logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2025
1 h

Best "Melrose Place" Character

W!ZARD STUDIOS
About this episode

Fox’s Melrose Place was intended to be an introspective drama about young adult life in 1990s L.A. But by Season 2, the show leaned into its soapy elements, with ever-shifting love triangles, backstabbing office rivalries, and more than a few iconic villains stealing babies, faking pregnancies, and even blowing up the apartment complex. At its height, the show reached nearly 15 million viewers, and its young and restless stars were EVERYWHERE. The show ended on a whimper in 1999, and had a mediocre CW revival in 2009. But for this Patreon-sponsored episode, we’re going to back Melrose, as the Great Pop Culture Debate seeks to determine the Best Melrose Place Character.


Characters discussed: Sydney Andrews, Lexi Sterling, Jane Mancini, Jo Reynolds, Dr. Michael Mancini, Billy Campbell, Megan Lewis, Taylor McBride, Amanda Woodward, Jennifer Mancini, Brooke Armstrong, Jake Taylor, Dr. Kimberly Shaw, Dr. Peter Burns, Matt Fielding, Alison Parker.


Join host Eric Rezsnyak, Patreon sponsor Bob Erlenback, and Special Guest Stars Courtney Fay and Todd Rezsnyak as they discuss 16 of the most notorious residents of 4616 Melrose Place.


For more exclusive content, including the warm-up in which we discuss the other Melrose Place lead cast members that didn’t make the bracket, become a Patreon supporter of the podcast today.


For more reasons why you should become a Patreon supporter, check out this Top 10.



Sign up for our weekly newsletter!

Subscribe to find out what’s new in pop culture each week right in your inbox!


Vote in more pop culture polls!

Check out our Open Polls. Your votes determine our future debates!

Then, vote in our Future Topic Polls to have a say in what episodes we tackle next.


Episode Credits

Host: Eric Rezsnyak

Patreon Sponsor: Bob Erlenback

Special Guests: Courtney Fay, Todd Rezsnyak

Producer: Curtis Creekmore

Editor: Bob Erlenback

Theme Music: “Dance to My Tune” by Marc Torch


#melroseplace #soapopera #90stvshows #aaronspelling #1990s #90s #2000stv #2000sthrowbacks #heatherlocklear #90ssoaps #primetimesoaps #grantshow #courtneythornesmith #marciacross #lisarinna

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Oct 6
PREVIEW: Worst Lead Character in a TV Series
Great Pop Culture Debate host Eric Rezsnyak explains how we created the bracket for our episode devoted to the WORST lead character in a TV series, and walks you through the Round 1 match-ups. The main episode will release on Tuesday, October 7, wherever you listen to podcasts. ⁠ ... Show More
4m 37s
Sep 30
Best Dolly Parton Song
Dolly Rebecca Parton grew up in extreme poverty in Appalachian Tennessee, and over the course of a legendary 60-year-and-counting career, would become one of the most important artists in country music. A singer, a songwriter, an actor, a producer, an entrepreneur, and a philanth ... Show More
58m 58s
Sep 23
Best "X-Files" Episode
“The X-Files” premiered on the Fox network in September 1993. While the sci-fi mystery show was inspired by earlier series like “The Twilight Zone,” “Twin Peaks,” and “Kolchak: The Night Stalker,” creator Chris Carter tapped into a unique moment in the cultural zeitgeist to produ ... Show More
58m 17s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2017
BEST SHOW HOLIDAY PARTY! PHILLY BOY ROY! JULIE KLAUSNER! CHRIS GETHARD! GARY THE SQUIRREL! TOO MUCH MORE!!!
IT’S THE BEST SHOW HOLIDAY PARTY! A CALL FROM PHILLY BOY ROY! JULIE KLAUSNER! CHRIS GETHARD! CLARE O'KANE! MARY HOULIHAN! BRETT DAVIS! JOSH KANTOR! FRED FROM HONOLULU! GARY SQUIRREL! TERRE T! J.PENRY! All in studio with TOO MANY MORE TO LIST!!! WATCH THE BEST SHOW LIVE EVERY TUES ... Show More
3h 55m
Aug 2024
Roy Rules
This week The Lonely Island and Seth talk about the digital short, Roy Rules! They discuss how the short came to be and we hear a special voice message on today's episode! The guys also talk about SNL sketches including Mike's Marbleopolis, Kuatos, and more!Roy Rules Mike's Marbl ... Show More
47m 45s
Dec 2024
The Criterion Episode
This week on the pod Seth Meyers is joined by Jake Tapper, Mike Schur, and Alan Sepinwall for a special breakdown of which digital shorts make the Criterion collection! They discuss what other categories the digital shorts can fall into, including “additional reading” and “Kim’s ... Show More
58 m
Jul 2024
The MacGruber Episode
This week, Will Forte and John Solomon take over the podcast! Joined by Seth and Jorma, the guys talk about how MacGruber was originally created, Will and John’s writing partnership, and the MacGruber sketches with Molly Shannon, Seth Rogen, and more!MacGruber (every episode) The ... Show More
54m 49s
Feb 2025
The SNL 50th Recap
In this special bonus episode brought to you by Airbnb, The Lonely Island and Seth Meyers recap their weekend participating in the Saturday Night Live 50th Anniversary Special! The Lonely Island: Musical Medley -  https://youtu.be/UV-RZYz8xTc?si=8IYmgJ8UEh4i2CM8Scared Straight - ... Show More
56m 21s
Aug 2018
2018 MTV Video Music Awards Special | AfterBuzz TV AfterShow
Dani Golub, J'Lamar, and Lauren Pacheco are breaking down all of your favorite moments from last night’s VMA’s. Chat with us about all things fashion, music, and winners. Follow us on http://www.Twitter.com/AfterBuzzTV "Like" Us on http://www.Facebook.com/AfterBuzzTV For more of ... Show More
51m 24s
Dec 2024
Listener Q&A Episode 2
This week The Lonely Island and Seth answer questions from listeners! Weekend Update Joke Swaps 2024 - https://youtu.be/GWu01Jr9sLY?si=vzUE843So3fMOQVtJorm Dances - https://youtu.be/p8nGLSlZbWo?si=sCvZbA4P61_5EO5GGiff Banks Sensitive Bully: Second Chance Theater - https://youtu.b ... Show More
37m 5s
May 2020
What’s Good: Fans and a Few Surprises, Part 3
Host Marc Evan Jackson is back for Part 3 to shoot the shirt with superfans of The Good Place from all over the world as they talk about the goodness they see around them in a special fan edition of “What’s Good.” We also get some surprise pop-ins from William Jackson Harper, D’A ... Show More
1h 32m
Feb 2016
SOUND COLLAGE! AVALANCHE BOB! PAPA JOHN! MOST OFFENSIVE SONG: PART 2!
A classic Best Show! Phones ring on part 2 of MOST OFFENSIVE SONG! A brand new SOUND COLLAGE! Hear the latest from AVALANCHE BOB! Plus, Tom compares his take on the Superbowl and Mike Francesca! WATCH THE BEST SHOW LIVE EVERY TUESDAY NIGHT 6PM PT ON TWITCH https://www.twitch.tv/b ... Show More
3h 2m
Jan 2025
Listener Q&A Episode 3
This week…another listener episode! The Lonely Island and Seth answer more voicemail questions from listeners! (Not all the clips we mention are available online; some never even aired.) If you want to see more photos and clips follow us on Instagram @lonelymeyerspod. Send us an ... Show More
42m 17s