Unravel the chilling mystery of Dee Dee and Gypsy Blanchard in our latest episode! A shocking Facebook post leads to a missing persons case with unexpected twists.
Sponsors:
Green Chef - greenchef.com/60casual and use code 60casual to get 60% off, plus 20% off your next two months
Shopify - shopify.com/casual for a $1 per month trial period
Learn more abo ... Show More
Jun 8
Rex Heuermann: The Gilgo Beach Killer
The chilling story of Rex Heuermann: how the alleged Gilgo Beach Killer evaded capture for years, leaving a trail of victims, corruption, secrets, and unanswered questions across Long Island's shoreline. Sponsor: shopify.com/casual - sign up for your $1 per month trial Learn mor ... Show More
2h 13m
Aug 2025
INFAMOUS: Karen Read & John O'Keefe Pt. 1
Massachusetts police officer John O’Keefe was found dead in a snowy yard after a party, and all eyes turned to his girlfriend, Karen Read. Morgan and Kaelyn dive into the controversial clues at the center of this infamous case: Karen's supposed confession, suspicious phone record ... Show More
1h 17m
Apr 2025
Episode 260 - Gone Girl? - The Disappearance of Jennifer Dulos
Join us, as we take a look at the mysterious disappearance of Jennifer Dulos - a wealthy mother-of-five who vanished from her Connecticut mansion, leaving behind a blood-spattered garage. You’ll hear the shocking claims made by her estranged husband who claimed, that Jennifer sta ... Show More
50m 54s
Sep 2025
KIDNAPPED: Sherri Papini
When Sherri Papini vanished during a jog in 2016, the search gripped the nation. Morgan and Kaelyn revisit the twists in this bizarre kidnapping case: a frantic husband’s 911 call, a nationwide hunt, Sherri’s shocking roadside reappearance, and the clues—DNA, text messages, and a ... Show More
1h 25m
Oct 2025
289. The Deadly Friend - The Murder of Steven B Williams
On this episode, Payton and Garrett dive into the chilling case of a beloved radio host whose friendship with a charming investor aboard a luxury yacht takes a deadly turn, ending in betrayal, greed, and murder on the open sea. Links: Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/murderwithmy ... Show More
41m 3s
Feb 2025
256. Lulu's Hitman - The Shocking Case of Ramon Sosa
In this episode, Garrett and Payton dive into the case of Ramon Sosa, a man who thought he had a happy marriage—until he discovered his wife "Lulu” was plotting to have him killed. What followed was a shocking twist involving betrayal, survival, and an unexpected police operation ... Show More
35m 26s