logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2025
1h 16m

Emily in What-If Land

Tara Llewellyn & Haley McIntosh
About this episode

The woman, the icon, the legend: Emily Gilmore. Who is she? Where did she come from? We have so many questions about the history of Emily Gilmore, where she would be if she chose different paths throughout the show, and of course exploring your “what if” questions! Grab a cup of coffee and get comfortable because Tara and Haley have more to say.

If you want more recap episodes, join us on Patreon for our spoiler-FULL rewatch, Gilmore Revisited as we dive into Season 7 (begrudgingly but curiously).

Our Gilmore to Say Core Collection is live! Shop now at www.gilmoretosay.com.

Want to hear your voice on our next GTC? If you have more to say, call in with your thoughts at 860-578-4653. We love hearing from you!

Now you can watch the girlies every week by subscribing to us on YouTube!

Where you lead I will follow...us @gilmoretosaypodcast



Our Sponsors:
* Check out Factor: https://factormeals.com/factorpodcast
* Check out Happy Mammoth and use our code GTS for 15% your entire first order! https://happymammoth.com


Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Up next
Aug 5
You Rewrite, I Rewrite Season 7
The rewrite you’ve all been asking for (for years!!!!!) has finally arrived! Can we take Season 7 from bland sheet cake to luscious layer cake without throwing it out all together?? Grab a cup of coffee and get comfortable because Tara and Haley have more to say.Our Summer Gazebo ... Show More
1h 23m
Jul 31
Gilmore To Read: Jasmine Guillory
My book loving besties! I'm so excited to be back again with another fantastic author.In this episode of Gilmore To Read, the New York Times Bestselling author Jasmine Guillory joins me to talk about Reading Is Sexy's book club pick for April: her latest book, Flirting Lessons. W ... Show More
1h 9m
Jul 29
Gilmore to Consider #50: What if Lorelai and Luke Eloped?
Where you call, we will answer! In our 50th (!!!) Gilmore to Consider episode, we’re exploring some of your “what ifs” from Instagram and listening to voicemails about Season 7. What if Lorelai hadn’t told Luke about sleeping with Christopher? What if she had slept with Jason ins ... Show More
45m 53s
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2025
Gilmore Girls Gazette: Bach’s Got Game
Sebastian Bach is spilling the TEA! What major star ditched an A-List heartthrob for the rocker? A real life Gilmore Girls Dragonfly Inn exists! We’ll tell you where.  Plus, YOU decided which tv show will be our next rewatch after Bunheads, find out the results. Follow @iamallinp ... Show More
37m 42s
Mar 2025
Gilmore Girls Gazette: Bunheads: Too Soon to Say Goodbye
It’s the second to last episode of the series, and we are sad to see it go!    We loved watching everyone together in one spot, but why did this episode hit too close to home for Amy and Danielle?   Plus, we’ll tell you which two characters are responsible for giving us the Gilmo ... Show More
23m 42s
Nov 2023
You Can Pull Link Sausages Out of Me (S6 E7 "Twenty-One Is The Loneliest Number")
Happy 21st Rory!  (Even though your drink is disgusting) We love this episode.  It's perfect timing for Halloween and we love Lorelai's enthusiasm. We have hope for a reunited Rory and Lorelai, although we're not there quite yet. Luke and Lorelai continue to be the heart of this ... Show More
54m 35s
Jul 2019
Season 15 Episode 13 'The Bachelorette' Review
Tonight is the tale of two very different family visits for Tyler and Jed after Peter is sent home. How do they go? What does this mean for Hannah and their relationships? Who will she pick?? Join Mike Thieling, Christine Alexis and Renee Ariel as they break down part 1 of the 2 ... Show More
1 h
Dec 2024
267. Season Six Finale While You Were Sleeping with special guest Moranne Keeler
“Lucy, you are born into a family. You do not join them like you do the Marines.” It’s the Season Six Finale, and we watched “While You Were Sleeping” with our favorite gal pal, Moranne Keeler, and boy do we love us some Sandra Bullock. We spend a good portion of the pod ponderin ... Show More
1h 51m
Dec 2024
I Am All In…Again: Give Me GilMORE
Luke and Lorelai have been reunited and we've got more behind the scenes for you.    Like you, Scott wants more, more, more!    Plus, what prop on set was giving them trouble while filming?See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
13m 47s
Apr 2023
It’s Lorelai (S5 E2 "A Messenger, Nothing More”)
Luke and Lorela :  Cute phone conversations and an "about to kiss" moment interrupted by a marching band! Lane:  She loves Zach but do we??? Kirk:  Where was Kirk?? Lindsay and Dean:  Yikes! Lindsay and her mom vs Rory and Lorelai:  Double YIKES!   Would you have been "a messenge ... Show More
1h 7m
Apr 2025
Gilmore Girls Gazette: Bunheads Out
Bunheads has come to an end… What storyline left Amy and Danielle wanting more episodes?   Since we loved all the characters, we deep dive into what the actors are up to now.    Were you bummed Bunheads ended so soon?? Let us know on our Instagram @iamallinpodcast!See omnystudio. ... Show More
19m 45s
Aug 2018
The Proposal S:1 | LaToya and Tyler guest on Episode 10 | AfterBuzz TV AfterShow
On tonight’s episode of the Proposal After Show, we talk about our non-negotiables AND turn-ons in a relationship! As Well as how likely we think the newly engaged couple will last! Plus we have special guest LaToya and Tyler in studio! Hosting tonight is Michael Clouse, Mina Wah ... Show More
50m 37s
Sep 2018
Wynonna Earp S:3 | Undo It E:9 | AfterBuzz TV AfterShow
Un-doin’ it, un-doin’ it, un-doin’ it well! Is this a video game or is this an episode of Wynonna Earp?! In this episode we get a HEALER and we gain a Mercedes… MVP: Waverly for the face lift. Hosting tonight, are AfterBuzz TV Panelists Yael Tygiel, Kari Lane, and Amber Plaster! ... Show More
41m 42s