logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2024
1h 11m

#546 - Stairway To Heaven - Newfane, Ver...

James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
About this episode

This week, in Newfane, Vermont, a simple house party turns into a complete mess, and turns violent, when one particular guest can't stop attempting to start fights, hitting on women, or trying to steal the host's car. All seems well, once he finally leaves, but party's host is later found, brutally murdered, with a ski pole stuck in his neck, while the troublemaker is found, wearing the victim's clothes. But that doesn't mean it's open & shut!!


Along the way, we find out that dogs apparently don't mix well with crafts, that you shouldn't challenge random people to fights, and that a ski pole makes a very deadly weapon!!


New episodes every Thursday!


Donate at: patreon.com/crimeinsports or go to paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder & Crime In Sports!


Follow us on...


twitter.com/@murdersmall

facebook.com/smalltownpod

instagram.com/smalltownmurder


Also, check out James & Jimmie's other show, Crime In Sports! On Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, Wondery, Wondery+, Stitcher, or wherever you listen to podcasts!

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Up next
Yesterday
Facebook Catfish Murders - Mountain City, Tennessee
This week, in Mountain City, Tennessee, a wild story unfolds when local people begin talking bad about each other on social media. This escalates to the point that death threats are flying around between a young lady's family, and her former group of friends. In the end, two peop ... Show More
2h 58m
Jul 4
Murder Soup - Cadiz, Kentucky
This week, in Cadiz, Kentucky, an amazingly bloody quadruple murder scene seems like a miracle, when one survivor is left to tell the tale. He tells of a man, bursting into the home, and duct taping the inhabitants, then murdering three members of his family, until he finally wre ... Show More
1h 10m
Jul 3
Murder Is Life - Lancaster, Texas
This week, in Lancaster, Texas, a brutal triple murder leaves detectives scrambling, but they don't know that the murderer, a dangerous man with a background of violence, had already been caught... and let go. When he is finally recaptured, he decides to confess, calling himself ... Show More
2h 47m
Recommended Episodes
Sep 2024
Moonless Night: 1
On a moonless night, a terrifying tale unfolded involving an alleged kidnapping and a murder, all within a timeline that didn't quite add up. 19-year-old Kim Hallock found herself at the center of a traumatic event – one that would forever change the trajectory of her life, that ... Show More
38m 9s
Apr 17
Who Killed Emily Pike? No More Stolen Sisters
On February 14th, 2025, 14-year-old Emily Pike’s dismembered body was found in garbage bags in a remote part of an Arizonan forest. This discovery came about three weeks after she had gone missing. Not only was this a horrible crime committed against a child, but Emily was also a ... Show More
1 h
Oct 2024
Left High and Dry: 1
Calling 911 didn't get Ruthie Mae McCoy help. The night she was shot, police didn't even break down her apartment door to check on her. Her body was discovered days later. The bizarre detail that McCoy was killed by someone entering through her bathroom medicine cabinet caught th ... Show More
39m 2s
Jul 2023
EP. 118 TEXAS - She Killed Her Best Friend & Stole Her Baby
At the end of 2019, a puzzling crime rocked the community of Austin, Texas. A mother, Heidi Broussard, had gone missing, along with her daughter... and nobody had a clue where she had went. But when the facts of the case began to emerge, an extremely dark picture was painted... a ... Show More
1h 12m
Oct 2024
Main Line Murders /// Part 1 /// 791
Main Line Murders /// Part 1 /// 791 Part 1 of 2 www.TrueCrimeGarage.comThe Main Line Murders is the largest and longest running murder investigation ever conducted by the Pennsylvania State Police.  On June 25th, 1979 the naked corpse of schoolteacher Susan Reinsert was found we ... Show More
59m 56s
Jun 12
The Murder of Kenneth "Kenny" Jerome (Vermont)
Kenneth Jerome got up that summer morning in 2005 and said goodbye to his girlfriend and children, just like he did every day. He set about his usual chores on the farm, just like he always did, and he expected to feed the cows, like he had for years. But July 7th was not like ev ... Show More
38m 2s
Nov 2024
Nancy | 9
A young woman in France has been trying to leave her abusive boyfriend for years. But when she finally does, the harassment doesn’t stop and her requests for help from the police lead nowhere. Carl, with the help of an on the ground reporter, reveals how the Kill List exists at t ... Show More
43m 21s
Mar 2025
14x10: A Robbery and a Murder
Stories in this episode: It Wasn't An Owl | twigvicious (0:41) Almost Kidnapped at an Adult Store | Triple F Chronicles (14:11) My Friend, The Psychopath | Exxtol (23:48) They Waited For Me | kingsdeadfs (30:24) My Dog Knew That My Neighbor Was Watching Me | GoddessofDooom (36:23 ... Show More
53m 59s
Oct 2024
Bonus Episode: Podcaster's RoundTable - October
Last week was the latest in our occasional True Crime Podcaster's Roundtable chats. I spent ah hour with Naomi (REAL True Crime), Dawn (Scottish Murders) and Paul (True Crime Enthusiast) talking all things true crime and true crime podcasting for just over an hour. We recorded th ... Show More
1h 6m
Apr 2024
828: Minor Crimes Division
People taking it upon themselves to solve the tiny, overlooked crimes of the world. Prologue: Host Ira Glass bikes around Manhattan with Gersh Kuntzman, in search of illegal license plates. (11 minutes)Act One: Writer Michael Harriot reexamines the DIY criminal justice system his ... Show More
59m 37s