logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2025
43m 8s

Is the 4% Rule Dead?

BIGGERPOCKETS
About this episode

Is the 4% rule dead? Most FIRE-chasers are using this retirement rule completely wrong, and it could cost them their financial freedom. With stock prices falling and many Americans fearing another recession, now is the time to tighten up your retirement portfolio and ensure you can survive if stock prices correct or crash. If you get this wrong, you could delay your FIRE for years or have to go back to work mid-retirement.

The 4% rule is one of the most bulletproof retirement formulas. It’s simple: Build a portfolio from which you can comfortably withdraw 4% annually. Need $40,000 per year to live? Your FIRE number is $1,000,000. Need $100,000 per year? Then you’re looking at $2,500,000. This math has been checked, double-checked, and triple-checked to withstand even the greatest economic depressions. However, most people have their portfolio set up WRONG, and it could put them at significant risk.

So, how do you ENSURE you can retire (early) with the 4% rule? What hedges should you make in your portfolio so your wealth stays afloat even as the economic tide starts to turn? What are Scott and Mindy doing now to prepare for a rocky stock market? Don’t miss this one—it could cost you your FIRE!


In This Episode We Cover

The 4% rule explained and whether it still works in 2025 and during market downturns 

Why your FIRE portfolio is WRONG, and it could be at massive risk right now 

How to prepare for an economic downturn to ensure you stay FIREd or on the path to FIRE

What Scott is selling and buying right now to protect his wealth (will his strategy work?)

Alternatives to the 4% rule that will protect your retirement portfolio even during the greatest of depressions 

And So Much More!


Links from the Show

Mindy on BiggerPockets

Scott on BiggerPockets

Listen to All Your Favorite BiggerPockets Podcasts in One Place

Join BiggerPockets for FREE

Email Mindy: Mindy@biggerpockets.com

Email Scott: Scott@biggerpockets.com

BiggerPockets Money Facebook Group

Follow BiggerPockets Money on Instagram

“Like” BiggerPockets Money on Facebook

BiggerPockets Money YouTube Channel

BiggerPockets Real Estate 1,095 - Scott Trench: How I'm Protecting My Money From “Irrational Exuberance”

BiggerPockets Money 120 - Are FIRE Naysayers Bad at Math? Yes. with Michael Kitces

The Rational Investor’s Case Against Bitcoin

Dow Jones - DJIA - 100 Year Historical Chart

Try REsimpli, The Only All-In-One Real Estate Investor CRM Software That Helps You Manage Data, Marketing, Sales, and Operations

Get to FIRE Faster with “Set for Life”

Sign Up for the BiggerPockets Money Newsletter

Find an Investor-Friendly Agent in Your Area


(00:00) Is the 4% Rule Dead?

(04:39) You CANNOT FIRE with This

(11:42) How to Prepare for Downturns

(21:12) Assets That Are At Risk

(23:17) What Scott’s Buying/Selling

(28:29) Alternatives to 4% Rule Portfolio

(34:21) Do You Trust the 4% Rule?


Check out more resources from this show on BiggerPockets.com and https://www.biggerpockets.com/blog/money-619


Interested in learning more about today’s sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Email advertise@biggerpockets.com

