logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2024
39m 53s

0615 | & Nancy

Studio BOTH/AND
About this episode
As the investigation into Marble Arvidson's disappearance heats up, it takes Josh and the team to a second nearby disappearance with some overwhelming connections to Keyes. And a theory the team considered several years ago, rears its very ugly head.

This episode was written, researched, edited, and produced by Josh Hallmark. 
With additional research assistance by: Jordan Taylor, Shana Wilensky, and Michelle Tooker.  
 
Resources included:
https://www.boston.com/uncategorized/noprimarytagmatch/2011/10/19/police-search-for-missing-shelburne-woman/
https://digital.nepr.net/news/2016/08/29/hurricane-irene-its-been-five-years-since-shelburne-falls-building-sailed-away/
https://www.wwlp.com/news/hurricane-irene-remembered-in-franklin-county-five-years-later/

This is a Studio BOTH/AND production: 
www.truecrimebullshit.com / bothand.fyi  
For an ad-free experience: www.patreon.com/studiobothand  

Music by: William Hellfire, La Bon, Yehezkel Rez, Dan Mayo, and Parhelion. 
Featured song by: The National  

Patreon producers: Amelia Hancock, Amy Basil, Annemarie Cash, Annette L, Asch Fish, Becky C, Benjamin Cioppa-Fong, Casey Jensen-Richardson, Christina Sisson, Dale Akstin, Drew Vipond, Heather Horton-Whedon, Jillian Natale, Kathleen Studer, Kendall C, Lana Halladay, Lauren F, Lynnlie Tuschoff, Manolis Boukolus, Nicole and Dennis Henry, Nicole Guzman, Pink, SC, Shelly Brewer, Sherri D, Trista, Tuesdi Woodworth, Zack Ignatowicz Warren, Beth McNally, John Comrie, Jordan M, Jordan Taylor, Michael Beers, Sara Cee, Shawna Hardin, Spooky Express, and Lydia Fiedler.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-bullsh--3588169/support.
Up next
Jul 3
A New Lead in the Brianna Maitland Case (with Crawlspace Media)
Last week, Tim, Lance, Greg, and Lou announced a new lead in the Brianna Maitland case. So, Josh sat down to get the new information, discuss its potential implications, and see how it's moving the investigation into Brianna's disappearance forward.Become a supporter of this podc ... Show More
24m 14s
Jun 27
The Holly Bobo Disappearance: An Interview with Eva Pilgrim
This past April, Josh sat down with Eva Pilgrim, the co-anchor of GMA3 and ABC’s senior national correspondent, to discuss her new investigative podcast What Happened to Holly Bobo. Listeners may recall that Holly Bobo’s name and image were found on Israel Keyes’s computer, as on ... Show More
44m 33s
Jun 19
Potential Keyes Victims: The Northeast
As we prepare for season 7 of our investigation into Israel Keyes, we look back at some of the potential victims we've covered throughout the series and provide case updates and classification updates.This episode covers the following cases:• Kellisue Ackernecht • Jack Coloney • ... Show More
30m 24s
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2024
The Case of the Two Nancy Drews
The biggest Nancy Drew mystery isn’t hidden in the plots of the books. It’s right there on the cover. If “Carolyn Keene” is a pseudonym, who really wrote the series? For 50 years, two women laid claim to that title. And in 1980, with help from an amateur detective, the truth came ... Show More
55m 16s
Apr 13
S22 Ep18: NoSleep Podcast S22E18
It's Episode 18 of Season 22. The voices are calling with tales of teenage terrors. "Hairpuller" written by Gloomara (Story starts around 00:03:15) TRIGGER WARNING! Produced by: Phil Michalski Cast: Narrator - Mike DelGaudio, Bridget - Mary Murphy, Patricia - Danielle McRae, Paul ... Show More
1h 9m
Apr 6
S22 Ep17: NoSleep Podcast S22E17
It's Episode 17 of Season 22. The voices are calling with tales about reaping grimly. "First Heat" written by B.A. Ries (Story starts around 00:03:35) TRIGGER WARNING! Produced by: Claudius Moore Cast: Peter - Dan Zappulla, Goggles - Graham Rowat, Roger - Jeff Clement, Anthony - ... Show More
1h 8m
May 2020
Shapearl
Having taken her investigation as far as she can, Shapearl moves on to an even bigger fight: making sure this never happens to anyone else’s child. She travels to Brazil to speak at a summit of mothers of murdered children and works to honor Courtney’s legacy and advocate for pol ... Show More
28m 51s
Mar 2025
Art as a Nuanced Endeavor (Listen Again)
This episode (aka "Napa Act 1") was recorded live in 2022 at the Blue Note Jazz Festival. “Art is the perfect place to talk it out–in fact, maybe the last place.” The crew reflects on how nuance and purpose is lost in a culture that favors judgment over debate. Executive Produced ... Show More
23m 29s
Oct 2024
S21 Ep23: NoSleep Podcast S21E23
It's Episode 23 of Season 21. Ride the Sleepless Express perilous property. "Open House" written by Steve Hudgins (Story starts around 00:03:05) TRIGGER WARNING! Produced by: Phil Michalski Cast: Narrator - David Cummings, Jean - Erin Lillis, Harriet Loomis - Nichole Goodnight, B ... Show More
1h 10m
Jun 19
Number's Lie
“Your presence in this department is a little unusual, Miss Jacob, but that's why you're here. We expected you to experience unusual side effects. You're in unexplored territory…”Content Warnings: Mentions of the extinction of the human race, and implied use of memory-altering dr ... Show More
23m 47s
Mar 2025
S22 Ep12: NoSleep Podcast S22E12
It's Episode 12 of Season 22. The voices are calling with tales of freaky fiends. "Playing Thunderstorm Sounds" written by Matt Scott (Story starts around 00:03:55) Produced by: Claudius Moore Cast: Narrator - David Cummings, Rory - Jeff Clement, Thing - Elie Hirschman, Virtual A ... Show More
1h 24m
Jan 2024
S20 Ep16: NoSleep Podcast S20E16
It’s Episode 16 of Season 20. Come join us around the campfire with tales that will leave you wanting s’more! “Revelation Radio” written by Seth Augenstein (Story starts around 00:02:40) Produced by: Jeff Clement Cast: Narrator – Erin Lillis, CEO Bob Lessman – David Cummings “Bab ... Show More
1h 8m
Mar 2025
S22 Ep13: NoSleep Podcast S22E13
It's Episode 13 of Season 22. The voices are calling with tales of futuristic fears. "The AI" written by MN Wiggins (Story starts around 00:03:30) Produced by: Phil Michalski Cast: Sara – Erin Lillis, Bobbie – Erika Sanderson, Nancy – Nikolle Doolin, Salesman – Reagen Tacker, Rec ... Show More
1h 14m