logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2025
57m 44s

Unfortunately Precedented Times

Julia Hava & Eliza McLamb
About this episode

In the first installment of a two-part series on immigration, the girlies ask an important question: what gives someone the right to call a place home — and who gets to decide? Is citizenship a moral construct, or just a legal one? If borders are made up, why do they control so much of our lives?

In light of the ongoing deportation horrors and increasingly aggressive border enforcement, we’re looking back to figure out how we got here. From early immigration through World War I, we trace the long, messy history of who’s been allowed in, who’s been shut out, and how the U.S. has used immigration as a tool for control, exclusion, and scapegoating.

Everyone, regardless of immigration status, has rights under the U.S. Constitution. You have the right to remain silent, the right to refuse a search without a warrant, and the right to speak to a lawyer. For more information and resources, visit ilrc.orgaclu.org/know-your-rights/immigrants-rights

This episode was produced by Julia Hava and Eliza McLamb and edited by Allison Hagan. Research assistance from Kylie Finnigan.

To support the podcast on Patreon and access 50+ bonus episodes, mediasodes, zoom hangouts and more, visit patreon.com/binchtopia and become a patron today.

SOURCES: 

4 things to know about the Alien Enemies Act and Trump's efforts to use it

A Brief History of U.S. Immigration Policy from the Colonial Period to the Present Day

A History of the Alien Enemies Act of 1798

A Letter to Columbia  

American Immigration Policy in Historical Perspective

Americans’ Views of Deportations

Chinese Immigration and the Chinese Exclusion Acts

Federal Government Detains International Student at Tufts

Historical Context: The Post-World War I Red Scare

How does deportation work, and how much does it cost? We break it down

Immigration History Timeline

Immigration judge denies bond for Tufts University student from Turkey, her lawyers say  

International students are being told by email that their visas are revoked and that they must ‘self-deport.’ What to know

Invocation of the Alien Enemies Act Regarding the Invasion of The United States by Tren De Aragua

Isolationism and U.S. Foreign Policy After World War I

Mahmoud Khalil arrest: Can the US deport a green card holder?

Newly Declassified Documents Reveal the Untold Stories of the Red Scare, a Hunt for Communists in Postwar America

Red Scare

Refugee Timeline  

Reported: Administration officials direct ICE to increase arrests to meet daily quotas

Secretary of State Marco Rubio Remarks to the Press

Targeting of Tufts Student for Deportation Stuns Friends and Teachers

The Alien and Sedition Acts

The Alien Enemies Act Is Outdated, Dangerous, and Ripe for Abuse

The Alien Enemies Act, Explained

The Alien Enemies Act: The One Alien and Sedition Act Still on the Books   

The Alien Enemies Act: What to know about a 1798 law that Trump has invoked for deportations

The First Red Scare

The Immigrant Army: Immigrant Service Members in World War I

The Industrial Immigrant in the United States, 1783-1812

The National Constitution Center’s Founders’ Library   

The Sedition and Espionage Acts Were Designed to Quash Dissent During WWI

The U.S. Confiscated Half a Billion Dollars in Private Property During WWI

To my husband, Mahmoud Khalil: I can’t wait to tell our son of his father’s bravery

Trump is promising deportations under the Alien Enemies Act of 1798. What is it?

Trump officials issue quotas to ICE officers to ramp up arrests

Tufts University student can’t be deported to Turkiye without court order  

U.S. Immigration Timeline

What WW1 civilian internment can teach us about today

When John Adams Signed a Law to Authorize Deportations and Jail Critics

Who is Mahmoud Khalil? Palestinian activist detained by ICE over Columbia University protests

​​‘Where’s Alex?’ A Beloved Caregiver Is Swept Up in Trump’s Green Card Crackdown

