logo
episode-header-image
Feb 2025
1h 48m

We Roast Each Other's Cars — The Carmudg...

Hagerty Media
About this episode

It's time to be honest with each other and the world: Derek and Jason take turns roasting (or just honestly reviewing) the other's cars in their collections. Plus, they roast their own stuff.


We’ll cover the good and the bad of nearly all of the boys’ various vehicles: 


Derek’s bikes – the Ducati Panigale V4S and Husqvarna 701 Supermoto. 

Jason’s E30s – the 325i wagon and beater sedan track car. 


The mid-engine Italian exotics – Derek's Lamborghini Miura and Jason's 1975 Ferrari 308 GT4.


Then, Jason's mid-engine micro machine 1991 Honda Beat. Naturally, a plethora of Mercedes products will be in the mix – the R129 500SL, W201 190E 2.3-16, W124 E320 wagon and W202 C43. The atypical oddballs: the Rover SD1 and Citroen CX. 


Plus Jason’s new-to-him V12 E31 BMW 850 CSi and Derek’s favorite back-road weapon 964-chassis Porsche 911. And we’ll round things out with Jason’s babies – the VW Scirocco and Mk1 Cabriolet. 


You’ll learn about the Rover SD1’s sketchy, outdated front suspension design, and the 190E’s oversized steering wheel and underbolstered seats. The corpulent hamster styling of the e-Golf and terrible brake balancing on the Beat. The 964 sounds like flatulence, and the VW Cabriolet sounds like imminent disintegration. Recaro-equipped, art deco, cheap, and Zebra-print interiors. Sloppy shifters, burning odors, affordable V12 Ferraris and BMWs, and the Mk1 VWs’ good vibrations versus the E30 M3’s shit ones. 


Join us for some Nikki Glaser-inspired antics, Carmudgeon-style!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Jun 9
Ask Us Anything: Part 3 — The Carmudgeon Show with Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep. 195
Time for another AMA round of Ask Us Anything! We asked our listeners (that’s you) for questions, and we were positively bombarded. Now we return the favor with sarcasm and sass, plus an answer or two! (Note: due to timing concerns, the last two episodes were published out of ord ... Show More
1h 22m
Jun 9
The C8 Corvette ZR1 Meets Its Predecessors — and Ferraris and Lambos — The Carmudgeon Show Ep. 196
The C8 ZR1 has arrived, and so too has a new ICONS episode on Detroit’s supercar-killing, 1064-hp twin-turbo, flat-plane crank Corvette. We’ll review the new car in detail and cover all the important bit players: the original 6-cylinder C1, the C3’s optional ZR1 package, the Lotu ... Show More
1h 7m
May 19
BMW M5 Touring vs Audi RS6 Performance — Carmudgeon Show w Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep 194
We review the new Audi RS6 Avant Performance, G99 BMW M5 Touring, Mercedes-AMG S63 E Performance and Porsche Panamera Turbo S E-Hybrid. One looks spectacular, one has the most impressive suspension of all time, and one is unbuyable. === This episode is sponsored by Vyper Industri ... Show More
54m 35s
Recommended Episodes
Apr 23
McMurtry Spéirling SMOKES the Porsche GT3 RS
Matt Farah from "The Smoking Tire" joins Spike and Zuckerman as they dive into luxury cars, electric speedsters, and car show highlights. From baldness comparisons to a Bentley Flying Spur review and the shocking McMurtry Spéirling that beat a Porsche 911 GT3 RS, this episode bri ... Show More
1h 12m
Jun 13
Maserati Is Doomed. Trump Selling His Tesla on Cars & Bids? $45K for an E46 M3?
Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Thank You To Our Sponsors! Upgrade your wardrobe and save on @trueclassic at https://trueclassic.com/CARS #trueclassicpod Acre Gold - https://www.getacregold.com 30 ... Show More
1h 26m
Mar 2025
We Bought the Untouched E39 BMW M5
Zuckerman just scored a unicorn—a Dakar Yellow E39 BMW M5 with only 633 ORIGINAL MILES! Spike, Zuckerman, and guest Drew Leslie from EAG break down the absurd negotiation process, the restoration challenges, and whether this car is too perfect to drive. Plus, Spike dishes on his ... Show More
1h 9m
Jun 11
Porsche’s 963 Road Car Is a One-Off
Join Spike, Jonny, and Zuckerman for a heated debate over the new Porsche 963 RSP Le Mans street-legal hypercar. Does a suspicious cupholder hint that it's actually headed for full production? Plus, they dive into the Porsche Carrera GTS T-Hybrid models and roast the complete flo ... Show More
1 h
Oct 2024
New Porsche GT3s with Andreas Preuninger
Not one but two new Porsche 911 GT3s are upon us, both a regular be-winged car and the more subtle Touring model. And for once, the headline news isn’t the power, the peak revs or the Nürburgring lap time, but how practical it is. That’s right, because for the first time in the 2 ... Show More
32m 58s
Jun 27
Mercedes AMG Reveals Ugly 1340HP Sedan, Next Lexus Supercar Spotted, RX-7 Rumors?
Join Kennan and Filippo for IMSA Sports Car Weekend at Road America for Cars & Bids Trackside Cars & Coffee! August 3rd! Submit your car HERE! https://crsnbds.com/IMSA Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS Thank You ... Show More
1h 22m
Apr 2
Seen Through Glass's Nightmare Ferrari Restoration
This week, Spike, Zuckerman, and guest Sam Fane from ‪https://youtube.com/@seenthroughglass‬ unpack why Sam’s ditching his Porsche Boxster, the chaos of restoring a Ferrari 360 Challenge Stradale he accidentally bought, and Matt Farah's 8-hour The Smoking Tire 1000th episode. Als ... Show More
1h 6m
Jun 25
Alpine A110: The Best Sportscar You Can’t Buy
Spike and Jonny are joined by Zack Klapman from The Smoking Tire Podcast for a three-car extravaganza, reviewing the Alpine A110, Mercedes AMG GT 63 S E Performance, and Audi A3. Highlights include Jonny's hilarious story about his misadventures in Russia with Land Rover, debates ... Show More
56m 9s
May 30
Porsche Kills the 718! China Crushes Tesla! Doug on BMW’s Ugly Redemption Arc!
Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Thank You To Our Sponsors! DeleteMe - https://joindeleteme.com/DEMURO Get 20% off your plan! Download Cash App Today: https://capl.onelink.me/vFut/kk6qvwgr#CashAppPod ... Show More
1h 34m
May 23
The Downfall of Nissan is Here! New Apple CarPlay is Bad? Best Investment Cars?
Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS ⁠⁠⁠⁠ Thank You To Our Sponsors! Ava - https://www.meetava.com Code- CARPOD, you’ll get your first month FREE! https://AmericanFinancing.net/Doug Disclaimer:NMLS 182334, nmls ... Show More
1h 24m