logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2025
51m 19s

Nightmare Fuel #24: I'm Not Supposed To ...

Dan Cummins, Lynze Cummins
About this episode

n this twenty-fourth installment of fictional horror written and narrated by Dan Cummins.... we explore the tale of a man who has recently gotten into a car accident with his wife and two daughters. And now he  can't accept that they seem to have all survived. Is he merely losing his mind as he starts to question whether or not his wife and daughters are truly still alive?  Or is something else, something supernatural, at play here?  

This episode was scored by Logan Keith. We recommend listening with headphones to experience the full effect of all the creepy background noises! If you like this episode, please let us know wherever you rate and review podcasts. Thanks so much!

For Merch and everything else Bad Magic related, head to: https://www.badmagicproductions.com

Up next
Oct 8
Bringing Evil Home
Dan's first tale this week is wild. What if you brought some type of demonic presence home from a vacation and it ended up possessing your neighbor, and then your demonically possessed neighbor than attacked you? We head to Ireland for that one. And then, we’ll take a quick trip ... Show More
1h 16m
Oct 3
Nightmare Fuel #41: The Judge
In this forty-first installment of fictional horror written and narrated by Dan Cummins, we meet Lachlan Harrison. Maybe not the best guy. But does he deserve what happens to him in the forest when he goes for what's supposed to be a light, refreshing hike? And will he atone? For ... Show More
1h 13m
Oct 1
The Eye Dwellers
Dan takes us to China, back to the 17th century for a truly weird and deliciously creepy tale. Then, England, where we explore another story involving a supposedly haunted doll, a doll with no name. Lynze brings us to the UK for a haunted house tale that has the most peculiar rhy ... Show More
1h 6m
Recommended Episodes
Apr 2025
14x16: The Sinister Apartment (feat. Kaydra Brannan)
Stories in this episode: Total Creep | Stachixy (0:41) Why You Shouldn't Run Late at Night | Axse996 (8:12) "Did I Ever Tell You You Look Like Jesus, Man?" | Silver721 (15:13) Me and Two Men on a Bridge Alone | Alternative-Fill5516 (19:31) This Happened a Few Months Ago But I Sti ... Show More
52m 54s
Jun 2023
181: The Real Suburban Axe Murder: Candy & Betty
On a hot Friday the 13th in June of 1980, Allan Gore was worried. He couldn't get a hold of his wife, Betty. For hours, he'd called her over and over. No answer. Betty always answered. She didn’t get out by herself, especially not with their two small daughters. She hated when he ... Show More
1h 21m
Sep 2022
Episode 79 | A MACABRE MURDER IN BALI | Family Vacation Turns Deadly
This is the macbre story of a weathly mother, Sheila von Wiese, her spoiled and deeply troubled daughter, Heather Mack, and what was meant to be a peaceful mother/daughter vacation in paradise that ended in a grizly murder in Bali. Heather Mack was a problem child, and despite al ... Show More
22m 54s
Dec 2024
269: MY DAD WAS A WAR CRIMINAL | 20 True Scary Stories | EP 257
This episode includes narrations of true creepy encounters submitted by normal folks just like yourself. Today you'll experience horrifying stories about dark family secrets, home invasions & the scary reason why one redditor quit Youtube HAVE A STORY TO SUBMIT? LetsReadSubmissio ... Show More
2h 45m
Oct 2022
Episode 45: He Watches Me Sleep
Stories in this episode:  - An Emotional Ghost Story, by DOOM  - I Experienced a Car Crash this Morning that Didn't Actually  Happen, by alexsandthat   - He Watches Me Sleep, by Impossible_Chance104  - Who or What Did I Speak to in my Garden, by missprincesspig   - Seeing Shadow ... Show More
51m 45s
Oct 2024
188: Nightmare Fuel or Fiction?..
Two Hot Takes host, Morgan, is joined by guest co-host Justin! Scary, Spooky Season is back, and we have 9 chilling tales to dive into! Now not every story in this year's theme is paranormal, because we all know reality can be even scarier. But for those that are paranormal.. do ... Show More
1h 53m
Oct 7
183 | They Sliced Off Her FACE - 6 Disturbing True Stories
Hug your loved ones close and make sure their skin is still attached. This heavily true crime episode will freak you out big time. ⚠️ Best listened to with headphones in complete darkness ⚠️ 0:00 INTRO Mrs. Dubowski's Lawn from SummerJob2003 Lifeguard creep from Wendigofan927 The ... Show More
1h 10m
Feb 2025
150 | 6 Driving through the Dark Woods HORROR Stories
Become an Eeriecast PLUS Member! https://eeriecast.com/plus GET MY WIFE'S ADORABLE STICKERS!!! https://ko-fi.com/ruffledragons/shop ORDER PHANTOM PHENOMENA: https://a.co/d/3hQAV7e ORDER APPALCHIAN FOLKLORE UNVEILED: https://a.co/d/iteR5xZ Get CRYPTID: The Creepy Card Battling Gam ... Show More
1h 3m
Mar 2025
RQ Network Feed Drop – Not Quite Dead S1: I:The Girl on the Gurney
This month we are featuring a feed drop for an incredible podcast on the RQ Network: Not Quite Dead.Not Quite Dead is a UK-based Gory, Horror, Romance, podcast from the award-winning team behind Spirit Box Radio, Remnants and Clockwork Bird. Follow Alfie, a nurse working overtime ... Show More
22m 53s
Feb 2025
Freaky Friday: Episode 151
I Think My Father Helped Kidnap a Woman in the 1980s; 'Dr Death' Harold Shipman Came into My House!; The Day I Accidentally Stopped My Kidnapping?; My Brush with Moorish Sovereign Citizens; Some Hope for Wildfire Survivors from a Survivor; and (Almost) Real Death at a Fake Murder ... Show More
1h 4m