logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2024
1h 23m

The Best and Worst Cars of 2024 — The Ca...

Hagerty Media
About this episode

Jason and Derek review their top 10 best (and worst) experiences behind the wheel in 2024. Everything from ulta-rare Porsches, to open-air Lamborghinis, manual-swapped Mercedes (and Ferraris), supercars, hypercars, rally icons, and more!


===

The Carmudgeon Show Sponsor, Vredestein Tires:

https://www.vredestein.com/


Click here to join the Hagerty Driver's Club: https://bit.ly/Join-HDC-Cammisa-Rev

===


Christmas comes early for us this year (but not quite in time for this episode) in the form of 6 brand new sets of dutch rubber courtesy of our sponsor, Vredestein Tires! 


The Curmudgeon's then continue with a discussion about each Carmudgeon’s Grandmother’s vehicular preferences, which included the likes of the Ford Pinto, AMC Pacer, ‘87 Chevy Cavalier, Saturn SL1, ‘99 Nissan Sentra, Dodge Aries K-car, Dodge Duster 340, and Buick Wildcat. 


Then we briefly revel in some sweet, sweet vindication after Car and Driver named the Tesla Model 3 to their 10 Best list, but rejected the G20 BMW 3-Series (as it had the F30 before it) and specifically the G80 M3. The Cadillac CT4 and CT5 Blackwing both made this list, alongside a handful of perennial stalwarts like the Honda Civic, Honda Accord, and GR86/BRZ twins.


Afterwards, we recount hanging with Jay Leno while filming 3 separate episodes of Jay Leno’s Garage featuring Jason’s Mk2 VW Scirocco 16V, E30 BMW 325i Touring, and E31 850 CSi. 


And finally, it’s time to talk best drives of the year! The boys loved three Ferraris: the 296 GTB, 360 Challenge Stradale (manual-swapped), and F50. Plus one car from Enzo’s nemesis: the Lamborghini Diablo VT Roadster. 


Then, Jason and Derek include wwo Porsches: the 992.1-chassis 911 S/T and 964 Carrera RS 3.8. Both the Bugatti EB110 GT and Veyron made the list, as did another Piëch-era favorite: the VW XL1. 


Speaking of VWs, the 1964 Beetle and new ID.Buzz both made the cut as well. What would a Carmudgeon episode be without a smattering of Mercedes products? The W209 CLK63 Black Series (manual-converted), W201 190E 2.5-16, C126 560SEC, and a W124 300E with a Mosselman twin-turbo kit and Zender body! 


Two EVs even made the list: the incredible Lucid Air Sapphire and spunky Hyundai Ioniq 5 N. Plus some exquisite lightweights: the Alfa Romeo Giulietta Sprint 1300, Lotus Exige V6 Cup, and Lancia Stratos.


The worst drives of the year? That honor goes to the disappointing Pagani Zonda and 4-cylinder W206 Mercedes-AMG C63.


We end wondering how to rack up miles behind the wheel of our favorite vintage cars safely. One thing we can all agree we need? More time off!  