Up next
Aug 13
Regime of Convenience
This week, the girlies log on to discuss the strange and somewhat evil journey of content streaming. They track the rise from radio to Napster to Netflix, expose how labels teamed up with platforms to rob artists blind, and unpack how mood playlists and background noise culture e ... Show More
1h 32m
Aug 6
On the Road Again *TEASER*
This week, the girlies are in a place of tour, reporting live from Binchicago! From the technical difficulties and gonjus gowns of live shows to meeting all the insanely impressive binchies (and their radicalized family members), they reflect on whether or not alcohol is poison, ... Show More
7m 25s
Jul 30
December Mediasode: Best of the Year, Enlightening Essays, and Should I Just Give Up on Jonathan Franzen?! *UNLOCKED FROM PATREON*
This episode was originally released on December 31, 2024 as a Patreon exclusive, and we’re unlocking it for you to make the most of the extra week in July. Become a patron today to support the show, keep us ad-free and unlock our backlog of over 50 bonus episodes and mediasodes ... Show More
48m 29s
Recommended Episodes
May 25
Where Are The Thinkers? Why Pop Culture Feels Doomed Right Now
Currently trending on TikTok, FKA Twigs is going viral for an interview in which she asks the host and the crowd - "Where are the thinkers?"While internet users raise eyebrows at her question, one that ignores the socioeconomic conditions that affect our ability to create, this w ... Show More
34m 5s
Nov 2023
33: The Problem with Empathy feat. Jade E. Davis
Abby and Patrick welcome Jade E. Davis, author of the new book The Other Side of Empathy. They discuss Jade’s critique of naïve notions of “empathy” and what she calls “empathy culture.” They examine the ways empathy can flatten suffering, demand particular performances of suffer ... Show More
1h 27m
Mar 2025
How The Left Turned On Woke
In a new interview, singer songwriter Sam Fender claimed he understood why young white men from Northern towns are being radicalised by misogynist social media influencers like Andrew Tate - it's because they're being accused of having privilege. In similarly convoluted language, ... Show More
29m 56s
Feb 2025
ALBERT KOSTANIAN - A Final Word (Ep.413)
Albert Kostanian returns to The Beirut Banyan. In this short episode he candidly discusses a campaign to discredit his economic views and media reputation, debunks accusations of shadow funding and behind-the-scenes government orchestration regarding Kulluna Irada, dispels smear ... Show More
12m 26s
Sep 2023
How the Media Creates Delusional Tribes - Tim Urban
Tim Urban is a blogger who writes about a wide range of topics, from science and technology to psychology and philosophy. He is known for creating minimalist stick-figure illustrations to help explain complex concepts in a simple way. His musings are collected on his website, ‘Wa ... Show More
59m 32s
May 2024
People Are Shouting At The Wrong Man
Subscribe to Mamamia This week, a deadly air strike in Rafah in southern Gaza killed at least 45 Palestinians and wounded dozens of others. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has referred to what happened as a “tragic mishap”, and yet, emerging reports indicate that such a ... Show More
32m 34s
Feb 2025
We Deserved To Lose - Kemi Badenoch
Kemi Badenoch is the leader of the Conservative Party in the UK. SPONSOR. Pure Gold. Protect your wealth with The Pure Gold Company. Get your free investor guide at https://pure-gold.co/trigger SPONSOR. MUD\WTR. Start your new morning ritual & get up to 43% off your @MUDWTR with ... Show More
1h 19m
Dec 2024
Making money from internet outrage
How do online platforms profit from our anger? In this episode, we explore the business of 'rage-baiting' – content designed to provoke outrage and drive engagement. We hear from creators who thrive on stirring emotions, critics warning of its societal impact, and academics expla ... Show More
17m 28s
Apr 2025
We Proved Trans Women are Men - Maya Forstater
Maya Forstater is a British gender-critical activist and co-founder of the organization Sex Matters | SPONSOR. We use Ground News to escape the echo chamber and stay fully informed. Go to https://ground.news/triggernometry to save 40% on the Ground News unlimited access Vantage p ... Show More
1h 10m
Apr 2025
We Need a Cultural Resurrection
Andrew Klaven is an author, screenwriter and host of "The Andrew Klavan Show" at the Daily Wire. Follow Andrew on X: https://x.com/andrewklavan SPONSOR. Augusta Precious Metals: Protect Your Retirement with Physical Gold. Rated #1. Click to learn more: https://bit.ly/triggergold ... Show More
1h 8m