This episode is a major full circle moment and our My Favorite Murder fangirl dreams come true. We sat down with the incredible Georgia Hardstark from My Favorite Murder and confirmed that she does love Grandparents and was in fact the kid who played ouija boards at sleepovers when she was a kid.🎉
Together, we dive into the paranormal, true crime conspirac ... Show More
Aug 2
Episode 384 - Champ | The Lake Monster That Almost Ate Corinne
It’s Corinne’s birthday, so we’re celebrating the only way that feels right, by diving into one of her favorite cryptids. Meet Champ, the legendary Lake Champlain monster. We dig into eyewitness accounts, famous photographs, underwater sounds, Indigenous legends, and the incredib ... Show More
1h 2m
Jul 30
Encounters x342 - Don't Go In the Water | Ghost Ships, Lake Legends & Haunted Shores
We’re diving into haunted waters this week with listener stories exploring eerie lakes, ghostly maritime encounters, and the strange pull of places where water and the supernatural seem to meet. Grab your life jacket, trust your instincts, and maybe think twice before wandering t ... Show More
59m 8s
Jul 26
Episode 383 - Reddit Horror Stories with Morgan Absher & Kaelyn Moore
This week Sabrina is joined by Morgan Absher and Kaelyn Moore (Clues, Two Hot Takes & Heart Starts Pounding), for a Reddit horror story swap that's creepy, chaotic, and hilarious. We trade some of the internet's most unsettling stories from Appalachian legends, cryptids, and Bigf ... Show More
1h 10m
Oct 2025
Ep. 63 - Take’n a SPOOKY Vacation
On today’s episode, Genevieve will be taking you back to some of our favorite cemeteries, public hangings, creepy seances and ax murders that we’ve enjoyed together in episodes of yore!Subscribe to the Newsletter!Subscribe to the Patreon free trial for ad-free listening!
43m 31s
Apr 2023
Freaky Friday: Episode 57
Tales from the Court Clerk; Haunted Playhouse; Possessed By An Entity; More tales of the mall; and special guest stories from Tyrella and Tori, co-hosts of the podcast Killer Queens!This week for our guest stories segment, we are joined by Tyrella and Tori, co-hosts of the podcas ... Show More
1h 19m