Legend says that a witch was murdered at Hex Hollow, and on Halloween Night it turns into a portal to hell. But locals know there's a lot of truth behind that legend.
This is an episode I did with the Spotify podcast Serial Killers for their October True Urban Legends Series! ***Because it is a Spotify podcast and not Heart Starts Pounding, I'm unable to o ... Show More
Apr 23
173. The College Students That Cracked A 34 Year Old Cold Case
In September 1991, a young mother in Arlington, Texas, Cynthia Gonzalez, left for a late-night appointment and never came home. Her car was found 40 miles away, and the investigation that followed would consume a legendary detective's entire career through serial killer suspects, ... Show More
37m 26s
Apr 16
172. Dark Mysteries of the Florida Everglades: The Flat Tire Murders, Missing Planes, and The Skunk Ape
In the summer of 1975, the bodies of young women began surfacing in canals along the edge of the Florida Everglades. To make matters worse, investigators blamed the victims for their own deaths. Today, we will cover many things the Everglades have swallowed. From serial killers t ... Show More
42m 10s
Jun 2022
The Haunted Farmhouse (ft. Shelby Scott) – Ep. 29
Stories in this episode:- Having a Drink with a Dead Man, by Leti - David's Shadow, by Rachel- My Abduction Story, by emodrakefan- 200 Year Old Haunted Farmhouse, by ctenc001- The Red Light, by Tanu - My Stories, by AshleyBe sure to check out Shelby Scott's podcast at scareyoutos ... Show More
49m 58s
Aug 2025
EP. 214 - MINNESOTA: The Punk Rock Axe Murders
In today’s episode, we examine a disturbing story of family annihilation, punk rock and axe murder. This is the story of David Brom and his murderous rampage, and you’re listening to “MURDER IN AMERICA”! - Listen to our new show, "THE CONSPIRACY FILES"!: -Spotify - https://open.s ... Show More
1h 35m
Aug 2023
11x10: Murder Down The Street
- The Murder Down the Street, by Anonymous (1:10) - The Red Van, by Claire (7:55) - The Lady on the Bus, by Lilly Mya (15:58) - The Axe-Weilding Alcoholic, by Kelsey (22:21) - The Break-In, by Carol (29:43) - Post Night-Shift Nonsense, by Becca (35:23) - To My Sister, by Anonymou ... Show More
50m 18s
Sep 2025
Fan Favorite | The Carancas Curse
Following the epic crossover between MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries and Redacted: Declassified Mysteries, hosted by Luke Lamana, we’re revisiting some of our favorite episodes where the line between medical mystery and dark conspiracy becomes blurred.In September 2007, a meteor str ... Show More
30m 36s
May 2022
8x13: Sleepwalking Horror - Let's Not Meet
Stories in this episode: - Sleepwalking Horror, by Callie (0:50) - It's Okay, Sweetie, by Anna (9:29) - My Sister Dated a Murderer, by Sara (16:08) - The Chef That Made My Life Hell, by Anon (22:53) - My Crazy Stalker Roommate, by Michaela (37:48) Extended Patreon Content: - Boyf ... Show More
44m 37s
Aug 2025
Fan Favorite | Blood Feast
Following the epic crossover between MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries and Redacted: Declassified Mysteries, hosted by Luke Lamana, we’re revisiting some of our favorite episodes where the line between medical mystery and dark conspiracy becomes blurred.One night in 1944, over 300 pat ... Show More
24m 59s
Jan 2023
Haunted Mansion in Cape May – Ep. 57
Stories in this episode:- Haunted Mansion in Cape May, by Maggie- Nightmare Nobody, by Jane- Calming Presence, by Archie- Strange Things That Have Happened in My House, by MorganSubmissions: stories@oddtrails.comListen ad-free and support the show by heading over to our Patreon! ... Show More
48m 13s