logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2025
52m 12s

Did I Really Do That?

Hidden Brain, Shankar Vedantam
About this episode

Have you ever been falsely accused of something? Many of us think there’s only one way we’d act in such a situation: we’d defend ourselves. We’d do whatever it takes to clear our name — and above all else, we’d never, ever confess to something we didn’t do. But psychologist Saul Kassin says that’s a myth. This week, we bring you a favorite 2022 episode about why we sometimes act against our own self-interest — even when the stakes are at their highest.

In this week's episode, you'll learn about:

  • Why we often freeze and fail to defend ourselves when someone accuses us of something
  • The various types of false confessions
  • What happens in our minds when we're pressured to confess to something that we didn't actually do
  • How police interrogation tactics are being used in workplaces and other organizations
  • Potential solutions to the problem of false confessions 

For more on the psychological dimensions of criminal justice, check out our episode on the infamous Stanford prison experiment.

And if you'd like to check out the research of Saul Kassin and others on this topic, visit our web page for this episode

Episode image by Tama66, Pixabay. 

 

 

Up next
Aug 4
Radical Kindness
Why do some people risk their own lives to help another person, or give away their fortunes for the benefit of strangers? This week, we talk with psychologist and neuroscientist Abigail Marsh, who studies the science of altruism. We'll explore what's known about the brains of peo ... Show More
1h 4m
Jul 28
You 2.0: Change Your Story, Change Your Life
We all tell stories about ourselves, often without realizing we’re doing so. How we frame those stories can profoundly shape our lives. In our latest You 2.0 episode, we bring you a favorite conversation with psychologist Jonathan Adler. He shares how to tell our stories in ways ... Show More
1h 17m
Jul 21
You 2.0: The Wisdom of Stoicism
What does it mean to be stoic? Many of us assume it means you have a stiff upper lip, or that you suppress your emotions. That's what Massimo Pigliucci thought — until he started to peruse a book called Meditations. It was written nearly two thousand years ago by the Roman Empero ... Show More
50m 11s
Recommended Episodes
May 2024
Human Nature Vs. Money: Battling Irrationality & Thinking Traps [#2 Cognitive Biases]
Manipulation tactics that work - Irrational behaviours that don't - Prediction Fallacies we fall for.In this episode, we dive further into our series on cognitive biases and how they cloud our judgment.Studying applied psychology we can learn how we get manipulated by companies a ... Show More
31m 9s
Nov 2024
How to Respond to Gaslighting
Ever been in an argument where someone twists your words, denies things that happened, or makes you doubt your own reality?Gaslighting can be one of the most frustrating and confusing behaviors to deal with. It leaves you questioning your memory, feeling blamed, and wondering if ... Show More
15m 6s
Mar 2025
76. The Polygraph with Retired FBI Agent George Olivo
Retired FBI agent and senior polygraph examiner George Olivo joins The Consult to separate fact from fiction when it comes to the polygraph. With years of experience administering polygraphs, he explains how they really work, their strengths and limitations, and the myths that ha ... Show More
1h 32m
Dec 2024
Cold Case Solved by a Witness After 20 Years
In recent years, cold cases that were solved through advances in science have been the main focus of popular documentary television shows such as Forensic Files and The New Detectives. These shows highlight the unwavering precision of DNA evidence, often a stark contrast to the s ... Show More
20m 26s
Apr 2020
Crossover Week: Crimes of Passion (Lorena Bobbitt Pt. 3)
If you enjoy the true stories told in Not Guilty, check out this episode from our series Crimes of Passion: Just because John and Lorena Bobbitt were acquitted for their individual crimes in 1994 didn't mean their challenges were behind them. But while Lorena used her verdict to ... Show More
48m 37s
Jan 2024
Will Kouri Richins Claim Mental Health Issues as Murder Defense?
The Tragic Tale of Kouri and Eric Richins: A Poisoning Mystery Unraveled  What happens when the person you trust the most becomes a suspect in your untimely demise? This question forms the crux of a recent episode of the podcast "Hidden Killers," where host Tony Brueski and forme ... Show More
8m 12s
May 18
Ep 176: Little White Lies
We’ve all stared at the calendar, convinced there’s a hidden twenty-fifth hour—plenty of room to redline that section, nudge the model, and squeeze in just one more detail. “We’ll sort it during bidding,” we promise ourselves, and the optimism buys another day of breathing room. ... Show More
1h 10m
Feb 2025
From the Vault: The Illusion of Control, Part 1
In this classic episode of Stuff to Blow Your Mind, Robert and Joe discuss our psychological tendency to overestimate our control over events, with implications for everything from gambling and paranormal beliefs to our movements through everyday life. (originally published 2/8/2 ... Show More
40m 31s
Apr 2025
MURDEROUS MINDS: The Model Student Murderer Pt. 2
Jennifer Pan’s lies were finally unraveling—and she was desperate to regain control. When her parents discovered the truth, she didn’t beg for forgiveness. She planned their murder. In this episode, we follow the investigation, the shocking confession, and the trial that stunned ... Show More
53m 49s