in, who’s been shut out, and how the U.S. has used immigration as a tool for control, exclusion, and scapegoating.

Everyone, regardless of immigration status, has rights under the U.S. Constitution. You have the right to remain silent, the right to refuse a search without a warrant, and the right to speak to a lawyer. For more information and resources, visit ilrc.orgaclu.org/know-your-rights/immigrants-rights

This episode was produced by Julia Hava and Eliza McLamb and edited by Allison Hagan. Research assistance from Kylie Finnigan.

To support the podcast on Patreon and access 50+ bonus episodes, mediasodes, zoom hangouts and more, visit patreon.com/binchtopia and become a patron today.

SOURCES: 

4 things to know about the Alien Enemies Act and Trump's efforts to use it

A Brief History of U.S. Immigration Policy from the Colonial Period to the Present Day

A History of the Alien Enemies Act of 1798

A Letter to Columbia  

American Immigration Policy in Historical Perspective

Americans’ Views of Deportations

Chinese Immigration and the Chinese Exclusion Acts

Federal Government Detains International Student at Tufts

Historical Context: The Post-World War I Red Scare

How does deportation work, and how much does it cost? We break it down

Immigration History Timeline

Immigration judge denies bond for Tufts University student from Turkey, her lawyers say  

International students are being told by email that their visas are revoked and that they must ‘self-deport.’ What to know

Invocation of the Alien Enemies Act Regarding the Invasion of The United States by Tren De Aragua

Isolationism and U.S. Foreign Policy After World War I

Mahmoud Khalil arrest: Can the US deport a green card holder?

Newly Declassified Documents Reveal the Untold Stories of the Red Scare, a Hunt for Communists in Postwar America

Red Scare

Refugee Timeline  

Reported: Administration officials direct ICE to increase arrests to meet daily quotas

Secretary of State Marco Rubio Remarks to the Press

Targeting of Tufts Student for Deportation Stuns Friends and Teachers

The Alien and Sedition Acts

The Alien Enemies Act Is Outdated, Dangerous, and Ripe for Abuse

The Alien Enemies Act, Explained

The Alien Enemies Act: The One Alien and Sedition Act Still on the Books   

The Alien Enemies Act: What to know about a 1798 law that Trump has invoked for deportations

The First Red Scare

The Immigrant Army: Immigrant Service Members in World War I

The Industrial Immigrant in the United States, 1783-1812

The National Constitution Center’s Founders’ Library   

The Sedition and Espionage Acts Were Designed to Quash Dissent During WWI

The U.S. Confiscated Half a Billion Dollars in Private Property During WWI

To my husband, Mahmoud Khalil: I can’t wait to tell our son of his father’s bravery

Trump is promising deportations under the Alien Enemies Act of 1798. What is it?

Trump officials issue quotas to ICE officers to ramp up arrests

Tufts University student can’t be deported to Turkiye without court order  

U.S. Immigration Timeline

What WW1 civilian internment can teach us about today

When John Adams Signed a Law to Authorize Deportations and Jail Critics

Who is Mahmoud Khalil? Palestinian activist detained by ICE over Columbia University protests

​​‘Where’s Alex?’ A Beloved Caregiver Is Swept Up in Trump’s Green Card Crackdown

