logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2024
54m 45s

Denied Pen and Paper, the Calamity of Th...

Why Quran?
About this episode

In these last few days, many of the companions explicitly disregarded the prophet's instructions in order to secure political power after his demise. The prophet had attempted to prevent their schemes by instructing many of the senior companions to leave Medina with Usama ibn Zayd, so that Imam Ali could assume leadership without interference, but many delayed and made excuses.

Some hypocrites were known, but others were skilled at hiding their hypocrisy as proven by the failed assassination attempt.

In the even known as "The Calamity of Thursday", while Prophet Muhammad lay on his death bed he decided to take an extra step to explicitly document the his successor and asked for something to write to leave a message "after which you'll never go astray."

However, a group of companions who were around him at the time, including Umar, realized that the prophet was planning to document his succession plan and started to strongly object and shout, prompting Prophet Muhammad to order them to leave.

The lecture analyzes the various Sunni sources which indicate that the opposition group, which Umar was part of, started saying prophet was "going insane."

The fact that these people were willing to sling mud on the prophet's sanity showed to the prophet the futility of writing down his will later. If he were to do so, those people would cast the same aspersions on the prophet's will, casting doubts on his sanity during every instance where he designated Imam Ali as his successor. This could be potentially stretched back all the way to revelation, and the spread of such slander would put people's belief in Islam itself at risk.

Lecture notes available at http://www.why-quran.org/?p=796.

Subscribe at http://www.why-quran.org/subscribe to watch the lectures live and participate in the Q&A at the end of each class.

Video recording of this lecture + Q&A available on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yBxvKOHjZcM&list=PLpkB0iwLgfTat-Pgh4W3WFmupPamiC9UT.

Up next
Dec 2024
Death of the Prophet
This lecture covers various events that occurred on the day of the prophet's passing and the day after, up until his burial. This lecture includes: - The Prophet consoling Fatima by telling her she would be the first of his family to join him in paradise. - Ali ibn Abi Talib ... Show More
44m 28s
Dec 2024
Was Prophet Muhammad Poisoned?
Everyone knows the prophet died of illness, and many say it was due to poison. Some say it was poison he consumed during te Battle of Khaybar three years earlier, but there are some serious doubts about that theory. Another theory suggests Aisha may have poisoned him. This lectur ... Show More
54m 4s
Dec 2024
Prophet Offering Retribution
In his last days, knowing death was imminent, Prophet Muhammad called his uncle Abbas and Imam Ali. He asked his uncle to carry out his will and settle his affairs after the prophet's death. When the uncle demured, the prophet asked Imam Ali, who accepted. The Prophet also g ... Show More
43m 53s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2025
10/6: Proofs From Sunni Hadith that Prophet Never Banned Mut'ah | The Real Shia Beliefs
Things you'll learn in this episode of The Real Shia Beliefs:- Why it's important to study Sunni texts on Mut'ah- Mut'ah of Hajj (Hajj al-Tamattu') & its relationship with Mut'ah marriage - Argument between Imam Ali and Uthman over Hajj al-Tamattu'- P ... Show More
31m 20s
Oct 2024
04 Faith and Marriage in Islam | Prophet’s ﷺ Road to Hajj | Nouman Ali Khan
Download our free guided workbook on the Prophet’s ﷺ Road to Hajj as a companion to this Dhul Hijjah video series at: https://bayyinah.com/dhulhijjah This narrative explores a series of crucial diplomatic and strategic efforts during a tense period in early Islamic history. Multi ... Show More
1h 3m
Sep 2016
041 – Honouring the Bearer of Qur’an | Sign of Pre-Eminence at Burial | Pace and Understanding
In this episode, Shaykh Faraz Rabbani covers hadiths thirteen to fifteen from Imam Nabahani’s set of hadiths on the virtues of the Qur’an and its recitation. In hadith thirteen, we learn that there are three categories of people whom honouring is considered from affirming Allah M ... Show More
21m 34s
Aug 2017
116 – Loving Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and Faith | What Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was Granted | Experiential Spirituality
In this episode, Shaykh Faraz Rabbani covers the hadiths fourteen to seventeen of the ninth set of hadiths of Imam Nabahani on the virtues of the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him). In the fourteenth hadith we learn that a person’s qualities are not truly complete ... Show More
37 m
Dec 2020
202- The Rawha- Was the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace)Ever Misguided? – Shaykh Faraz Rabbani
Shaykh Faraz Rabbani answers the question: Was the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) ever misguided?  Shaykh Faraz Rabbani explains the state of the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) before being sent with Islam as conveyed in Sura al -Duha. He clears the co ... Show More
11m 51s
Jan 2025
Abu Mahdhura (ra): The Kid Who Mocked Adhan
As the Prophet ﷺ left the siege of Ta’if, a group of youth were making fun of the adhan. The Prophet ﷺ saw past their mockery and stuck to his hope of their becoming Muslim. In one of the most beautiful stories of the Prophetic lens, we gain new insight into how he brought the be ... Show More
16m 34s
May 2019
Ramadhan Gems 2019 - Night 10 - Prophet Muhammed Part 4
Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan gives an interesting analysis in today’s session on the Prophet SAW and how his relationship is with us and the kind of love and care he has for his Ummah. Surah Ale Imran demonstrates the happenings of the Battle of Uhud. the main point of interest is cent ... Show More
28m 20s
May 25
NEW BOOK: I’tiqad A’immah Al-Hadith | Abu Bakr Ahmad Al-Isma'ili | Shaikh Dr. Asim Al-Qaryooti #AMAU [Audio - 2/2]
You try to follow the Qur’an and Sunnah—then you're told you're rigid. You quote the Salaf—then you're labelled a Wahhabi. And why do others accuse you of being extreme—for simply following what the Salaf believed? This lecture tackles these tensions head-on—through the words of ... Show More
4h 36m
Aug 2024
The Secrets of Prophet Muhammad's Life (Ft. Sayed Ali Imran)
Have we truly understood the life of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh)? In this episode, we explore the Seerah of Rasul Allah (saww) and how it differs from his Sunnah, the Quran, and the world of Hadith. Our esteemed guest, Sayed Ali Imran, joins us from Canada to discuss how the Seerah w ... Show More
58m 5s
Jan 2021
208-The Rawha- al-Barzanji: Background and Introduction – Shaykh Faraz Rabbani
Shaykh Faraz begins with insights on the opportunities found in Rabi’ al-Awwal of renewing faith and rejoicing. The Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) spoke about his birth, and scholars wrote works celebrating it. Perhaps the most famous of these mawlids was that of Im ... Show More
22m 9s