logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2025
1h 6m

Haunted with Georgia Hardstark of My Fav...

Sony Music Entertainment
About this episode
This episode is a major full circle moment and our My Favorite Murder fangirl dreams come true. We sat down with the incredible Georgia Hardstark from My Favorite Murder and confirmed that she does love Grandparents and was in fact the kid who played ouija boards at sleepovers when she was a kid.🎉

Together, we dive into the paranormal, true crime conspiracies, and haunted treasures. From ghostly gowns and eerie poison rings to haunted houses with gangster spirits and a ghost cow or two. 🏚️🐄👻

Georgia shares stories about her love for vintage items, potential hauntings, and a very suspicious brooch that freaked her cat out (haunted accessory alert?!). Plus, we explore her paranormal encounters as a kid, her thoughts on aliens (future humans?!), and what she’d do as a ghost—spoiler: it involves cats and mischief. 🐾✨

We also played a paranormal twist on Two Truths and a Lie that had us guessing which Victorian mansion, Edwardian gown, or mysterious antique might be hiding a haunted past.

Grab your headphones, some snacks (ghost cheese, anyone?), and settle in for an hour of laughter, chills, and spooky inspiration.

This episode is sponsored by iRestore and Nature Sage.

  • iRestore Illumina Face Mask is 360 medical-grade LEDs of pure magic which is double most other brands. It hits your skin with red, infrared, and blue light all at once, tackling wrinkles, acne, and inflammation like a boss. For a limited time, our listeners get $205 off their Illumina Face Mask with code TGOG25 at iRestorelaser.com 
  • Naturesage makes plant-based, Omega 3 supplements you’ll love (without the fishy taste). Head to NatureSageOmega3.com/TGOG and use code TGOG for 40% off your order.
If you enjoy our show, please consider joining our Patreon, rating and reviewing on iTunes & Spotify and following us on social media! Youtube, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, and Discord.

Edited and produced by Jaimi Ryan, original music by Arms Akimbo!

Disclaimer: the use of white sage and smudging is a closed practice. If you’re looking to cleanse your space, here are some great alternatives!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Oct 9
Encounters x302 - Demonic Encounters & Attachments
Things are getting dark—and we mean demonically dark because we’re bringing you some of our scariest listener stories. Shadow men, faceless figures, haunted houses, and demonic attachments that refuse to leave. These stories gave us chills, waves of doom, and even chest pains—and ... Show More
58m 8s
Oct 7
Haunted with Haunted Objects
Things are getting extra haunted because we’ve brought a collection of haunted objects into the TGOG studio for the entire month of October. This episode introduces each eerie piece, including a sorrowful bear named Boo Boo, a vessel called Lily, a haunted cat figurine, and even ... Show More
59m 2s
Oct 5
Episode 342 - Ouija Boards Gone Wrong
October is in full swing, and we’re cracking open the door to the other side! We’ve got terrifying Ouija board tales pulled from Reddit’s darkest corners: a haunted doll harboring the sinister Tall Man, a Boy Scout camp session that unleashed something calling itself The Beast, a ... Show More
56m 43s
Recommended Episodes
Sep 27
HAUNTED BUNK BED From HELL! The TRUE Tolman Family Horror Story | Real Ghost Stories LIVE
Few haunted object cases have rattled the paranormal world like the story of the Tolman family and their cursed bunk bed in Wisconsin. After bringing home a secondhand bed in the late 1980s, their lives spiraled into months of relentless terror. Children fell mysteriously ill. Ra ... Show More
23m 43s
Sep 2024
The Ghost in the Nightgown: A Mother's Paranormal Nightmares
In this chilling episode of True Scary Story, Fatima recounts her encounters with the paranormal, which intensified during her pregnancy and after the birth of her daughter. Raised in a religiously complex family, she initially dismissed these experiences as tricks of the mind, b ... Show More
20m 50s
Jan 2025
Ghostmail #60 | Sacrifices In The Attic of a House in Kingsland GA & MORE!
Become a Parajunkie Today for zero ads always, private livestreams, extra content, and MORE! www.patreon.com/savannahunderground In this episode of The Most Haunted City on Earth, Madison and Chris Soucy dive into a captivating Ghostmail session, where our beloved Parajunkies sha ... Show More
45m 59s
Nov 2024
Our Favorite Ghost Stories + Beasts From Beyond w/ Elle Dougherty!
Become a Parajunkie today and never listen to another ad! www.patreon.com/savannahunderground In this episode of The Most Haunted City on Earth, Madison Timmons is out of the studio so we invited Parajunkie and animal lover Elle Dougherty to tell Chris and JT about her paranormal ... Show More
54m 53s
Sep 5
HAUNTED: Bobby Mackey's Music World
Bobby Mackey's Music World, a honky-tonk bar in Wilder, Kentucky, is said to be haunted by a host of restless spirits. From tragic deaths and violent crimes to rumored connections to the occult, the history of the building is just as terrifying as the spirits who inhabit it—turni ... Show More
45m 40s
Sep 2022
The Whistler
Dan has a story about a young boy named Cody and his imaginary “friend”  who is NOT friendly and not imaginary. Then a collection of paranormal sightings in Plainfield, Wisconsin, that all revolve around the ghosts of either murderer Ed Gein - his mother, or his victims. Lynze ha ... Show More
1h 4m
Dec 2024
Ghostmail #57 | A Ghost At The Titanic Museum, Guardian Angels, & MORE!
Become a Parajunkie Today! www.patreon.com/savannahunderground Take a listen to our new podcast, From One To Wicked here: https://open.spotify.com/show/06QAIRzlD07PLxLLm3tHfA Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/from-one-to-wicked/id1772817108 👻 Welcome to a spe ... Show More
43m 50s
Sep 2024
Ghostmail #54 | Possible Encounter With Black Eyed Children, & MORE!
Become a Parajunkie today! Zero Ads Always plus livestreams every week. www.patreon.com/savannahunderground 👻 Welcome to another thrilling episode of "The Most Haunted City on Earth"! In this episode, our hosts Madison, Chris, and special co-host J.T. dive into our "Ghostmail" s ... Show More
1h 8m
Feb 2025
Ghostmail #61 | Terror in a HAUNTED Minnesota Ore Mine!
At the end of the year, we will be purchasing a new RV and taking it around the country to the most haunted locations! Become a Parajunkie to support this endeavor!Welcome back, Parajunkies! In this chilling episode of Ghost Mail, we're diving into some of the most spine-tingling ... Show More
53m 55s
Sep 22
Dialing the Dead: A Séance with Sam & Colby
Weirdos! This week, we’re diving headfirst into the haunted and the unexplainable with none other than Sam & Colby! They’ve shared their passion for seeking the paranormal, taunting the unknown, and occasionally screaming at shadows in abandoned places. Sam & Colby talk about som ... Show More
1h 53m