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Aug 5
How to Reach Coast FIRE (The Relaxed Way to Retire!)
Tired of the extreme saving grind? What if there was a way to front-load your retirement savings and then "coast" to financial independence without the stress? In this episode of the BiggerPockets Money Podcast, hosts Mindy Jensen and Scott Trench break down Coast FI - the strate ... Show More
32m 14s
Aug 1
How “Regular” People Can Achieve FIRE (Early Retirement) by 40!
Join hosts Mindy Jensen and Scott Trench as they sit down with Cody Garrett, a former musician turned financial planner who discovered the FIRE movement seven years ago and is now just four years away from achieving financial independence by age 40. Cody's unique dual perspective ... Show More
48m 50s
Jul 29
Are We Heading Into a Recession? J Scott Breaks It Down
In this episode of the BiggerPockets Money podcast, hosts Mindy Jensen and Scott Trench are joined by real estate expert J Scott to break down the mixed signals dominating today's economic landscape. Are we or we not heading into a recession? They discuss what's really happening ... Show More
52m 7s
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2025
The Opportunity is Coming in Commercial Real Estate (How to Take Advantage)
The multifamily and commercial real estate crash seems to be nearing its end, which means some incredible buying opportunities are on the way. Big apartment owners have been decimated after their occupancy rates dropped, interest rates shot up, and loans got called due. But when ... Show More
40m 19s
Jan 2025
How to Make More Passive Income with Fewer Rentals (& ACTUALLY Retire Early) w/Chad Carson
Want to retire early? Then, STOP buying rental properties. You heard that right; buying more rental properties may actually push you further away from early retirement IF you’ve crossed a certain threshold. Today’s guest proves you don’t need dozens of rental properties to reach ... Show More
47m 38s
Sep 2024
What to Invest in When You’re NOT Buying Real Estate
Struggling to pick what to invest in, especially when real estate prices and mortgage rates are still so high? Many investors are sitting on the sidelines, saving cash for their first or next investment property, but nothing seems to work out. So what do you do, keep your money s ... Show More
51m 1s
Aug 2024
How to Retire Early with Fewer Rental Properties Than You Think w/Chad Carson
You want to retire early, so you come up with a plan. “I’m going to buy ten rental properties and call it quits, then I’ll never have to work again.” Within a decade, you’ve got your ten rental properties, but now you want more. You buy another ten, then a big apartment complex, ... Show More
50m 46s
Oct 2024
These 6 Side Hustles Made Us Millionaires - Start Making More Money TODAY (F.I.R.E. For Beginners)
▸▸▸https://www.365daystofire.com/ We're so excited to announce that enrollment for our 365 Days to F.I.R.E. Program is now open! To learn more, go to: https://www.365daystofire.com/ —-Enroll in our Stock Market Investing Course for Financial Independence and Retiring Early: https ... Show More
8m 38s
Nov 2024
The Savings Expert: Are You Under 45? You Probably Aren’t Getting A Pension! Do Not Buy A House! This Is Probably Why You’re Broke! - Jaspreet Singh
Revealing what hedge funds and multinational banks don't want you to know about building wealth! Jaspreet Singh is spilling secrets and helping everyday people find financial freedom   Jaspreet Singh is an entrepreneur, former attorney, and financial educator. He is CEO of Briefs ... Show More
2h 30m
Jan 2025
How To Build Generational Wealth Without A Big Salary
“True generational wealth isn’t just a home—it’s income that lasts beyond your lifetime.” This is a mindset shift we all need. Learn from Jaspreet on how to redefine generational wealth and how to create it, even if you don’t make a high salary. From owning cash-flowing assets to ... Show More
26m 12s
Aug 2024
240: BiggerPockets Real Estate Episode 1,000: Real Estate Is Changing, and So Is BiggerPockets
For the past 999 episodes of the BiggerPockets Real Estate Podcast, we’ve heard stories from investors who have achieved financial freedom through rental property investing. However, when we started this podcast in 2013, it was a different time. The housing market had crashed jus ... Show More
47m 42s
Jul 2024
996: Financial Freedom in 3 Years by Investing in “Boring” Rental Properties
Can rental properties replace your W2 income, lead you to financial freedom, and help you build multimillion-dollar wealth in the process? Yes, and Grant Francke is proof you can do it in a few years or less. After the burnout of forty-eight-hour shifts as a railroad conductor (y ... Show More
41m 17s
Jul 2024
984: Pay Off Student Loans or Invest in Real Estate: Which Makes You Wealthier?
Should you pay off student loans or invest in real estate? This is the question Tom Keating had to ask himself back in 2018. At the time, he had no real estate investing experience and only picked up The Book on Rental Property Investing by chance. He still had student loans but ... Show More
35m 31s