logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2024
54m 45s

Denied Pen and Paper, the Calamity of Th...

Why Quran?
About this episode

In these last few days, many of the companions explicitly disregarded the prophet's instructions in order to secure political power after his demise. The prophet had attempted to prevent their schemes by instructing many of the senior companions to leave Medina with Usama ibn Zayd, so that Imam Ali could assume leadership without interference, but many delayed and made excuses.

Some hypocrites were known, but others were skilled at hiding their hypocrisy as proven by the failed assassination attempt.

In the even known as "The Calamity of Thursday", while Prophet Muhammad lay on his death bed he decided to take an extra step to explicitly document the his successor and asked for something to write to leave a message "after which you'll never go astray."

However, a group of companions who were around him at the time, including Umar, realized that the prophet was planning to document his succession plan and started to strongly object and shout, prompting Prophet Muhammad to order them to leave.

The lecture analyzes the various Sunni sources which indicate that the opposition group, which Umar was part of, started saying prophet was "going insane."

The fact that these people were willing to sling mud on the prophet's sanity showed to the prophet the futility of writing down his will later. If he were to do so, those people would cast the same aspersions on the prophet's will, casting doubts on his sanity during every instance where he designated Imam Ali as his successor. This could be potentially stretched back all the way to revelation, and the spread of such slander would put people's belief in Islam itself at risk.

Lecture notes available at http://www.why-quran.org/?p=796.

Subscribe at http://www.why-quran.org/subscribe to watch the lectures live and participate in the Q&A at the end of each class.

Video recording of this lecture + Q&A available on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yBxvKOHjZcM&list=PLpkB0iwLgfTat-Pgh4W3WFmupPamiC9UT.

Up next
Dec 2024
Death of the Prophet
This lecture covers various events that occurred on the day of the prophet's passing and the day after, up until his burial. This lecture includes: - The Prophet consoling Fatima by telling her she would be the first of his family to join him in paradise. - Ali ibn Abi Talib ... Show More
44m 28s
Dec 2024
Was Prophet Muhammad Poisoned?
Everyone knows the prophet died of illness, and many say it was due to poison. Some say it was poison he consumed during te Battle of Khaybar three years earlier, but there are some serious doubts about that theory. Another theory suggests Aisha may have poisoned him. This lectur ... Show More
54m 4s
Dec 2024
Prophet Offering Retribution
In his last days, knowing death was imminent, Prophet Muhammad called his uncle Abbas and Imam Ali. He asked his uncle to carry out his will and settle his affairs after the prophet's death. When the uncle demured, the prophet asked Imam Ali, who accepted. The Prophet also g ... Show More
43m 53s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2025
10/6: Proofs From Sunni Hadith that Prophet Never Banned Mut'ah | The Real Shia Beliefs
Things you'll learn in this episode of The Real Shia Beliefs:- Why it's important to study Sunni texts on Mut'ah- Mut'ah of Hajj (Hajj al-Tamattu') & its relationship with Mut'ah marriage - Argument between Imam Ali and Uthman over Hajj al-Tamattu'- P ... Show More
31m 20s
Aug 20
Qutham ibn Abbas (ra): The Prophet’s ﷺ Lookalike
While Abdullah ibn Abbas (ra) became known for his knowledge and eloquence, his younger brother Qutham (ra) was known for something else: his striking resemblance to the Prophet ﷺ.In this episode, discover how Qutham, who was raised alongside al-Husayn (ra), the last to leave the ... Show More
19m 14s
Sep 2024
103: The Pope, TimeTravel, Sana Manuscripts & The Modern Quran w. Sh Uthman Ibn Farooq
Sheikh Uthman Ibn Farouq (one message foundation) come back on the Ansari podcast! For another insightful conversation about all things Quran, bible, politics & Islamic history! Sheikh Uthman ends all debate about Quranic preservation and dives into the history of it's Divine ... Show More
1h 41m
Oct 2024
03 The Final Negotiation | Prophet’s ﷺ Road to Hajj | Nouman Ali Khan
Download our free guided workbook on the Prophet’s ﷺ Road to Hajj as a companion to this Dhul Hijjah video series at: https://bayyinah.com/dhulhijjah The strategic blunders of the Quraysh after the Battle of Uhud were significant. Failing to annihilate the Muslims, they realized ... Show More
27m 56s
May 2020
24-Reflection & the End of Life – Renewal by the Book: Quran Tafsir Based on Imam Ghazali’s Ihya – Shaykh Faraz Rabbani
In this lesson of Renewal by the Book, Shaykh Faraz Rabbani, reflects upon verses of the Quran that correspond to the chapter on reflection and the end of life from Imam Ghazali’s Ihya. إِنَّمَا مَثَلُ الْحَيَاةِ الدُّنْيَا كَمَاءٍ أَنزَلْنَاهُ مِنَ السَّمَاءِ فَاخْتَلَطَ بِهِ نَ ... Show More
35m 43s
Oct 2
Abdullah ibn Amr (ra): The One Who Preserved The Sunnah
He embraced Islam later in the Prophet ﷺ’s life, but strove to catch up in seeking and serving knowledge, sometimes almost going to extremes in that pursuit. Abdullah ibn Amr ibn al-As (ra) became among the first to gain permission to record the Prophet ﷺ’s teachings in writing. ... Show More
1h 26m
May 2025
Nukhbat Al-Fikr - Part 2 | Fabrications & Hidden Gaps Exposed | Ustadh Muhammad Tim Humble #AMAU [Audio - 2/2]
A chain of narration might look complete—until you realise one connection was only assumed, not proven. In the second session of the explanation of the book Nukhbat al-Fikr, Ustadh Muhammad Tim Humble continues uncovering the inner mechanics of hadith authentication. This session ... Show More
3 h
Jul 2022
Clearing Up The Misconceptions Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi Interviewed By Imam Ibrahim Bakeer #125
Created by Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi Interviewed By Imam Ibrahim Bakeer #125 --------------------------------------------------- A.L.M. This is the Book; in it is guidance sure, without doubt, to those who fear Allah; Who believe in the Unseen, are steadfast in prayer, and spend out ... Show More
1h 18m
May 2025
Surah An-Nisaa: The Women - Verse 23 - Prophet Muhammad's Secret
In today's Podcast, we address a story the critics of Islam have long celebrated and, sadly, is repeated by Muslims who are ignorant about their faith. Both claim that our beloved Muhammad was chasing his desires—God forbid. Today, we defend our beloved Muhammad and explain the ... Show More
12m 37s
Jan 2024
Imam Ali and the Caliphs
Join Sayed Jawad Qazwini as he delves into the intricate relationship between Imam Ali and the first three caliphs – Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman. Uncover historical perspectives and explore differing opinions on whether the bond was based on friendship or animosity. Sayed Jawad Qa ... Show More
44m 52s