logo
episode-header-image
Oct 2023
49m 40s

S5 Ep10: Daniel Lee Siebert

Audioboom Studios
About this episode
On February 24th, 1986, police in Talladega, Alabama forced their way inside the home of 24-year-old mother and student Sherri Weathers. When she had not shown up for classes in over a week, police were sent to do a wellness check. And soon the reason for her absence became very clear. 

Sherri and her two young children had been strangled to death, and their killer had piled them on top of each other in the shape of a cross. The killer was a 31-year-old artist and seasoned criminal, and his macabre masterpiece was far from complete. Two more bodies were discovered, and the killer had slipped away without a trace. With no clue as to where he went, police began the long and grueling search to find him, before he struck again.

This episode is sponsored by:
Badlands - listen on all major podcast apps!
Wondery's This is Actually Happening - listen ad free on the Wondery Plus app
BetterHelp -What Makes A Killer is sponsored by BetterHelp. Get 10% off.

Original music by Ben Krejci, Lee Rosevere, Sergey Cheremisinov, Kevin MacLeod, and Kai Engel. Additional music provided by Epidemic Sound.

Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License.
Up next
Oct 2023
S5 Ep13: Bobby Joe Long
In this last episode of season five, we'll examine Floridian serial killer Bobby Joe Long... 1984. Tampa, Florida. A 17-year-old girl named Lisa was on her way home from work, when she was abducted from the side of the road. For the next 26 hours, she was subjected to a terrifyin ... Show More
39m 7s
Oct 2023
S5 Ep12: Christopher Hightower
September 22nd, 1991. Guilford, Connecticut. Early that evening, a mysterious man visited the home of Christine Brendel and delivered some shocking news – her brother Ernest and his family had been kidnapped, and were being held for ransom by the Mafia. It turned out the man at t ... Show More
45m 38s
Oct 2023
S5 Ep11: Vincent Tabak
Christmas day, 2010. A couple was walking their dog along a remote road in Clifton, an English port city of Bristol, when they happened upon the body of a 25-year-old Joanna Yeates. 32-year-old Dutch engineer Vincent Tabak, who was obsessed with violent pornography and rough sex, ... Show More
36m 15s
Recommended Episodes
May 2021
Larry Gene Bell // 122
<p>In the early summer of 1986, two young blonde girls went missing in the state of South Carolina without a trace. Until a series of cryptic phone calls led investigators to their bodies. A serial killer was on the loose and a letter written by one of the victims to her own fami ... Show More
45m 6s
Nov 2021
Nikki Whitehead
Ep 62: A young woman and mother brutally murdered in her own home in Georgia in January of 2010 was found by her 16-year-old twin daughters, who frantically flagged down police for help. The crime scene pointed to a killer with a lot of anger towards this woman but the investigat ... Show More
46m 35s
Nov 2024
In the Weeds (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
<p>On a Monday afternoon in 1986, medical staff at a clinic in San Antonio, Texas were starting to get worried, because their most respected nurse had not shown up for work and nobody could get a hold of her. So later that morning, two of the nurse’s colleagues drove down to her ... Show More
34m 8s
Oct 2019
Episode 61 - Sherri Dally
The morning of May 6th, 1996 was routine for Sherri Dally. The thirty-five-year-old wife and mother woke up early and got her family prepared for their day, laying out her children’s clothing and organizing lunches. After she dropped her two young boys off at school, Sherri drove ... Show More
54m 38s
Mar 2020
Erin Caffey
Ep 10: In the early morning hours of March 1, 2008, 2 young men burst into the Caffey home in the middle of the night and embarked on a killing spree that would leave two young children and their mother dead. Their father, Terry suffered multiple gunshot wounds but somehow manage ... Show More
40m 45s