Up next
Oct 8
Who Up Quantifying the Self?
This week on Binchtopia, Eliza returns from her off-grid era to dive into the history and evolution of body technology, from ancient tracking rituals to Silicon Valley’s quantified self movement. The girlies break down Fitbits, Oura Rings, Prenuvo scans, and sleep apps to examine ... Show More
1h 18m
Oct 1
Tap to Joust w/ Nick Garros *TEASER*
Venture forth with Julia and beautiful Lady Garros on their noble quest to the Renaissance Faire, where Nick donned a full chest plate and even the turkey legs demanded a tithe. After ranting about ye olde ATM’s and how capitalism ruins everything, the binchies travel back in his ... Show More
5m 58s
Sep 24
The Crisis of Despair w/ P.E. Moskowitz
Julia is joined by genius mind P.E. Moskowitz for a conversation about their new memoir Breaking Awake, which chronicles the mental breakdown that drove them to experiment with drugs, reckon with trauma, and draw meaning from suffering. From Klonopin and SSRIs to ketamine and LSD ... Show More
55m 51s
Recommended Episodes
Sep 12
Psychedelics and the structure of reality | Julian Baggini, Eileen Hall, and James Rucker
Truth, delusion and psychedelic realityDo psychedelics reveal hidden layers of reality, or are we simply tripping?Psychedelics are back in the cultural zeitgeist, this time as a treatment for mental health issues. However, critics argue that psychedelics only work by replacing me ... Show More
46m 51s
Aug 29
Will psychedelics revolutionize mental health treatment? | Matthew Johnson, Shayla Love, and Kevin Sabet
The psychedelic revolutionWill LSD, Psilocybin, MDMA, and Ketamine treatments live up to the hype?For decades, psychedelics were derided as dangerous recreational drugs; now many claim they have the potential to revolutionise the treatment of mental health. With hundreds of clini ... Show More
49m 34s
Mar 2025
Oprah and Harvard Professor Share How Psychedelics Are Actually Healing
BUY THE BOOK! “How to Change Your Mind: What the New Science of Psychedelics Teaches Us About Consciousness, Dying, Addiction, Depression, and Transcendence” by Michael Pollan “Fire in the Hole!: The Untold Story of My Traumatic Life and Explosive Success” by Bob Parsons In this ... Show More
57m 47s
Dec 2024
PART 2 - The Truth About Addiction Uncut with Johann Hari
What if everything you think you know about addiction is wrong? Johann Hari's personal journey into the heart of the war on drugs led him to ask this question and to write the book that gave rise to his viral TED talk, viewed more than 62 million times. Johann Hari is a best sell ... Show More
44m 39s
Jun 2024
RU297: MICHAEL REILEY ON DEEP LISTENING, SOUND SANGHA, SOUL RETREATS & PSYCHEDELICS
RU297: MICHAEL REILEY ON DEEP LISTENING, DREAMING, SOUL RETREATS & PSYCHEDELICS http://www.renderingunconscious.org/dreams/ru297-michael-reiley-on-deep-listening-dreaming-soul-retreats-psychedelics/ Rendering Unconscious episode 297. Available to view at YouTube: https://youtu.be ... Show More
1h 1m
Jul 30
Part Two: Johann Hari Reveals the Truth They Aren’t Telling You about Depression, GLP-1s and ADHD & Why Our Biology Is Not To Blame
Is Big Pharma really healing us — or profiting from keeping us sick? NYT best-selling author Johann Hari (Stolen Focus, Lost Connections, Chasing the Scream, Magic Pill) returns with a powerful breakdown of the real causes of depression, anxiety, and the global attention crisis. ... Show More
53m 11s
Jul 29
Johann Hari Reveals the Truth They Aren’t Telling You about Depression, GLP-1s and ADHD & Why Our Biology Is Not To Blame
Is Big Pharma really healing us — or profiting from keeping us sick? NYT best-selling author Johann Hari (Stolen Focus, Lost Connections, Chasing the Scream, Magic Pill) returns with a powerful breakdown of the real causes of depression, anxiety, and the global attention crisis. ... Show More
53m 42s
Aug 2024
Awakening Is Necessary for Our Survival
In this podcast, Eckhart elaborates further about finding freedom from the bondage of self. He says the first step is to confront our thinking and resist the urge to identify with every thought we have. Eckhart says rising above thinking paves the way to liberation. Many people t ... Show More
40m 20s
May 2024
[Hors-serie] Rewire your dopamine system with Anna Lembke
Anna Lembke est une psychiatre de renom,  et diectrice de la clinique de médecine de l'addiction et du double diagnostic de l'université de Stanford  et autrice de "Dopamnine nation". C'est la médecin de référence dans le documentaire "the Social dilemna"  (derrière nos écrans de ... Show More
52m 35s
Aug 2024
66: Teens, Cops, and Spies: The Varieties of Hysterical Experience feat. Dan Taberski
Abby and Patrick welcome Dan Taberski, creator of the brand-new podcast series Hysterical. They explore the genesis of the series and the challenges and rewards of confronting both the history and the present of “the H-word.” Tracking the trajectories of this famously “elusive ne ... Show More
1h 24m