Happy Holidays!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Up next
Aug 18
Car Week Kickoff At Motorlux — The Carmudgeon Show w/ Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep. 201
Jason and Derek escape the studio this week to record from Hagerty's Motorlux event, the kickoff to Monterey Car Week 2025. We join them at this year's highlighted Bruno Sacco display, featuring designs that defined Mercedes-Benz in the 80's, 90's, and 2000's. The legacy of Sacco ... Show More
37m 51s
Aug 11
Go Rallying With Your Friends — The Carmudgeon Show w/ Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep. 200
In celebration of 200 episodes of The Carmudgeon Show, Jason Cammisa and Derek Tam Hyphen Scott debrief their recent weekend-long Pacific Coast Rally with friends. === The Carmudgeon Show Sponsor, Vredestein Tires: https://www.vredestein.com/ === Indecisive between his BMW 850CSi ... Show More
55m 46s
Aug 4
Ask Us Anything: Part 4 — The Carmudgeon Show with Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep. 199
We've finally run out of questions to answer! As we come to an end of our AMA series, Jason and Derek continue to tackle the remaining questions from the last Q&A Some topics you asked about (and some you didn't), including but not limited to: - Opel Manta(?) - Nissan Altima Driv ... Show More
51m 20s
Recommended Episodes
Jun 11
Porsche’s 963 Road Car Is a One-Off
Join Spike, Jonny, and Zuckerman for a heated debate over the new Porsche 963 RSP Le Mans street-legal hypercar. Does a suspicious cupholder hint that it's actually headed for full production? Plus, they dive into the Porsche Carrera GTS T-Hybrid models and roast the complete flo ... Show More
1 h
Apr 2025
McMurtry Spéirling SMOKES the Porsche GT3 RS
Matt Farah from "The Smoking Tire" joins Spike and Zuckerman as they dive into luxury cars, electric speedsters, and car show highlights. From baldness comparisons to a Bentley Flying Spur review and the shocking McMurtry Spéirling that beat a Porsche 911 GT3 RS, this episode bri ... Show More
1h 12m
Jul 23
We Drove the Best Ferrari Ever Made
Spike and Jonny cover exotic car extremes from the $4M Ferrari F80 to the seductive Aston Martin Vanquish. They also debate what to do with producer Cameron's rusted VW Golf "sh*tbox" and discuss a perfectly preserved Chevy Vega unearthed from a 1975 time capsule! _______________ ... Show More
54m 55s
Mar 2025
We Bought the Untouched E39 BMW M5
Zuckerman just scored a unicorn—a Dakar Yellow E39 BMW M5 with only 633 ORIGINAL MILES! Spike, Zuckerman, and guest Drew Leslie from EAG break down the absurd negotiation process, the restoration challenges, and whether this car is too perfect to drive. Plus, Spike dishes on his ... Show More
1h 9m
May 30
Porsche Kills the 718! China Crushes Tesla! Doug on BMW’s Ugly Redemption Arc!
Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Thank You To Our Sponsors! DeleteMe - https://joindeleteme.com/DEMURO Get 20% off your plan! Download Cash App Today: https://capl.onelink.me/vFut/kk6qvwgr#CashAppPod ... Show More
1h 34m
Nov 2024
945: A Car You’re Crying Out For, The Backup Track Car, A Tool For The Hour
Porsche announces the new 911 Carrera T! The guys discuss, along with Xiaomi’s unofficial ‘Ring lap record for 4-doors using a modified SU7. They debate fun dad cars for Wilson in San Diego, who needs two car seats as his family is growing. Then, David C. asks if there’s a PPI th ... Show More
51m 17s
Jun 13
Maserati Is Doomed. Trump Selling His Tesla on Cars & Bids? $45K for an E46 M3?
Have a question you want answered on the podcast next week? Ask HERE ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://crsnbds.com/PODQUESTIONS ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Thank You To Our Sponsors! Upgrade your wardrobe and save on @trueclassic at https://trueclassic.com/CARS #trueclassicpod Acre Gold - https://www.getacregold.com 30 ... Show More
1h 26m
Apr 2025
Seen Through Glass's Nightmare Ferrari Restoration
This week, Spike, Zuckerman, and guest Sam Fane from ‪https://youtube.com/@seenthroughglass‬ unpack why Sam’s ditching his Porsche Boxster, the chaos of restoring a Ferrari 360 Challenge Stradale he accidentally bought, and Matt Farah's 8-hour The Smoking Tire 1000th episode. Als ... Show More
1h 6m
Mar 2025
Jerry Seinfeld's $25 Million Porsche 917
Jerry Seinfeld joins Spike and Zuckerman for another unfiltered deep dive into cars, comedy, and collecting. They break down the sale of Jerry’s Porsche 917K, debate the 964 RS vs. 993 RS, and reminisce about his SNL spoof. Plus, Pete Stout from *000 Magazine* stops by to talk ab ... Show More
1h 11m
Jan 2025
961: It’s No Batmobile, Real Tall Person Space, Trash Can With Missiles
The guys talk about car sales numbers and new tech releases. They debate two cars for Matthew in NY, who is retiring from the NYPD and using his pension check. Then, Steven is a dad with fun car needs for his growing brood. Social media questions ask for best winter driving activ ... Show More
58m 8s