In May of 2001, Jennifer Stahl and four friends were in her apartment in New York City when another man was buzzed in. They didn’t know that he had another man with him, and the two were planning on robbing everyone there along with money that Jennifer was supposed to have. Each man would later claim that the other was responsible, but at the end, all 5 of ... Show More
Mar 17
Jamie Faith: Manipulation, a "Blind" Obsession, and the 10-Hour Drive
Jamie Faith was a "bachelor for life" until he met Jennifer. But after 15 years of marriage, a masked gunman ended his life in broad daylight. Join us as we explore the tragic murder of Jamie Faith, the exploitation of a veteran’s PTSD, and the shocking GoFundMe fraud that took p ... Show More
1 h
Mar 10
The Murder of Amy Schulz: Forensics, Footprints, and Cecil Sutherland
Want Exclusive Bonus Episodes, Early Access and Ad-Free content? Join our Patreon The murder of Amy Schulz remains one of the most haunting true crime cases in Illinois history. In 1987, the 10-year-old vanished during a five-minute walk in the quiet town of Kell, leading to ... Show More
47m 12s
Mar 3
The Au Pair Affair Part 2: Brendan Banfield Takes the Stand | The Verdict & Sentencing
"It’s easier to fall in love with someone that saved you." Those were the words of Brendan Banfield as he attempted to explain away an affair, a dead wife, and a dead stranger to a jury of twelve. In Part 2 of our deep dive into the VA v. Brendan Banfield trial, we move past the ... Show More
1h 8m
Aug 2025
448: The Murder of Hadas Winnick (from "I'm Related to a Killer")
On September 25, 2007, 22-year-old Amy Winnick left her job near Calabasas, California, and headed home. Her cell phone rang. It was was her 25-year-old brother Jesse. "Don't go home," he told her. And then he said "I just killed Mom," and then he hung up. This unimaginable night ... Show More
48m 32s
Jul 2023
EP. 118 TEXAS - She Killed Her Best Friend & Stole Her Baby
At the end of 2019, a puzzling crime rocked the community of Austin, Texas. A mother, Heidi Broussard, had gone missing, along with her daughter... and nobody had a clue where she had went. But when the facts of the case began to emerge, an extremely dark picture was painted... a ... Show More
1h 10m
Mar 2023
10x05: The Untouchables (Extended)
This episode includes 30 minutes of bonus content thanks to all of our amazing patrons! Stories in this episode: - He Tried to Come in to Clean Our Carpets, by ningensfriend (1:30) - The Untouchables, by JJ (10:37) - Almost Attacked While Driving to the Hospital, by Carly (22:14) ... Show More
1h 22m
Jun 2022
#384: The Staircase Revisited - Part 1
<p>On December 9, 2001, Kathleen Peterson died a terrible death, suffering for over 2 hours, bleeding from scalp lacerations and blunt force trauma while she lay in the stairwell of her North Carolina home. Her husband Michael Peterson was convicted of her murder after a contenti ... Show More
46m 39s
May 2023
10x12: I Dated A Murderer - Let's Not Meet
Stories in this episode: - He Held a Shotgun to My Head, by Anonymous (1:19) - Banned from the E-Bar, by Sarah (9:09) - Someone Else Was Out There, by Kassidy (16:05) - The Small-Time Drug Dealer Who Infiltrated My Friend Group, by Ashley (23:16) - Hungry Taxi Driver, by Alee (33 ... Show More
49m 28s