logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2025
55m 54s

Speaking Truth to Power (and to the Pews...

Scan Media, LLC
About this episode

In this conversation, host Corey Nathan welcomes back Peter Wehner, contributing writer at The Atlantic and The New York Times, senior fellow at the Trinity Forum, and author of multiple books including The Death of Politics and City of Man. A former speechwriter for President George W. Bush, Pete brings a unique perspective shaped by his deep political experience, Christian faith, and unwavering moral compass. Together, Corey and Pete engage in a wide-ranging conversation on the 2024 election, the moral health of our nation, the role of the church, and the constitutional implications of a second Trump presidency.

What We Discuss:

  • How Pete Wehner processed the pivotal moments of the 2024 election, including Biden’s withdrawal and Kamala Harris’s campaign
  • Why Donald Trump’s reelection reveals unsettling truths about American society and the church
  • How constitutional crises might unfold under Trump’s second term
  • Why thinkers like Vaclav Havel, Solzhenitsyn, and Tocqueville are essential guides in this political moment
  • How to have more effective and empathetic conversations across political and religious divides

Episode Highlights:

  • [00:01:00] – Introduction to Pete Wehner’s background and career
  • [00:02:00] – Pete reflects on Biden’s debate performance and why he felt Biden should have withdrawn sooner
  • [00:05:00] – Analysis of Kamala Harris’s campaign, debate performance, and what ultimately cost her the election
  • [00:09:00] – The moral reckoning: what Trump’s reelection says about American voters and the church
  • [00:14:00] – Pete dissects why evangelicals have remained loyal to Trump and how rationalizations took hold
  • [00:27:00] – A 30-page email exchange: Pete’s attempt to reason with a high-profile Trump supporter and what it revealed
  • [00:34:00] – Trump’s “appetite for revenge”: Pete outlines troubling actions already taken in just 60 days of Trump’s second term
  • [00:41:00] – Defining a constitutional crisis and what happens when a president defies court rulings
  • [00:46:00] – Finding hope and moral clarity through leaders like Havel, Solzhenitsyn, and Tocqueville
  • [00:50:00] – The TP&R question: Pete's insights on how to build better conversations across our differences

Featured Quotes:

“Donald Trump is president because of the white evangelical vote. He touched something deep in the hearts of many Christians—and that should trouble us.” – Peter Wehner

“Hope is not the conviction that something will turn out well; it’s the certainty that something makes sense, regardless of how it turns out.” – Vaclav Havel (quoted by Pete)

“We're moving toward a constitutional crisis... If Trump defies a court order, we may find out how many divisions Chief Justice John Roberts really has.” – Peter Wehner

“We have to prioritize human relationships. The ripple effects for the country can be healthy.” – Peter Wehner

Resources Mentioned:

📣 Call to Action:

If you found this conversation insightful, please:
✅ Subscribe to Talkin' Politics & Religion Without Killin' Each Other on your favorite podcast platform.
✅ Leave a review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen: ratethispodcast.com/goodfaithpolitics
✅ Support the show on Patreon: patreon.com/politicsandreligion
✅ Watch the full conversation and subscribe on YouTube: youtube.com/@politicsandreligion

🔗 Connect With Us on Social Media

@coreysnathan:

Our Sponsors:

Let’s keep talking politics and religion—with gentleness and respect. 🎙️💡

Up next
Aug 25
Drawing the Line: When Gerrymandering Becomes Political Warfare
🎙️ Diving back into the gerrymandering / redistricting wars and the so-called "war on democracy." Is it a real war or political hyperbole? Corey unpacks recent redistricting efforts in Texas and California, confronts ethical and legal questions, and most importantly, discusses h ... Show More
36m 36s
Aug 21
From the Streets to a PhD: Dr. Terence Lester on Faith, Educational Injustice, and Fighting for Equity in a Broken System
Dr. Terence Lester on overcoming poverty, confronting systemic racism in education, and how we can show up for students our schools are failing. Introduction: Dr. Terence Lester is an activist, speaker, professor, and founder of Love Beyond Walls, a nonprofit focused on raising a ... Show More
1h 12m
Aug 19
Most of Us Are in the Middle — So Why Are the Extremes Controlling the Conversation?
Not Right. Not Left. Not Crazy. Just Real Talk About Politics and People. 43% of Us Aren’t Partisan Left or Right. This Episode Is for You. Reflecting on what it means to be politically independent in a time of increasing polarization. Drawing on personal stories and hot-button i ... Show More
40m 36s
Recommended Episodes
Sep 2024
September Mailbag Q&A: Politics, Hollywood, Church Hypocrisy and More!
In this episode, I will answer a ton of questions submitted by my followers over the weekend. We will tackle politics, Hollywood, how to start reading the Bible, forgiveness and more. You aren't going to want to miss this one! Whether you're seeking guidance or inspiration, this ... Show More
29m 33s
Mar 2025
God’s Holy People (Part 1)
Whenever God turns to you, if you believe in him, all he sees when he looks at you is complete beauty and sweetness. Jesus Christ offered himself up and fulfilled all of the obligations we owe God, so he has completely satisfied God. God sees nothing and senses nothing but sweetn ... Show More
44m 3s
Oct 2024
Reading Mark 2 - New Life, New Way: What Happens When You Follow Jesus
In this episode of Bible Reading and Coffee Drinking, we dive into Mark 2 and explore how Jesus brings real change to our lives. From forgiving sins to healing bodies, Jesus shows us that His power goes beyond the physical—He’s here to transform our hearts. We’ll look at how He w ... Show More
28m 33s
Aug 13
Knowing Good
We all have very strong moral convictions about what we think is right and wrong. And in a pluralistic society, we need to find ways of sharing our beliefs and being honest about who we are in a way that’s respectful and promotes peace. One of the ways we can make for a more civi ... Show More
47m 18s
Nov 2024
347: Applauding Grace
Hello friend. I hope you’re doing well today.  This week on the podcast we’re looking at an issue that plagued the Philippian church—legalism. They trusted the work of Jesus but were trying to add a little something on their own. If you ever find yourself looking for “Jesus plus” ... Show More
23m 25s
Sep 2024
God vs Gov... Who Wins?
When should a Christian practice civil disobedience? Does God want Christians to be politically activate? Join me as I weigh in on this age-old debate! Pre Order Pastor Marks newest book Vote Like Jesus to help you navigate this election year! -Instead of looking left or right, g ... Show More
1h 12m
Oct 2023
S 14 Ep 19: How do I Navigate Politics now that I am a Christian?
People often say the two topics we should avoid at the dinner table are religion and politics. In this episode, we talk about both. How should a new Christian, or an established one, think about politics? What does the Bible say about politics, human institutions, and governance? ... Show More
18m 47s
Feb 2025
Don’t Try to Live off Mouldy Bread (Joshua 9: 1-27)
Send us a textWelcome:Summary.When God brought the Israelites into the Promised Land, He gave them a paradoxical command: “The land is yours—now go and take possession of it.” That was both a gift and a responsibility.In the same way, we are told that God has blessed believers in ... Show More
30m 59s
Dec 2022
Stealing Standards from God
It's that time of year again! You're sitting around with family at the Christmas dinner table, and Uncle Joe insists on picking apart your Christian faith. What's the best way to respond? Ignore him while you play with your mashed potatoes? Or do you try to refute his objections? ... Show More
48m 26s
Sep 2024
Episode #109- September 25, 2024: The Idol of Perfection
#109 The Idol of Perfection In this episode, Annie, Lauren, and Stacy have a discussion about the struggles we see in holding ourself and others to perfectionism and combatting that with the peace of Christ. John 6:70 “Jesus answered them, “Did I not choose you twelve? Yet is not ... Show More
31m 42s