logo
episode-header-image
Feb 2025
1h 48m

We Roast Each Other's Cars — The Carmudg...

Hagerty Media
About this episode

It's time to be honest with each other and the world: Derek and Jason take turns roasting (or just honestly reviewing) the other's cars in their collections. Plus, they roast their own stuff.


We’ll cover the good and the bad of nearly all of the boys’ various vehicles: 


Derek’s bikes – the Ducati Panigale V4S and Husqvarna 701 Supermoto. 

Jason’s E30s – the 325i wagon and beater sedan track car. 


The mid-engine Italian exotics – Derek's Lamborghini Miura and Jason's 1975 Ferrari 308 GT4.


Then, Jason's mid-engine micro machine 1991 Honda Beat. Naturally, a plethora of Mercedes products will be in the mix – the R129 500SL, W201 190E 2.3-16, W124 E320 wagon and W202 C43. The atypical oddballs: the Rover SD1 and Citroen CX. 


Plus Jason’s new-to-him V12 E31 BMW 850 CSi and Derek’s favorite back-road weapon 964-chassis Porsche 911. And we’ll round things out with Jason’s babies – the VW Scirocco and Mk1 Cabriolet. 


You’ll learn about the Rover SD1’s sketchy, outdated front suspension design, and the 190E’s oversized steering wheel and underbolstered seats. The corpulent hamster styling of the e-Golf and terrible brake balancing on the Beat. The 964 sounds like flatulence, and the VW Cabriolet sounds like imminent disintegration. Recaro-equipped, art deco, cheap, and Zebra-print interiors. Sloppy shifters, burning odors, affordable V12 Ferraris and BMWs, and the Mk1 VWs’ good vibrations versus the E30 M3’s shit ones. 


Join us for some Nikki Glaser-inspired antics, Carmudgeon-style!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Oct 6
Why The Malaise Era Was Actually Good — Carmudgeon w/ Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep. 207
The Malaise Era, a period of the US auto industry from the early 1970s to the mid 1980s, was certainly not one that garners much enthusiasm or celebration from your typical modern day car enthusiast. The rather abrupt introduction of stricter emissions and safety standards, plus ... Show More
1h 13m
Sep 29
Special Guests, Dustin and John From Driveway Finds! — Carmudgeon w/ Jason Cammisa & DTS — Ep. 206
Hagerty has a new show on the block - Driveway Finds! And it just so happens that its hosts/creators, Dustin Hallinan and John Brito, live a short drive away from The Carmudgeon Show studio. Chaos ensues. But maybe not in the way you’d think… === This episode is sponsored by Batt ... Show More
1h 34m
Sep 22
Vonnen’s Porsche 911 Does The Unthinkable — Carmudgeon w/ Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep. 205
Air-cooled Porsche 911s are wonderful to drive. With charming handling characteristics, bank vault build quality, and often cheerfully entertaining powertrains, it’s no surprise that they’re a hot commodity in the collector car marketplace with millions of fans around the world. ... Show More
59m 15s
Recommended Episodes
Apr 2025
McMurtry Spéirling SMOKES the Porsche GT3 RS
Matt Farah from "The Smoking Tire" joins Spike and Zuckerman as they dive into luxury cars, electric speedsters, and car show highlights. From baldness comparisons to a Bentley Flying Spur review and the shocking McMurtry Spéirling that beat a Porsche 911 GT3 RS, this episode bri ... Show More
1h 12m
Aug 6
How NOT to Unload a $6M Yellowbird
Spike and the crew discuss the rumored Porsche GT3 Cabriolet, a viral $6M Yellowbird accident, and Jonny's epic test drives of the Lamborghini Temerario and Bugatti Mistral. Things get heated during a BMW M5 Touring vs Audi RS6 Avant debate, while Zuckerman keeps things classy in ... Show More
1 h
Sep 12
New Ferrari Revealed! Mercedes Announces Dream DougCar, We Sold a Manual Cayenne for $125k?!
Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS Thank you to our sponsors! Download Upside and use code CARS to get an extra 25 cents back for every gallon on your first tank of gas. Get $10 Off at BRUNT with code CARS at http ... Show More
1h 27m
Aug 12
Top 5 Sports Cars Under $50K, The First Sports Car, The Aging Fleet | Episode 1,007
The guys start a new ‘recommendation’ series about the top cars, trucks and SUVs they would buy. This episode begins with sports cars, and they each name and discuss the reasons for their top 5. They also debate first sports cars for Michael in LA, who has finally decided it’s ti ... Show More
1h 51m
Sep 24
Mint Condition: Baiju Bhatt's Perfect Porsche 964 RS
Spike is joined by the crew to talk cars, comedy, and a special guest interview with Baiju Bhatt, co-founder of Robinhood. They dive into the Bridge car show, Porsche's future lineup shakeup, and a controversial center-steering Porsche mod. Plus, Baiju Bhatt shows off his Porsche ... Show More
1h 8m
Oct 7
The Most Fun Car At Each Price Point, Van Life In A Car, Jail Speeds In First Gear | Episode 1,015
What’s the most fun car at each price point? The guys start at $5K and work their way to the $100k price level, and each come up with their own list. For Mark & Tamara in TX, they debate fun cars that could theoretically be used for van life. Then, Art B. loves horsepower and spe ... Show More
1h 43m
Sep 9
Top 5 GT Cars - Most Fun Under $50K, Sports Car-Shaped Hole, Does The Dealer Always Know Best? | Episode 1,011
For the list of Top 5 GT Cars Under $50K, the guys need to first define what a GT car is, but the also wonder if GT cars are still prevalent from manufacturers. Do they still resonate with buyers? They discuss a debate for Matthew T, who has a sports-car-shaped hole in his life. ... Show More
1h 34m
Sep 5
The Audi TT is Back! Lotus is in Big Trouble. Best Porsche 911?
Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS Thank you to our sponsors! Express VPN - Find out how you can get up to four extra months FREE. https://ExpressVPN.com/CARS Prize Picks - https://prizepicks.onelink.me/LME0/CARS ... Show More
1h 31m
Apr 2025
Patrick Long on Air|Water and the Future of Porsche
This week, Spike and Zuckerman are joined by professional racer Patrick Long, where they dive into car troubles with a broken Porsche 912. They review hilarious Morris Solomons dealership logo submissions, discuss the exciting Willow Springs acquisition, and debate the market val ... Show More
55m 52s
Aug 20
James Pumphrey's Making a Drift Movie
James Pumphrey from Speeed returns to the garage to discuss Sung Kang's 'Drifter' movie, review the Ineos Grenadier and BMW M5, and debate Ford's mystery EV pickup truck and Porsche rumors. Plus, we show off a custom car that we guarantee you've never seen anything like before! _ ... Show More
1h 4m