logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2025
1h 15m

Is Toby the Scranton Strangler? With Pau...

Audacy & Jenna Fischer and Angela Kinsey
About this episode

Is Toby is the Scranton Strangler?? This week the ladies discuss this very popular fan theory! In old school debate style, they each take a side and present their case. Angela vs Jenna. Angela says that Toby IS the Scranton Strangler and Jenna argues that he is NOT. With the help of many “Office Ladies” fans writing in with their theories and the ladies' own deep-divey research, this debate gets heated! Sam becomes the impromptu judge and Cassi serves as the debate expert but ultimately we needed to hear from Paul Lieberstein aka Toby Flenderson himself. He joins the ladies in the studio to answer this fan theory once and for all! Is Toby the Scranton Strangler? We want to hear your thoughts! We hope you enjoy this episode, we never knew we could have so much fun talking about Toby. 


Check out Paul Liberstein’s Audible show “Middlespace: The Rebels Attack, And Then Other Side Attacks as Well” https://www.audible.com/podcast/Middlespace-The-Rebels-Attack-And-Then-The-Other-Side-Attacks-As-Well/B09L37JVBC


Check out Office Ladies Merch at Podswag: https://www.podswag.com/collections/office-ladies 


Office Ladies Website - Submit a fan question: https://officeladies.com/submitaquestion 

Follow Us on Instagram: OfficeLadiesPod

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Today
The Paper Interviews #1 with Domhnall Gleeson
This Friday on Office Ladies 6.0, we have a special bonus episode where Jenna and Angela interview Domhnall Gleeson who is in the upcoming “Office” spinoff “The Paper”! The ladies ask Domhnall how he got his job on “The Paper” and what his experience has been like so far. They al ... Show More
19m 51s
Aug 6
A Look Back on a Conversation with Billie Eilish
This week on Office Ladies 6.0, we revisit our special episode where Jenna and Angela sit down with “Office” superfan and popstar, Billie Eilish! Billie shares her favorite episodes, seasons and what “The Office” means to her. Jenna, Angela and Billie reveal which character(s) th ... Show More
1h 13m
Aug 4
Second Drink: Traveling Salesman
This week we're breaking down Traveling Salesmen, the first episode in a two episode arch directed by Greg Daniels (Upload, Space Force). Greg sends in some amazing memories from this episode, the ladies give a little TV production crash course, and discuss those really fun chara ... Show More
1h 28m
Recommended Episodes
Aug 2024
Why Toby and Jenna’s Relationship In Pretty Little Liars Was Problematic
This week we are unpacking episode 17 and discussing our favorite and least favorite character moments. Tammin and Lindsey share how Hannah’s mom could have redeemed herself with just one line, and also reveal if they liked Chad Lowe’s character. Lindsey talks about the best scen ... Show More
56m 14s
Apr 2024
Teen Talk (Season 2 After Show)
Back for another special post-season after show, the Dad Crew sits down to talk through the season two finale, how it came together cleaner than the season one finale, the giant scissors Matt actually bought during the recording, and how the teenage motif fit into the pressure ev ... Show More
1h 32m
Feb 2025
A Brutally Honest Review Of Apple Cider Vinegar
On today's show, we're diving deep into Netflix's gripping new Australian series Apple Cider Vinegar, which tells the infamous story of wellness scammer Belle Gibson. From Kaitlyn Dever's eerily perfect Australian accent to the fascinating creative liberties taken with the real s ... Show More
37m 46s
Jun 30
Paul Confronts Leslie on To Catch a Cheater: The Ex, the Ticket, and the Truth
Paul thought his relationship with Leslie was rock solid after three years together — until he noticed her acting distant and texting her ex, Joel, more than ever. While Leslie prepared for a solo visit to her hometown, Paul couldn't shake the feeling she was planning something w ... Show More
12m 6s
Jul 2024
Kyle MacLachlan, Angela Simmons & Rufus Sewell?
TICKETS ARE OFFICIALLY ON SALE FOR OUR FALL TOUR! GET 'EM AT WHOWEEKLY.US/LIVE. Huge news! Vice President Kamala Harris visited the newest location of Tyra Banks' ice-cream-meets-entrepreneurial-school-maybe-not-sure, Smize and Dream! Wahoo! Justin Long shit the bed, Tasha K gets ... Show More
1h 8m
Apr 2025
Kathryn Hahn
Kathryn Hahn is new to being a mother. Amy hangs with her friend and the star of 'Agatha All Along' to talk about meeting each other while working on 'Parks and Rec,' being anointed as "Mother Hahn," and getting joy from her dog, Banjo. Host: Amy Poehler Guests: Patti LuPone and ... Show More
56m 9s
Sep 2024
Chuck Bryant, Bobby Moynihan, Holly Laurent
Podcaster extraordinaire Chuck Bryant of the Stuff You Should Know podcast joins Scott to talk about going into the 17th year of Stuff You Should Know, ants, and the Seven Wonders of the World. Then, masked vigilante The Batmin returns to talk about criminals he has recently put ... Show More
1h 6m
Apr 2025
Paul F. Tompkins is Happier Than Ever
Welcome back! Today’s guest is the legendary Paul F. Tompkins! Paul and Caleb talk about the current state of world affairs, history, finding ways to stay positive, possums, and much more! We are on TOUR! Come see So True LIVE in a city near you! Dates/Tickets can be found here: ... Show More
1h 11m
Feb 2022
There Are No Roommates | Episode 2
Ivan meets more of his fellow patients during a group therapy session, where backstories are revealed and things come to a head. A figure from Ivan’s past makes an appearance. Warning: This episode contains adult content, adult language, and violence. ~~ From QCODE, makers of fan ... Show More
41m 8s
Jul 15
Julianne & Kevin - Mixing Work and Pleasure?
In today’s shocking episode, Julianne suspects her boyfriend Kevin might be hiding something after two years of what seemed like the perfect relationship. As the clues add up, the team sets a trap to uncover the truth. Is he being unfaithful, or is there more to the story? Think ... Show More
12m 12s